My friend’s 30-something nephew told us about the seven weddings he attended around the country over the past several months. He’d also been to his share of couples’ showers. “I guess the gender reveal parties are up next,” he groaned. Ugh, I thought. I first learned about these new pre-birth parties a few years ago and thought it was a joke. The recent season of the Grace and Frankie web TV series featured a gender reveal party. And now the term was apparently rolling off the tongues of 30-somethings.
I did a Google search when I got home and sure enough—gender reveal parties have gone mainstream. The first image was of Party City’s “Girl or Boy Gender Reveal Party Kit for 16.” Another showed an Etsy shop’s custom pink or blue-filled baseballs or golf ball “bombs” for the big “reveal.”
For the unfamiliar, expectant parents get their friends and family together for a party where the gender of their baby is “revealed.” Sometimes even the parents don’t know beforehand. So the ultrasound tech writes down the sex of the baby and seals it in an envelope. A bakery then makes either a pink or blue-centered cake for the party. (By the way, just for background, it wasn’t until the 1940s that the generally accepted rule of pink for boys and blue for girls was switched up. That’s when children’s clothing manufacturers and retailers arbitrarily decided to reverse gender-specific colors in their advertising.)
Sex vs. gender.
The reason these gender reveal parties annoy me so much is that all an ultrasound reveals is a baby’s physical anatomy. Yep, in front of family and friends, a baby’s gender is assigned based on their body parts. But it’s really the child’s sex that’s being assigned. From my point of view, the better name for gender reveal parties would be external genitalia reveal parties.
When I told my 27-year-old kid Harry about the gender reveal party trend, their response was a resounding, “Ewwww.” Harry identifies as nonbinary. That means Harry’s gender identity is neither male/female nor man/woman. Harry is simply a unique, individual human. What my pregnancy ultrasound revealed didn’t matter. Harry has never fit society’s limiting stereotyped traits, characteristics or behaviors for a kid assigned male at birth.
All on the same gender page.
A rich new vocabulary has developed in our shifting landscape of beliefs about gender. So I want to step back a bit and clarify a few terms. Even some of the more common ones can be confusing. I was clueless the first time I saw the words “gender identity” in print. So I wouldn’t have been able to explain the difference between gender identity and sexual orientation then either. To me, sex and gender were interchangeable, and just one of two boxes to check on a driver’s license application. Speaking of, amid an expanded understanding about gender, California now recognizes a third gender on state ID document.
I’m sure there will be more terms in the future, beyond the 60 or so gender identifiers Facebook offers. In fact college kids are probably coming up with new identifiers that no one else is aware of yet. But for now, here’s a quick primer of general terms.
The sex and gender basics.
Sex refers to one’s physical anatomy, specifically one’s genitalia. Secondarily, it also includes reproductive organs and genetics.
Sex Assigned at Birth is the assignment of people as male, female, or intersex based on their physical anatomy at birth.
Gender typically refers to socially constructed roles, behaviors and norms that a given society deems appropriate for men and women. Those same social constructs shape definitions of “masculine” or “feminine” too.
Gender Identity is one’s own personal, inner sense of being a man or a woman (or boy or girl), neither (like my kid Harry) or both. For transgender people, their internal gender identity and their sex assigned at birth are not the same.
Gender Expression/Presentation is the way someone expresses or presents their gender identity through clothing, hairstyle, makeup, or mannerisms.
Sexual Orientation refers to someone’s romantic, physical or emotional attraction to another person. It is completely separate from gender identity.
As for gender reveal parties, gender is not about body parts. A pregnancy ultrasound reveals a baby’s assigned sex. It’s not until babies start talking and experience their culture’s gender expectations that they’ll be able to tell you who they know themselves to be. For that, all we have to do is listen. In anticipation of future conversations — with kids or adults — check out the fabulous Gender Unicorn illustration below. In the meantime, just invite your friends over for a nice brunch. Cake optional.
IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE:
“For every girl who…there’s a boy who”
“Talking to children about gender expression isn’t always easy.”
My ultrasound didn’t reveal much, but my doctor said he was pretty sure I was having a girl. Goodness, a mini-Renee. 😳 Such a thrill when Tanner was born with a penis. I realize technology has improved since my pregnancy, but I’m with you, Julie. Just not feeling these parties. Donate some money to a worthy cause instead.
Hehehe…Yes, I can imagine a mini-Renee. What double hell-raising fun that would bring! But I know Tanner was and is quite the gift.❤️ I had the same thoughts as you about the money spent on these parties… Think how much good would come from all those donations! Hugs, Julie xo
Well Julie, once again you set me to thinking. I had to cringe when I read “external genitalia reveal” but in reality that nails it. I also had to chuckle thinking how my own would have gone if they had ultrasound when I was as in hydro. It would have been an “I’m not sure” party. And, of course, when the doctors guessed, they forever altered my life, and not for the better. But I also thought back to you when my children had their in office gender reveal, and I confess I had a initial preference though it made little difference beyond that initial glimpse. I just knew more about what girls were and I had tons of hopes for mother-daughter moments though at the time I had to play father. I did fine with my son and would forever be grateful for him. My daughters did come more naturally for me, but my love was unconditional regardless of what they were and how they identified. When my youngest daughter veered towards male in her adolescence I was confused myself despite my own history and perhaps disappointed that we wouldn’t be dress shopping or buying makeup, but that was my problem not hers. She later clarified her identity as middle of the road, but happy as a young woman. I was with her through all of the questioning and was certainly qualified to relate to that. I tend to believe we’d all be better parents if we too had gender questions of our own. I was qualified in that aspect but still dabbled in dreaming about a never-to-be fictional child. In the terms end, it is little more than storybook daydreams and we should simplify shrug our shoulders 🤷♀️ and get the awe of the miracle we get to play a part time in. 💕
You’re such a beautiful writer, Janelle. Thanks so much for sharing your experiences, along with your hopes and dreams. I think all parents experience a bit of that when expecting and beyond. Your kids are lucky to have you. And I fell so fortunate to know you. Big love, Julie xo
Dear Cousin,
Let’s have a party for celebration of all genders and celebration of removal of stereotypes and drawn lines.. I’ll bring the multi-colored,flavored and textured vodka cake and everyone else can bring some love and acceptance. It starts with gentle self-acceptance and can blossom from there. If all this old thinking can be emptied from hearts and brains, think of what wondrous opportunities can fill those spaces! What time is the party and is it at your house?
Of course, you would have fantastic party ideas! We’ll celebrate all our individual fabulousness and all the positivity that comes with love and acceptance. I’ll make the cake, Amber can perform, and you can tell stories of the history of drag in Russia. 🙂 xo
What a great explanation of the expressions used currently. Very clarifying! Thanks! Kat
Thank you for letting me know this was helpful, Kat. I’m learning more all the time, too! Jxo
Very nice post, luckily more people are becoming open minded these days, blogs like this help to spread the good word so keep up the good work!
Thanks for the kind words, Adam. I really appreciate your outlook! Julie xo
Julie, thanks! And thanks for sharing your great posts every week!
Thank you for taking the time to comment! xo