- Dec 2022
- Nov 2022
- Oct 2022
- Sep 2022
- Aug 2022
- Jul 2022
- Jun 2022
- May 2022
- Apr 2022
- Mar 2022
- Feb 2022
- Jan 2022
- Jan 2022
- Shareable mantras for every New Year.
This past weekend, deconstructing Christmas became absolutely necessary. More pine needles lay under my tree than remained on the branches. And Saturday was the last day of the Sanitation Dept’s scheduled tree pick-up. All I had to do was unstring the mini-lights, vacuum up the needles, and pack up three new ornaments, gifts from my sister and two friends who know my passions. And also know that I usually have a decked-out tree. But I ran out of time for full-on tree decorations. As it turns out, those sparkly ornaments prompted my mantras for the New Year. I realized the three ornaments -- all pictured here -- told a holiday and New Year's short story of love, truth, and self-determination. I share the story with you now as my inspiring, supportive mantras for 2022 and beyond.
Love is love.
We should all be lucky enough to find it. And allowed to find it.Transgender people exist.
Like every human, trans and nonbinary people of all colors, ages, and abilities deserve respect, kindness, and equality.Be proud of your shine.
Peacocks are known for their splendor and poise. They show their true colors without needing anyone’s permission. We must polish our own and then look for the radiance of others. Are you with me? IF YOU LIKED THIS POST, YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Cheers to a gay and exciting New Year!" "Gender-neutral pronouns show respect."January 17, 2022
- Oct 2021
- Gender-neutral pronouns show respect. #PronounsDay
“Harry, can we talk about pronouns for minute?” I asked my 31-year-old millennial kid recently. “Is this your annual check-in, Mom?” I smiled. “Well, yes, I guess it is.” I know using someone’s correct pronouns shows respect. So, I wanted to stay on top of Harry’s pronoun usage. I first asked Harry about gender pronouns eight years ago. At that time, Harry was listed on Facebook as my daughter, with she/her pronouns. Soon after, Facebook added the gender-neutral pronoun “they.” And Harry simply became my child. The term nonbinary didn’t exist in relation to gender in 2013. But Harry hadn’t fit inside the box of specifically “he” or specifically “she” since toddlerhood. Harry chose “they” on Facebook because it was the only gender-neutral option at the time. Nowadays, friends, family, and clients interchange all pronouns when referring to Harry. And I do the same. But a recent bio blurb Harry wrote used only “they.” “Should I be using only “they” for you exclusively?” “Mom, I just don’t care,” Harry told me, as they have many times. “How people refer to me has no bearing on how I feel about myself.” But let me assure you that a lot of people do care. Their personal pronouns are just that – personal. They align with our gender identity. Using a person’s correct pronouns shows respect. Misgendering someone by using incorrect pronouns is a sign of disrespect.
Who Doesn’t Want to Be Respected?
If you think using correct pronouns doesn’t apply to you, please think again.- Generation Z, those aged 18-24, will soon surpass millennials in the workforce. And one in six Gen Zers knows someone who uses they/them pronouns.
- Two percent of the world’s population has red hair. At least two percent is transgender, nonbinary or gender nonconforming.
Make safe spaces.
Maybe you’re confused or unsure about using gender-neutral pronouns. Maybe the whole subject intimidates you. I understand. I’ve been there. But all it takes is a little effort and practice. Share your pronouns with others in introductions. Include your pronouns to your email sign-off. Or add your pronouns next to your name in a virtual meeting. Because when you do you are making space for everyone to be themselves. Every person’s gender is always valid. Even if you don’t understand it. In other words, using a person’s correct pronouns shows respect. Today, on International Pronouns Day and every day. “On International Pronouns Day, ‘they’ is here to stay!” “They/they pronouns have come between my child and me.” “Video Vriday: Bullying Prevention Month and gender-neutral pronouns redux.”October 20, 2021
- May 2021
- The commonalities of leadership and parenting.
I loved getting the chance to talk about the commonalities of leadership and parenting. Many thanks to Out Leadership's Fabrice Houdart, managing director of global equality initiatives, for interviewing me this week. We talked about generational shifts taking place in the workplace. And I shared a few thoughts on how achievable it is for leaders to become more empathetic and inclusive. And the last segment is for any LGBTQ+ adult who struggles with a non-accepting mom on Mother's Day. The full interview follows. For Mother’s Day, our very own Fabrice Houdart interviewed Super-Mom Julie Tarney, author of My Son Wears Heels, who wrote so eloquently about her journey parenting a gender nonconforming child from toddler to adulthood and since then has been training thousands of executives on how to challenge their own misconceptions about gender identity and gender expression.
Julie, as a baby boomer businesswoman and parent of a nonbinary millennial, do you have any thoughts on what effect generational shifts happening in the workforce might have on corporate initiatives for LGBTQ+ inclusion?
I think the generational shifts we’re seeing in the workforce make LGBTQ+ inclusion even more of an imperative for businesses. Here’s why. More than 1 in 3 of the U.S. labor force, about 35%, are millennials, making them the largest generation in the workforce. By 2025, millennials are expected to make up 75% of the global workforce, with many already in managerial positions. Not far behind are members of Generation Z, those born after 1997. By 2028, these two generations will make up 58 percent of the workforce.1 in 6 Gen Z adults identify as LGBT.
Now here’s what’s really interesting. The February Gallup poll found that 1 in 6 Gen Z adults identify as LGBT. That’s a big demographic shift. They are also more likely than other generations to know someone using gender-neutral pronouns and to say forms should offer gender options other than “man” or “woman.” And in a 2017 Harris poll, 20% of millennials identified as something other than strictly straight and cisgender, compared to 7% of boomers. The future is changing fast and based on studies and trends, people will be more open about identifying as nonbinary. And both millennials and Generation Z – our future leaders – think society is not accepting enough of those individuals. In fact numerous studies (updated 2024) have found GenZers said were more likely to stay with organizations they perceived as having a diverse and inclusive workforce. So, to attract, engage and retain the newest members of the workforce, there must be dedicated focus on a corporate culture of inclusion and belonging. We already know that the more a company can reflect society and its diverse representation the better it will perform. So, to keep up, companies need to hire a workforce that reflects the population. That is not new news. Companies need to embrace diversity, equity and inclusion in the same way they embrace all their business goals. Some leaders struggle, because there’s a learning curve, but everyone has a responsibility to do this work. And despite generational differences and shifts, the most important thing is to treat everyone as a valued individual.You talk to business executives, particularly in companies that are at the beginning of their D&I journey. What do you think moms can teach CEOs?
That’s such a wonderful question, Fabrice, because I think leadership and parenting are very similar in that you are creating a path for others’ success. And honestly, as a new mom I often drew on my leadership skills to inform my parenting in challenging situations. For example, when my child Harry was two years old, he asked me how I knew he was a boy. After a brief anatomy lesson – that now makes me cringe when I think about it – Harry informed me, “Well, inside my head I’m a girl.” When I wasn’t sure how to reply, I defaulted to a basic principle of leadership: Maintain the self-confidence and self-esteem of others. I told him I thought it was great he knew that about himself. That was the right answer, because he smiled as wide as a coat hanger. I still had no idea at the time what his statement meant, but he felt good about himself.CEOs should want happy employees.
All moms ever want is for their children to be happy, kids who feel protected, safe, and valued for just being themselves. CEOs should want happy employees – those who are engaged, committed to vision and mission, and feel safe enough in their job to contribute meaningfully to the success of their organization. In another commonality between leadership and parenting, I think moms can teach CEOs to remember the soft skills, like empathy for one. Leaders can draw on the same empathy they have for their family members. And ideally, when it comes to LGBTQ+ inclusion, they can empathize with how much work it can be just to show up at your job when you are part of a marginalized community. Mothers also give their children a strong sense of belonging. They need that from us, as much as employees do from a company’s leadership. I believe moms can remind CEOs that they need to think about how someone feels in the culture they are responsible for creating or re-creating. Creating a company culture of belonging requires a focus on other core values, like trust, encouragement, two-way communication, validation, and a positive attitude. Lastly, just as moms don’t know everything, leaders don’t know everything either. Both must remain curious, ask questions, listen carefully and commit to being life-long learners. You wrote beautifully about your own journey as a mother, what made a difference for you? Two things made a difference for me on the gender journey I took with my child. First, it was realizing what was at stake for me. I didn’t have good role models for parenting, so I was determined to be a good mother. I wanted my child to have unconditional parental love, and I wanted to encourage and support him in every way possible. Secondly, and this relates back to your previous question, I had much to learn about parenting a child who was different from any child I’d ever known. And a lot of that learning required unlearning.I also learned to examine my own double standards.
I was confused, worried and fearful after Harry’s “inside my head I’m a girl” declaration. And I had so many questions! Surely, I thought, I had to set some limits to his self-expression – or did I? Would he be bullied? What kind of guidance would he need? Could I do the right thing? And what was the right thing? The internet was no help because in 1992 there was no internet. There weren’t support groups, chat rooms or online resources. And the language was very inadequate then. There were no terms like gender nonconforming, gender expansive, gender fluid or nonbinary. What did exist where Harry grew up in Milwaukee, Wisconsin was a lot of misinformation, stereotyping and judgement. If you were the mom of a feminine boy, it meant you were doing something wrong to your child. So, Harry became my most enlightened teacher. As a parent, I learned to rely on my instincts, I listened carefully and kept an open mind. I decided that as long as Harry was happy, I’d let them lead the way. By the way, Harry now interchanges all of the gender pronouns. At the same time, I learned to think differently about society’s expectations that boys and girls fit neatly inside a gender box that was either pink or blue. I came to understand that there’s more than one way to be a boy or a girl, or a man or a woman. I also learned to examine my own double standards. That was especially true at Halloween. I made some of my biggest parenting mistakes over Halloween costumes. Like not getting Harry the Pink Power Ranger costume they really wanted. I had always wanted Harry to fit it. I thought he would be safer that way. Harry taught me in middle school that fitting in doesn’t mean being like everyone else – it means being accepted for who you are. Change is happening all over the world on the issues, but for many coming out to their family, within their community, workplace or place of worship remains a source of suffering, which path forward do you see? There’s been an enormous amount of progress on the issues, yes, and of course backlash as well, but the progress has been significant. Yet to be discriminated against, harassed or victimized for your gender identity or loving who you love is stressful and exhausting. And that has over-reach as you say in all social situations. I believe the path forward must start at the top. And in a country’s case, that’s the legislative branch of government. In the U.S. passage of the Equality Act is a must. Other countries must require similar laws that provide LGBTQ+ people equal protection under the law in all areas – housing, education, healthcare, the workplace.While LGBTQ+, gender nonconforming and nonbinary visibility is at an all-time high, allies must also be visible.
Changing the world requires action, and each of us can drive continued change for fairness and equality and help eliminate suffering. We can write to government officials. We can attend school board meetings. At the very least sign a petition. And paying attention to equality legislation in the works and how it might affect the people you know can help you understand what friends, family and colleagues might be going through. While LGBTQ+, gender nonconforming and nonbinary visibility is at an all-time high, allies must also be visible. I think the path forward widens when we’re all forging it together. Sunday is Mother’s Day, for many LGBTQ+ people there is a long road to reconciliation with their family, do you have advice to the many LGBTQ+ kids who will reach out Sunday to mothers they resent? Yes, as hard as it is to believe, not every mom accepts and celebrates her LGBTQ+ child exactly as they are. Parents who aren’t supportive or who are openly homophobic or transphobic understandably trigger lots of hurt feelings and unspoken tensions. I will say you don’t have to tolerate that lack of acceptance or pretend it’s not eating you up inside. While you can’t pick your biological family, you can choose how you interact with them. You can set your own boundaries of what you will or will not do.Know your value, trust yourself and your feelings.
What’s really important to tap into on Mother’s Day or any day is your own personal power. Choose how you spend Mother’s Day based on what will give you the strongest feelings of joy. Surround yourself with your chosen family or friends who care about you and respect you, whatever your differences. Most of all, know your value, trust yourself and your feelings. Believe in yourself always. You are perfect. I must speak also to the unaccepting moms. And dads, too, because Father’s Day is coming up soon. Unconditional love and support have no expiration date. Maybe you have rejected your child because of who they are. Or who they love. But please know that it is never too late to have a close relationship with your child, no matter their age. Admit your mistakes, acknowledge what you don’t know. Your beliefs were influenced by others, so now lead with your heart. We can always demonstrate in the present moment what it means to cherish our children. Even if we previously didn’t have the resources to do it. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST, YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "5 Mother's Day Maxims from a gender creative parent." "No matter what their age or gender expression, kids need to hear this." "When your child comes out to you."May 7, 2021
- Mar 2021
- Trans allies must also be visible on Transgender Day of Visi ...
[caption id="attachment_8916" align="aligncenter" width="640"] My kid could be fired in 21 states just for being who they are.[/caption] Transgender Day of Visibility (TDOV) honors and celebrates the lives of transgender and nonbinary people. They are our colleagues, clients, friends, neighbors and family. TDOV helps raise awareness of how much work still needs to be done for trans and nonbinary folks to live safely and thrive, free from bias, discrimination and acts of violence. This is where we come in. Trans allies like me must also be visible on Transgender Day of Visibility – and every day – to help create welcoming, respectful and trans-inclusive spaces.
Not sure how to be a trans ally?
Trans and nonbinary allies help build more gender-inclusive workplaces, schools and homes. Maybe you’re not sure where to begin. Remember that “ally” is also a verb. So here are four way you can ally with the transgender and nonbinary communities.Be aware.
Transgender and nonbinary people in numerous states face multiple barriers in workplaces, housing, education and healthcare. I’m distressed whenever I think my adult child could be fired in 21 states because of who they are. Of the 192 ant-LGBTQ bills being considered in state legislatures right now, 93 directly target transgender people. And anti-trans bills are on the desks of governors in four states. Being aware of the issues can help you understand what your co-workers and friends might be going through right now. Allies can be supportive by knowing legislation in the works.Respect pronouns.
Try using “they” more often as a singular pronoun. My guess is you’ve probably already used “they-them-their” pronouns in the singular. For example, pre-pandemic, if you found a cell phone on the conference table after a meeting, you’d say, “Someone left their cell phone here.” Also, think about renaming yourself in your next Zoom meeting to include your pronouns after your name. That simple gesture lets trans and nonbinary people know you see and respect them.Do your own research.
Trans and nonbinary people are not responsible for your education. They should not have to explain themselves to you. Unsure of the difference between gender identity and sexual orientation? Need clarification on what nonbinary means? Take a quick minute to look it up. It Gets Better has a fantastic glossary. And please share what you learn with friends and family. Get involved. Changing the world requires action. Take another quick minute to call elected officials. You may not know that you don’t have to live in a state to call its governor and voice your opposition to anti-trans legislation that’s targeting vulnerable transgender kids. The most extreme anti-trans bill in the country is just one signature away from becoming law in Arkansas. Here’s a link from the ACLU on how to contact Arkansas Gov. Hutchinson and tell him to end attacks on trans youth by vetoing HB 1570. While transgender visibility is at an all-time high right now, trans allies must also be visible every day. Together we absolutely can make a difference. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST, YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "A transgender Air Force?" "We must rise up for transgender children." "My new role model is an 11-year-old transgender girl."March 31, 2021
- Oct 2020
- On International Pronouns Day, 'they' is here to stay!
There’s a chance you haven’t yet heard about International Pronouns Day. The observance, which occurs on the third Wednesday in October, began three years ago to encourage widespread respect, sharing and education about personal pronouns. The singular "they" pronoun probably sparks curiosity. To some, it creates confusion. Whatever your take, singular "they" is here to stay.
Word of the Year.
In December 2019 the folks at Merriam-Webster announced the pronoun "they" as the Word of the Year. Their choice was data-driven: searches for "they" had increased 313% over the previous year. Many of those searches resulted from shifts in the way "they" is used. Singular “they” has been around for over 600 years. And you’ve probably used it yourself before all the attention. “Everyone wants a vacation, don’t they?” “Someone left their cell phone on the conference table.” In more recent years, the singular "they" pronoun also refers to someone whose gender identity is nonbinary. That is, an individual who doesn’t fall into one of the two binary categories of male or female. Merriam-Webster added that new sense of "they" to their dictionary in September 2019 this way: used to refer to a single person whole gender identity is nonbinary. That same month singer Sam Smith announced their pronouns as they/them. Earlier in 2019, Rep. Pramila Jayapal told the House Judiciary Committee in a hearing on the Equality Act that her gender nonconforming child uses "they."Some people are ‘they.’
It’s now commonplace to see a person’s gender pronouns in their email signatures, social media bios and video conference displays. This is important, because everyone has the right to be addressed by the name and pronouns that correspond to their gender identity, including the use of nonbinary pronouns. Trans, nonbinary and gender nonconforming people, especially those whose gender is or is perceived to be outside of the man/woman binary are sometimes harassed and treated with hostility. This is often demonstrated by the intentional or repeated use of the wrong pronouns. Here are some things you can do to be more trans- and nonbinary-inclusive.Respect pronouns.
You can’t tell someone’s pronouns by just looking at them. Default to using someone’s name, if possible, to avoid mis-gendering. You can always take the first step by introducing yourself and your pronouns at the same time. Know that not making assumptions gives people space.Be inclusive in group settings.
Start your online meetings by asking everyone to introduce themselves and state their pronouns. It’s common practice in college classrooms.Practice.
Practice using the singular they pronoun more often. The more you do it, the easier it will be to remember. And your pronouns to your email signature and your name display when in video meetings or get-togethers.Be sincere.
Mistakes are common when re-learning habits of speech. If you do screw up, you can correct yourself and move on in the conversation. If you realize it later, or someone else points it out to you afterwards, you can apologize by saying something like, “I’m so sorry I didn’t use the correct pronoun for you. I’ll do better next time.” Use of the singular they pronoun is part of the larger work of creating and sustaining inclusive and supportive communities for everyone. I know you can do it. Happy International Pronouns Day! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST, YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: ‘He, Zie or They: Gender pronouns are personal. ‘They/them pronouns have come between my child and me.’ "What my son taught me about gender identity."October 21, 2020
- National Coming Out Day is Sunday. Are you ready to support ...
This Sunday is National Coming Out Day, the LGBTQ+ holiday that celebrates lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, intersex, nonbinary and gender-nonconforming people for being exactly who they are. And as the name implies, the day encourages LGBTQ+ folks to share their identities for the awareness and visibility required in the movement for full equality. Whether or not someone comes out on National Coming Out Day, the holiday recognizes the sometimes-difficult journey of self-discovery and the courage it takes to share their full identity with family, friends, co-workers or the world.
Why ‘courage’ is an operative word.
To say “coming out” takes courage is based on facts that the LGBTQ+ community is well aware of, for both youth at home and adults in the workplace. According to the Human Rights Campaign’s (HRC) 2018 LGBTQ Youth Report:- 78% of youth not out to their parents as LGBTQ hear their families make negative comments about LGBTQ people.
- 48% of LGBTQ youth out to their parents say their families make them feel bad for being LGBTQ.
- Only 24% of LGBTQ youth can “definitely” be themselves as an LGBTQ person at home.
- One fifth (20%) of LGBTQ Americans have experienced discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity when applying for jobs. (Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, 2017)
- 53% of LGBTQ employees heard lesbian and gay jokes, 37% heard bisexual jokes and 41% heard transgender jokes in 2018. (HRC)
- Nearly two thirds (59%) of non-LGBTQ employees believe it is “unprofessional” to discuss sexual orientation or gender identity in the workplace. (HRC, 2018)
- Even in inclusive workplace environments, LGBTQ individuals still see a risk of their relationship with their manager, team member or clients changing for the worse. (Catalyst Research)
Be ready to support someone who comes out to you.
People of all sexual orientations, gender identities and gender expressions need safe spaces to live their truth and be comfortable sharing it. That means feeling unconditional love and acceptance at home. At work, LGBTQ folks need the respect, support and inclusiveness of the people around them. Here’s what you can do:- Someone comes out to you because they trust you. Thank them for trusting you enough to share their true self with you. Ask how you can support them.
- Educate yourself. If you hear a new term or need a quick refresher on the difference between sexual orientation and gender identity, your search engine is just a click away.
October 9, 2020
- Feb 2020
- A sassy Valentine and my love for Mister Rogers.
No glitter, plastic gems or sparkly rhinestones decorated the valentine I gave my kid Harry this year. I’m usually drawn to cards with the same items Harry uses for the beat face of his alter-ego drag persona, Amber Alert. But a shiny red embossed word “Sassy” on the card rack caught my eye instead. Underneath the adjective, read its definition: lively, bold and full of spirit. Add in self-assured and stylish, and you’ve got quintessential Harry and Amber. Our Valentine dinner convo turned to the Academy Awards’ Mister Rogers opening number by another sassy, queer entertainer, Janelle Monáe. Then I revealed to Harry my love for Mister Rogers.
I didn’t like Mister Rogers.
When Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood debuted in 1968 I was in high school. I had no reason to care about children’s television. Instead, I worried about friends being drafted to fight in Vietnam. But my gal pal Wendy was born in 1968 and grew up watching Mister Rogers. And it was the documentary Won’t You Be My Neighbor that she picked for us to see when it premiered in 2018. “You really want to see a movie about Mr. Rogers?” I asked her. “He was a big part of my childhood,” she told me. “I used to watch Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood every day. And at the end of every show, I’d go to the kitchen and tell my mom it was time to say goodbye to Mr. Rogers.” I’d always thought of Mister Rogers as just an old fuddy-duddy with a scraggly tiger puppet. I confessed I’d never watched a single episode. But I did remember laughing at Eddie Murphy’s parody of Mister Rogers on SNL in the early ‘80s.A singular vision of love and kindness.
Before I watched the documentary with Wendy, I never imagined the depth of the show. I didn’t realize how many issues he took on or knew of his background in children’s education. I was so moved by Mister Rogers’ connection with kids that I went to see the movie again. I took a notebook with me. And another pack of tissues. I don’t know if I can convey the monumental impact Mister Rogers had on generations of kids, or why the adults, like Wendy, who grew up with him, revere him so. However, I did learn that on camera, he spoke as if only to an audience of one. And he strongly believed that a child’s feelings were just as powerful as an adult’s feelings. Here are a few Mister Rogers quotes from the documentary that imprinted on my heart: “Love is at the root of everything – all learning, all parenting, all relationships. Love or the lack of it.” At a congressional hearing on funding for public television: “One of the first things a child develops in a healthy family is trust. I give an expression of care each day to every child, to help him realize that he is unique, by saying you’ve made this day a special day by just you being you. There’s no person in the whole world just like you and I like you just the way you are.” “I don’t think anybody can grow unless he really is accepted exactly as he is.”Making a difference.
At dinner that night, I told Harry he’s my forever valentine. And while revealing my love for Mr. Rogers, I explained why the person I’d never met will always hold valuable real estate in my heart. I may very well be watching the Mister Rogers documentary again, only with Harry next time. And I’ll probably apologize for not encouraging him to watch the show when he was a child. We’re all capable of love. We all long for it and are worthy of it. Regardless of how we identify or what backgrounds or abilities we have. The list of our differences is endless. But we all want the same thing. Please remember love and kindness for family, friends, co-workers, in whatever neighborhood you live, work or play. As Mister Rogers would say, it’s such a good feeling. Photo of Amber Alert by Ben Boyles IF YOU LIKED THIS POST, YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The unlikely queer icon." "Married or single, every parent has a Valentine." "The look of everyday love."February 18, 2020
- Nov 2019
- Transgender awareness in schools.
The maleficent U.S Education Secretary Betsy DeVos kicked off the school year by visiting a private school that bans transgender students and teachers. At the same time, the New York City Department of Education (NYC DOE) implemented new Guidelines to Support Transgender and Gender Expansive Students for public school-based teachers and staff. While those two events are diametrically opposed, two other facts go hand in hand. Transgender students or students who are gender nonconforming exist. And like all kids, they have the right to attend school free of fear. So, it is undeniable that we need transgender awareness in schools. Every. Single. Day. As a PFLAG NYC Safe Schools Program presenter, I see firsthand – in classrooms and at professional development workshops – how necessary these new NYC DOE guidelines are.
The whys behind the need.
I've talked with trans and gender nonconforming children who aren't accepted by their families or who are bullied by classmates. I have met many teachers who are unclear what it means to be transgender, or who don’t know the difference between gender identity and sexual orientation. I've heard other Safe Schools Program speakers share how their young trans kids come home with wet pants because they’re afraid to use the bathroom that aligns with their gender identity. If that situation happens just once, that child is in crisis. And as a result, that family is in crisis. I lost many nights of sleep when Harry was bullied in middle school for his gender expression. And often, I couldn't concentrate at work. When your child isn’t affirmed at school, you default to panic and anxiety. Because if a student doesn’t feel safe, they can’t learn. Maybe that’s not your child. An underrepresented child at school isn’t going to show up on your radar until it’s part of your experience. But I guarantee it applies to one of your child’s classmates. If we want all children to feel safe in school, we need transgender awareness in schools.Guidelines are necessary.
The NYC DOE is familiar with the 2017 research that shows transgender and gender nonconforming youth (trans/GNC) are experiencing extremely hostile climates in U.S. schools. In a nutshell:- Nearly 84% of trans and 70% of GNC students were bullied because of their gender.
- Over 4 in 10 trans/GNC students faced gender-related discrimination at school.
- Almost half of trans/GNC students were required to use the incorrect bathroom.
The "musts".
The guidelines serve as a resource to further the understanding of gender identity, gender expression and sexuality in schools. And there are some important “musts”:- All staff and students must refer to students by chosen names and pronouns, and non-permanent records must reflect these.
- Students must be provided access to facilities consistent with their gender identity asserted at school.
- Students must participate in all school activities in accordance with their gender identity.
- Any staff member must immediately report student-on-student harassment, discrimination, bullying and/or intimidation.
November 19, 2019
- Oct 2019
- When your child comes out to you.
Let me assure you. The age at which your child comes out about their gender identity and/or sexuality can vary. And they may come out to you more than once. I speak from experience. My adult nonbinary kid Harry came out to me five times. The first time was at two years old, when he said, “Inside my head I’m a girl.” That was my 1992 introduction to gender identity, even though I’d never heard the term before. I felt confused, worried and fearful. I didn’t know what Harry’s toddler-truth would mean for them, or for me. As a result, I watched as Harry explored and played with gender throughout grade school. After that, Harry came out in high school as bisexual, and then gay. I understood sexuality, so that was easy. Later, in college, Harry told me he genderqueer and queer. I had a lot of questions about using the word queer comfortably! As my memoir went to print, Harry identified as nonbinary. That was another new word for me. There may be newness for you, too, about a child’s highly personal gender and sexuality journey. So, I want to share five things to know when your child comes out.
1. You will not be the first person your child comes out to.
It’s true. Your child may confide in a friend or sibling before sharing their gender identity or sexuality with you. But even before that, your child will have come out to themselves. They will have identified an inner sense of self, a feeling of who they truly are that doesn’t match up with established gender norms. Or they will have recognized what gender(s) they crush on or are romantically attracted to.2. When your child comes out to you, they are sure in that moment.
Self-discovery is a process. Gender identity and/or sexual orientation may evolve with your child’s development. But that is for them to tell you, not for you to project as a phase. They come out to you because they trust you. Reciprocate by trusting them to know themselves in the present moment. Thank them for sharing their true self with you. Assure them that you love them no matter what and will always be there for them. Stay open minded and continue to listen carefully.3. Your vocabulary will improve.
Your child may come out to you as pansexual, genderqueer, stemme or another identity or sexual orientation unfamiliar to you. Facebook used to offer 70 options for how people could identify. Now it’s simply customized. But the point is, there are bound to be terms you haven’t heard before. Your child will understand you wanting to understand them. It’s okay not to know everything and to ask for help with terminology. Then do some research on your own. There’s a wealth of information online. Support groups like PFLAG exist for you, too. And if it’s important to your child, then you’ll soon become comfortable with they/them/their as singular pronouns.4. You add "ally" to your job title.
As a parent, guardian or caregiver, you’ve held many titles. Chauffeur, cook, nurse, chief cheerleader, to name a few. For an LGBTQ+ kid, your role as ally becomes inextricably linked to the pillars of unconditional love, encouragement and support. They may need your help advocating for them at school, with government agencies, or with other family members and neighbors. Assure them they can count on you in any situation. And be ready to take on the world, if necessary.5. It’s not about you.
When your child comes out to you, it is all about them. Their truth, their self-esteem, their desire to be loved and accepted for who they are. You may wonder as I did, what it will mean for you. Will you be judged at work, by neighbors, at church? What will conservative family members say? Your child may internalize some of the same questions. And that becomes your focus: helping them feel safe and protected. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "4 things your LGBT child needs you to know. And do." "They/them pronouns have come between my child and me." "Does worrying about my gender nonconforming son make me a bad mom?"October 11, 2019
- Sep 2019
- I celebrate Sam Smith wearing heels!
Photos of singer-songwriter Sam Smith wearing heels publicly for the first time at the British GQ Awards in London Tuesday night uplifted me all week. When I first saw the photos posted on their Instagram account, my heart burst with rainbow, unicorn and red high heel emojis. And for the uninitiated, the photo above is not Sam Smith wearing heels. That’s a shot of my kid Harry, who also wears heels, taken in 2007 when he was a junior in high school.
Here’s the picture of Sam Smith’s red carpet moment. [caption id="attachment_8360" align="aligncenter" width="485"] Sam Smith in his "virgin heels."[/caption] Black patent leather Gucci heels aside, it was the 27-year-old, four-time Grammy winner’s text copy that gave me all the mom feels:“As I was walking to my front door I stopped and listened to my heels clonking against the floor. And I just thought ‘FUCK YES’!! There was a time where I thought I’d never ever ever be able to be myself like this in front of the industry or anyone. It feels so good and I just wanted to share that with you all.”
I sent big virtual hugs to Sam Smith for so openly sharing their feelings about the sense of freedom that comes with gender expression. And for saying how right it feels to be their true self.Sam Smith's gift.
While I’d watched Sam Smith’s big night at the Grammys in 2015, I wanted to know more about this young possibility model. So I did a little research. I learned of their love for feminine clothes growing up and how they wore full makeup to school. They came out in 2017 as genderqueer and as nonbinary in March of this year. Sam Smith’s Instagram post is a gift for all the genderqueer nonbinary kids, teens and twenty-somethings that have yet to feel okay expressing their gender identity. I hope LGBTQ+ kids everywhere will be inspired and empowered to freely just be themselves. And I hope the rest of us will cheer them on with full support. Fuck yes! [caption id="attachment_8369" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Harry and me at Barnes & Noble in Downtown Brooklyn, Sept. 6, 2016[/caption]My Son Wears Heels Memoir Turns 3!
On the heels of Sam Smith wearing heels, I’m reminded of another reason to revel and reflect. The University of Wisconsin Press published MY SON WEARS HEELS three years ago today. It was the labor of love I wrote to help families with LGBTQ+ kids of all ages. I wanted those moms, dads and caregivers to know they weren’t alone with their confusion, worry and fears. I knew that if I could encourage them to listen carefully, keep an open mind and love unconditionally, I would ultimately be helping their kids. These past three years now represent a whole new crop of toddlers. Some assigned male at birth prefer pink skirts, sparkly tops and their mom’s heels to stereotypical “boy clothes.” There are toddler girls who won’t wear dresses, like neckties and want a buzz cut. And guess what? Some of those gender nonconforming kids may not yet be able to articulate their identity. They may feel both male and female, neither boy nor girl, or clearly not the gender that appears on their birth certificate. And while they will learn that traditional society has rules about gender and gender expression, they need the space and support to evolve and discover themselves. [caption id="attachment_8366" align="aligncenter" width="413"] Harry the night he got his dress-up box.[/caption] Reading about Sam Smith’s childhood preferences reminded me of my parenting journey. And because Sam Smith and Harry are just two years apart, I can’t help but wonder how their mother felt. Did she want Sam to just fit in with other boys the way I wanted Harry to fit in? Did she fear being judged a "bad mom" for parenting a boy others deemed “too feminine”? Ideally Sam Smith’s mom let them lead the way as she followed their zigzagging footsteps.Keeping up.
I spent two decades behind a child who knew exactly who he was, even though the language for his identity didn't exist. There was no internet in the early nineties, and I hadn't learned the term “gender identity” yet. Later, when Harry wanted to wear heels to his high school graduation, I wasn’t even sure how to spell “stiletto.” But I assure you he did. In his first year of college, Harry informed me he was genderqueer and had to explain the term. While MY SON WEARS HEELS was being printed, Harry came out as nonbinary, a term I'd never heard before. The truth is, humans evolve as a species and as individuals. Parents, families, societies and language will just have to continue keeping up. My life with a son who wears heels led me to this: If you want the kids in your life to be happy, secure and self-confident, just let them be. Trust them to know themselves. And trust yourself enough to enjoy the journey with them. It will be better than any awards show. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "My son's eye for fashion." "My son was born a non-conformist." "Family, books and Barbie heads."September 6, 2019
- Jul 2019
- WorldPride 365
My kid Harry – aka drag artist Amber Alert – flies home tomorrow from Berlin, Germany. Amber performed Saturday night at Bushwig Berlin, the drag festival held during Christopher Street Day Berlin, one of the biggest LGBTQ gatherings in Europe. And I realized that exactly one month ago, five million people and I took to the streets of New York City. We marked the 50th anniversary of the uprising at the Stonewall Inn, celebrated WorldPride 2019 and joined the NYC Pride March or the inaugural Queer Liberation March. (I so wanted to be in two places at once!) In the weeks leading up to WorldPride, a number of my LGBTQ baby-boomer buddies and family spoke of memories over the last half-century. Remember that in 1969, the American Psychiatric Association considered being gay a mental disease. And being gay was a crime in every state but Illinois. One gay friend spoke of a bartender who told him point-blank in the seventies, “You’re not going to get served here, so leave.” Another close friend remains amazed at how far the Pride Movement has come. “Not only do we enjoy hours of coverage on television,” he said, “but people say Happy Pride in the same way they wish their friends and family a Happy Thanksgiving!" But he still remembers when the AIDS epidemic struck and people were afraid of gay people. “Most didn’t want to shake hands,” my dear friend told me. “A lot didn’t want to be in the same room with someone who was gay. The Studio 54 days, when everyone wanted to be us, were definitely over.” He lost nearly 200 friends during the AIDS crisis, and spent most of the 80s visiting them in the hospital. Yes, there’s been progress. If you have health care, AIDS is no longer a death sentence. Marriage equality is the law of the land. There are federal hate crime protections. And it started in the most impactful way when LGBTQ people, led mostly by trans women of color, decided to take a stand against police brutality and violence at a gay bar on Christopher Street. But we have long way to go. You can still be fired today in 28 states based on your sexual orientation, gender identity or gender expression. Violence against the trans community, especially black trans women, is out of control. The current Republican adiminstration has launched more that 100 attacks against LGBTQ people, including transgender kids in K-12 public schools. And in the context of WorldPride, being gay still makes you a criminal in 70 countries, punishable by death in 11 of them. But culture can’t be stopped. That’s what made Stonewall 50 combined with WorldPride NYC so important this year. It is strength in numbers, demands for equality, fair treatment, and safety protections under the law for all citizens of the world that will continue to move us forward. When Harry left for Berlin, I searched for how many Pride marches there are around the world. There’s an event somewhere in the world every month except December. That means thousands of people taking to the streets and A LOT of visibility. (In some countries, unfortunately, Pride events are illegal.) I like to think about WorldPride 365. Yearlong activations that bring LGBTQ people and their allies together to advance humanity. People see us and hear us when we march down the street. Stories have the power to change hearts and minds. And activism helps enact legislation across the U.S. and around the globe. Each of us can make a difference in the lives of others. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "My Gay Pride glow segues to fireworks of freedom." "Gay Pride is an outlook." "Rainbows, pride and drag-queen nostalgia."
July 30, 2019
- Jun 2019
- Parenting a nonbinary child is someone’s present.
My brother thinks I’m stuck in the past. He didn’t tell me that directly. But he did mention it on the phone recently with my kid Harry, who turned 29 this year. I laughed when Harry told me. Surely my frequent posts on social media of photos of Harry from toddler to teen prompted Uncle John’s comment. There were several on my Instagram last week honoring Harry’s dad’s awesomeness on Father’s Day. But here’s the thing: My past experience parenting a nonbinary child is most definitely someone’s present. We’ve made a lot of progress understanding gender identity, sexual orientation and gender expression. There are now some 200 LGBTQ characters on cable television and streaming services that have contributed to our collective knowledge.Still, there are adults who aren’t sure exactly what those three terms mean or how they differ. Many of the uninformed are the parents, family members and caregivers of children and teens who don’t fit into the two-option-only categories of gender and sexuality. Others will become their teachers or future employers. We need to understand these LGBTQ kids, respect them, and make ways for them to belong just as they are. They’ve been around since the beginning of human existence. And I’d say they make up at least 20 percent of our population.
Here are some important trend statistics from studies in 2016-17:
- Only 48 percent of 13-20-year-olds (Generation Z) identify as “exclusively” straight, compared to 65 percent of millennials aged 21-34;
- More than a third of Generation Z believes that gender does not define a person as much as it used to, while only 28 percent of millennials felt the same way;
- Over half, 56 percent, of Gen Z say they knew someone who went by gender neutral pronouns such as “they/them,” compared to 43 percent of people 28-34 years old.
As for the millennial to baby boomer comparison:
- Twenty percent of millennials identify as something other than strictly straight and cisgender (someone whose gender lines up with the gender they were assigned at birth), compared with seven percent of baby boomers.
Here are some disturbing statistics from a 2017 Human Rights Campaign/University of Connecticut study of LGBTQ teens:
- More than 70 percent of LGBTQ teenagers report feelings of worthlessness and hopelessness in the past week;
- Only 26 percent say they always feel safe in their school classrooms -- and just five percent say all of their teachers and school staff members are supportive of LGBTQ people;
- Sixty-seven percent report that they’ve heard family members make negative comments about LGBTQ people.
And then there are these startling statistics from a recent workplace study by the HRC:
- Forty-six percent of LGBTQ workers say they are closeted at work, compared to 50 percent in HRC’s groundbreaking 2008 report;
- One in five LGBTQ workers report having been told or had coworkers imply that they should dress in a more feminine or masculine manner;
- Fifty-three percent of LGBTQ workers report hearing jokes about lesbian or gay people at least once in a while;
- Thirty-one percent of LGBTQ workers say they have felt unhappy or depressed at work.
June 21, 2019
- May 2019
- Do emotions have a gender?
Many children learn that gender is simple. There are boys and girls; boys behave one way, girls another. Modern researchers have explored girls’ experiences with limiting stereotypes. At the core of those limits are beliefs that women are innately caring, nurturing and fragile. When it comes to understanding how rigid boundaries of masculinity can hurt boys, however, our culture is off to a slower start. So it's important to examine how we talk about what it means to be a man. For example, do emotions really have a gender? You’ve heard the directives. “Man up.” “Boys don’t cry.” “Be brave.” “Be a man.” It all starts with what some experts call “the man box.” Inside this box are a narrow set of qualities that many boys and young men are told are necessary to be an ideal man: toughness, physical strength, power, courage and financial success. The lesson? “Real men” don’t express emotions or show empathy. Studies show that many parents across the globe are more likely to talk about feelings and discuss emotional topics with daughters than sons, even as infants. Gillette’s recent headline-making TV ad calls out a lot of these assumptions, and slams them down one by one. The “man box” has real consequences. Researchers connect this impossibly narrow perception of manhood to clinical depression in men. They cite men's difficulty in expressing emotions other than anger for fear of being seen as girly or feminine. But feelings shouldn’t be denied or suppressed because society erroneously equates them (and women) with weakness. The truth is, emotions don't have a gender and every emotion is valid.
No boys left behind.
Parents, guardians and trusted adults can contribute to the health and wellbeing of boys and men by thinking of emotions as an internal compass and sharing that attitude with the young people in their lives. To experience, feel and then evaluate those feelings is our internal guidance system for self-awareness, decision-making and personal growth. In short, we must allow all children to express their full range of feelings, regardless of gender. It's part of their freedom as little humans. Together, we can smash this box of masculinity myths! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Gender stereotyping redux." "Should I indulge my young gender-nonconforming son's interest in belly dancing?" "My son like nail polish, but our relatives gift only stereotyped 'boy' toys."May 3, 2019
- Mar 2019
- 4 things your LGBTQ child needs you to know. And do.
If your child has come out to you as LGBTQ, you may doubt your ability to be a good parent, as I did. Or you may fear for their safety due to bullying or harassment, as I did. But the HRC reports positive outcomes for LGBTQ youth whose parents are supportive and accepting. Those outcomes include greater self-esteem and resilience. Here are 4 things your LGBTQ child needs you to know and do:
1. Coming out is a process.
Before your LGBT child comes out to you, they’ve had to come out to themselves. Maybe it happens with their first crush. Maybe you have a boy who tells you he’s really a girl, or a daughter who tells you she’s a boy on the inside, or a child who doesn’t feel like either. Believe them. Open your heart to them. And continue to listen. Gender identity and sexual orientation are about how you feel inside, who you know yourself to be. And it can develop over time. Trust them to know themselves.2. There’s no right way to be a boy or a girl.
Transgender kids know that a girl can have a penis and a boy can have a vagina. A gender-nonconforming or gender expansive child knows that boys can be happy wearing dresses or that girls can love a good buzz cut. Kids are as unique as their fingerprints, so it follows that not every child will fit inside the pink or blue boxes traditional society has constructed as the norm. So check your expectations and allow your child the freedom to express their individuality.3. Words Matter.
There are many different words used within the LGBTQ community. If you have a child in middle school or older, chances are they’re familiar with all of them. Facebook users can now choose their gender identity from categories, like “bigender” or “gender fluid.” And they can decide which pronouns they want to be associated with the gender option they’ve chosen. Use their chosen pronouns and educate yourself. Learning their language will help you have clearer discussions with your child.4. Have their back.
In addition to unconditional love and acceptance, your LGBT, non-binary or gender nonconforming child needs you to be their ally. They need you to advocate for them with family and friends, in the neighborhood and at school. And they need you to carry your allyship back to the office. Demonstrating the same respect and support you have for your child with your LGBT colleagues will help continue to shape a workplace environment that ensures your child’s future economic equity and stability. This piece first appeared in the spring issue of Business Equality Pride (BEQPride) Magazine. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "What my son taught me about gender identity." "Talking to children about gender expression isn't always easy." "Gay means happy."March 22, 2019
- Oct 2018
- Drag Queen Story Hour: Where dress-up is real!
What do drag queens and children have in common? They love dressing up and all things sparkly and fancy. Drag Queen Story Hour (DQSH) is just what it sounds like. Fabulous drag queens reading storybooks to children in public libraries, schools, children's museums, bookstores and community events. I've seen firsthand how these magical literary events capture the imagination and gender play of kids ages 3-8 and give them glamorous, positive and unabashedly queer role models. Children are able to see people who defy rigid ideas about gender and imagine a world where people can present as they wish. Drag Queen Story Hour is where dress-up is real! Created by writer Michelle Tea and RADAR Productions in San Francisco, the nonprofit Drag Queen Story Hour now has chapters all over the world. Events have been held in more than 100 cities. The first time I attended a DQSH in Brooklyn, Queen Witti Repartee kicked off the hour by getting close to 150 kids and families members on their feet to dance the Hokey Pokey. Then she read three picture books, including one of my favorites, Jacob’s New Dress. Afterwards, as the kids colored pages from The Dragtivity Book, a grandfather in a red shirt came over to tell Witti that he’d learned something from her. He might have been the only person there older than me, and I wondered what it was he’d learned. Maybe he realized that drag is just about creating a character to express another side of who you are. Or maybe it was how a loving parent can support a boy who wants to wear a dress.
Help Drag Queen Story Hour Fight Back Against Right-Wing Attacks
Sadly, some people aren’t open to learning something new. In fact there are those trying to prevent Drag Queen Story Hour from spreading its message of love and acceptance. For example, the Family Policy Alliance launched a campaign in Colorado Springs to urge legislators to stop DQSH events in libraries. Conservative groups and individuals have also staged protests outside of readings (including in Brooklyn and San Francisco), although these folks are always greatly outnumbered by LGBTQ families and allies. And in some cities, like Houston,, local politicians are even putting pressure on libraries to cancel scheduled DQSH events. But in true drag queen style, Drag Queen Story Hour is standing strong! And they need our help.Here's What You Can Do
Please join me in supporting freedom of expression by donating to the Drag Queen Story Hour GoFundMe drive. Every dollar counts in getting them closer to their $10,000 goal. These funds will allow them to strengthen as an organization. They'll be able to host more events and develop resources for chapters around the country, especially in places where respect for LGBTQ people faces significant opposition.“If you can teach people to love themselves, it makes it a lot easier for them to love other people.” –Queen Harmonica Sunbeam
Even if sparkly earrings, false eyelashes and candy-colored wigs aren’t your thing, I hope you agree we can all get behind the Drag Queen Story Hour’s work to teach kids it’s okay to be different and to love themselves. P.S. By all means please share this post to spread the word about helping Drag Queen Story Hour meet its operational funding goals. You're awesome! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Kids' books that celebrate the gender spectrum." "Life lessons learned from a drag queen." "My son's first drag idol was a cross-dressing rabbit."October 10, 2018
- Aug 2018
- Jamel Myles: a bullied 9-year-old dies by suicide after comi ... Warning: Triggers for heartbreak, tears and depression. Over the summer 9-year-old Jamel Myles came out to his mom as gay and said he wanted to wear more feminine clothes. She told him she still loved him. Jamel was proud of himself and eager to share the news with his classmates. Four days after school started, Jamel Myles took his own life. His older sister told their mom that after coming out at school the mean kids who had bullied him incessantly the year before told him to kill himself. Can you imagine the hate-filled words that child had to endure?! I can. And where did those bullying 9-year-old classmates hear such despicable language? The answer: in homes where kids like Jamel would be put in foster care, in churches where he would be decried an abomination, and from the mouths of elected officials who don’t believe transgender students deserve equal rights or federal protections. And can you imagine the shock and grief Jamel’s mother, Leia Pierce, is feeling? Of course, you can. In interviews this week she pleads for an end to bullying. In the solidarity of shared heartbreak, we must also share her outrage.
Here’s what we adults can do.
- We must teach children to be kind.
- It's our job to teach children to be accepting.
- Children must learn that it’s okay to be different.
- We must teach children that it’s okay to be gay.
- All kids should know that love is love.
- We must teach children that hate is never okay.
- Everyone can work to ensure that schools, churches, neighborhoods and homes – and our own workplaces – are safe and welcoming spaces for all people.
August 31, 2018
- Jul 2018
- 'How do I talk to my Christian parents about my kid’s gender ...
When I first read the question asking for advice, four words jumped off the screen: Christian parents gender exploration. My pulse raced with urgency for a child I didn’t know. I wanted to call rather than write. But that wasn’t possible. Here’s the letter submitted anonymously to the helpful and supportive folks at My Kid Is Gay, followed by my reply. “My four-year-old (they/them/theirs, for now) has been exploring gender and recently asked me to tell family members about it – including my fundamentalist Christian parents who babysit frequently. Is it necessary to have this conversation with my parents, especially since we still don’t knowl how our child may end up identifying? And if so, do you have advice on how to talk to my parents about this and ideas for good ground rules to have so my child is emotionally safe when they’re with their grandparents (who babysit frequently)?" YES! It is absolutely necessary for you to talk to your parents. Here are three critically important reasons why you must have a conversation with them about your 4-year-old’s exploration of gender.1. Your child asked you to.
That request was child-speak for “sometimes I don’t feel good about myself when Grandpa and Grandma babysit me.” Something is going on during your parents’ babysitting hours that isn’t lining up with the confidence and freedom your child typically feels. With you, they’re allowed to be themselves; to play outside the lines of gender expectations and explore their sense of self. It sounds likely, however, that your parents are critical of your child’s gender exploration when the three of them are alone together. Given their fundamentalist Christian beliefs, your parents may be trying to enforce gender stereotypes or gendered ideas of how your child “should” be acting based on the constructed concepts of “boy” and “girl”. Maybe your child is hearing comments like, “those clothes really aren’t meant for you,” or “your hair looks silly like that.” Maybe they’re being told, “It’s wrong for you to want that toy.” Even worse, maybe your parents have said, “God doesn’t like it when you act like that.” Your child has asked you to intervene. They are counting on you for your unconditional love, support and protection. They expect you to have their back.2. Your child’s life is always about right now.
The decision to act on your child’s request does not depend on how they may end up identifying down the road. The only thing that matters is how your child is feeling right now. It sounds like your child is feeling distress when your parents babysit, so that must be your focus. No good can come now or later from the sense that the love of a family member is conditional. If your parents’ criticism and/or ridicule of your child are allowed to continue, your child may start to question if adults can be trusted. What’s more, if religion plays into that equation, then faith can become suspect too. It may be hard for your child to separate the loving God many preach from the judgemental God of others. Your four-year-old child’s present life is supposed to be fun, fabulous and creative, so help them be happy in the now moments as these will shape all future moments.3. Your child’s emotional well-being depends on your intervention.
With frequent babysitting opportunities to be alone with your child, your parents may think they can “fix” your gender non-conforming child. However, the reality is that unsupportive, negative comments are both harmful and dangerous. A child made to feel shame about themself for their likes, dislikes, and preferences is a child at risk for low self-esteem and diminished self-worth. When those preferences may go on to form the core of their gender identity, it’s important to step in early. Shame, guilt and other highly negative feelings can lead to more serious psychological distress. A mental health study published in the May 2018 journal Pediatrics found a high prevalence of anxiety and depression among transgender and gender non-conforming children and adolescents. While an earlier study released in January 2018 also reported increased risks among those youth, it found that better family functioning is likely to be protective for those children. It is imperative that you intervene on behalf of your child and let your parents know their support is critical. That goes for all other family members, too, who may or may not be aware of your child’s exploration of gender. The concept may be new or challenging for them, but this is not about them.Advice on how to talk to your parents.
This urgent conversation with your parents doesn’t have to be a scary confrontation. Start with a text or an email. Let them know you’d like to talk with them about your child when the child isn’t around. You can suggest getting together at their house or talking to them simultaneously on the phone. When you do talk, be direct. Your child asked you to tell them about their gender exploration. Obviously, they’re already aware, but they need to know that their grandchild doesn’t feel understood or respected. Their grandchild is experiencing a natural stage of child development that requires their full support. That right there is the basis for your one and only ground rule: Only positive messages and interactions with your child are allowed. Be very clear, and then give them time to think it over. Let the choice be theirs. If they can’t agree to positive-only interactions, then they can no longer babysit. If they push back about why allowing your child to discover and express gender on their own terms is “wrong” or “unnatural,” just go back to the ground rule: only positive messages and interactions with your child are allowed. They are allowed their own opinions, but anything less than loving kindness and respect for your child won’t be tolerated. When they do decide to accept the ground rule, let your child know you’ve had a talk with their grandparents. Assure them that your parents now understand what it means when a child explores gender expression. Then, unless you have a nanny cam, you’ll need to check in with your child. See how things are going when the grandparents babysit. Address any concerns immediately. Go back to the ground rule and the choice they have to continue babysitting or not. There is the unfortunate scenario your parents won’t fully accept your child for who they are as a whole person. In that case, you can assure your child that while their grandparents love them. But not all grownups "get it” when it comes to gender creativity. Explain that, for now, you think it’s important they wait to babysit until they can better understand. No matter how it plays out with your parents or any other family member, continue to invite them along on your child’s gender journey. You can suggest websites, articles, and resource books on raising healthy gender nonconforming children, like Gender Born, Gender Made, for their continuing education. If they’re on Facebook, you can even recommend they watch the National Geographic documentary, Gender Revolution: A Journey with Katie Couric, on Facebook. You are your child’s chief advocate. Draw strength from that. Show your child that how they feel and what they say matters. They are counting on you to hear them and take action. What are you waiting for? Talk to your parents. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "When your son wants to wear eyeliner to Catholic school." "Giving a boy a dress will not make him gay." "Gender confusion? It's all in the minds of confused adults."July 27, 2018
- 4 ways to be a year-round LGBTQ ally.
International Pride Month may have officially ended, but there’s something to keep in mind about the months July through May. People of all sexual orientations, gender identities and gender expressions need safe spaces to be their true selves every day of the year. That means feeling the respect, support and inclusiveness of the people around them. Here are four simple ways to be a year-round LGBTQ ally.
1. Don’t assume everyone is straight.
If you’re a straight, cisgender person like me, keep your assumptions in check. When a woman says she’s married, don’t ask what her husband does. If a man is wearing a wedding band, don’t assume he has a wife. Try asking your nephew if he’s seeing anyone, instead of “Do you have a girlfriend?” Think partner, spouse, or significant other. Every time we assume someone is straight and/or cisgender, they have to evaluate whether or not it’s safe to come out. Imagine how stressful that can be! So keep an open mind.2. Educate yourself.
It’s not up to the LGBTQ+ community to have to explain themselves to you. Other people, especially co-workers and acquaintances, are not responsible for your education. If you hear a new term, or need a quick refresher on the difference between gender identity and sexual orientation, it takes less than a minute to look up. There are a ton of online resources and glossaries to help you understand all the different ways we exist as humans.3. Be aware of the issues.
Did you know over 100 anti-LGBTQ bills were introduced in 2017? North Carolina’s HB 186 would have repealed laws that define the LGBTQ community as a protected class, allowing for discrimination of employment and public accommodations. LGBTQ people can be legally fired from their job in 28 states just because of who they are or whom they love. LGBTQ+ youth can still be forced into harmful conversion therapy in 37 states. Paying attention to legislation in the works and how it might affect the people you know can help you understand what co-workers, friends and family members might be going through.4. Start a conversation.
Engage more people like you. As allies, the more we can do to bring people who share our identity to understand the broad spectrum of LGBTQ+ identities and to also act as allies, the better. Lastly, that Pride button on your jean jacket or rainbow flag on your desk is an all-season show of support to people who just want safe spaces to be their authentic selves. And if you have kids or grandkids, I assure you there’s no way you’ll be able to pack up their rainbow shirts, boas or flags until next June! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Have you come out as an LGBTQ ally?" "A little convo etiquette for LGBTQ allies."July 2, 2018
- May 2018
- This nonbinary kid’s role model shucks oysters.
Lately I’ve been thinking about my one of my kid Harry’s iconic influencers. A stencil Harry made of her and hand-colored with makeup his senior year of high school hangs in my guest room. His drawing of her famous, humanly impossible arabesque pose appeared in his notebooks. Harry even wore a t-shirt to my hometown book launch that featured a striking image of her with rhinestone-studded bowler hat and a cigarette clenched between her teeth. She's singer/songwriter, actor, James Bond flick icon and former supermodel Grace Jones. And she's still my nonbinary kid's role model.
Decades of Grace.
I knew of Grace Jones in the 70s, as the unusually striking and statuesque model who hung out with Andy Warhol, David Bowie and the Studio 54 crowd. Harry discovered her decades later when his first high school boyfriend Andrew introduced him to her music. He eventually gave Harry her entire discography. “I was really attracted to how weird her music was,” Harry told me recently. “The image she’d created for herself was very distinctive, irreverent, unapologetic, androgynous and fierce AF.” Funny, I thought. Those were all traits I’d use to describe Harry. He had eschewed the established gender binary for clothes, toys and colors in early childhood. And just as Grace Jones was intensely honest and different, Harry was always true to Harry. Even before he knew the term nonbinary, Harry knew he wasn’t like other boys. Most of all he didn’t care what other people thought of his gender expression. He never apologized for being himself. [caption id="attachment_7868" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry's AP Art Project, 2008[/caption] “Plus she’s the fullest embodiment of a diva I’ve ever seen,” Harry continued. “If anyone is deserving of the title diva, it’s her."My nonbinary kid's role model is a true diva.
I knew Harry’s meaning of diva extended beyond the standard fabulous, glamorous, talented and temperamental. To Harry, I imagined Grace Jones was a goddess for her fierce personality and unflinching confidence. I remember how excited he was to see the only North American show of her “Hurricane” tour. Later he loved SO much the Grace Jones performance contract rider he found online. It specified 2 dozens oysters on ice “(unopened—Grace does her own shucking).” I saw her personal strength -- and also some unexpected vulnerability -- for myself in the new documentary, Grace Jones: Bloodlight and Bami, by filmmaker Sophie Fiennes. From her early modeling days to producing her own albums, she forged her own path. She didn’t let anyone get in her way. Especially relevant I think, she was guided by how things made her feel.A possibility model.
In a recent New York Times interview with Grace Jones, Fiennes notes that, “Grace is always living the limitless possibilities of being – the possibilities of every moment, that you could live it more extremely.” The larger-than-life woman who just turned 70 still chooses to make her own rules. And without knowing it, she affirmed my nonbinary kid. The fantastic melding of Harry and drag artist Amber Alert created their own rules and their own understanding of gender identity. As a result, I see them, too, as a possibility. Happy Birthday, Grace Jones. Thank you for all the possibilities you offer others who oppose established beliefs. I'm pretty sure that, like you, they simply want to follow their dreams, take risks and be unapologetically themselves. [caption id="attachment_7848" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry & me, Boswell Book Company, Milwaukee 2016.[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "In defiance of gender roles: Clothes!" "Gender bending by an iconic American artist." "The unlikely queer icon."May 21, 2018
- Apr 2018
- 'They/them pronouns have come between my child and me.'
While they/them used as singular pronouns may be confusing at first, you probably already use them without even noticing. In my latest advice piece for MyKidIsGay.com I reply to a parent who's struggling with the switch to their adult child's gender-neutral pronoun. (Did you catch the "their" there?) I'm hopeful the tips that follow below will help keep you from messing up, too. "My problem is that I rarely see my child because she has so much resentment that she doesn't visit her parents very often. So there is little opportunity to practice the they/them pronouns as they are never around. And when they does come around if we mess up it's quite a dramatic thing for them where they starts to cry and feels deeply deeply offended. So frankly the whole thing is quite ridiculous when there's this expectation of perfection in changing to a different pronoun because the fact is that this is happening at the level of procedural memory where it occurs automatically. We can't just change pronouns without thinking about every single sentence." If you want to see your child more often, I want you to know that is possible. It’s also in the realm of possibilities to have a close, trusting relationship with them. Now here’s the thing, it’s going to take real effort on your part. It’s not going to be easy, but it will be worth it. And I know you can do it. You switched to they/them/their pronouns in your letter above, right? Let’s start from a place of compassion. First, have compassion for yourself. You’re worried about your current parent-child relationship. Maybe you’re concerned you’ll lose that child from your life permanently. Those stresses may be adding to the pressure you feel to use different pronouns, making it all the more difficult to focus on using they/them/their consistently. Those feelings are real. Your child’s feelings are real, too, so try to think with compassion about them as well. Personal pronouns are fundamental. They/them pronouns are now inextricably linked to your child’s identity, and using the correct pronouns validates their personhood. It says, “you’re important and we respect you for who you are." I suspect that their tears and being deeply offended when you mess up are because they feel hurt. Your words and actions matter to them. Whether you realize it or not, not using they/them pronouns is interpreted as a refusal to acknowledge and accept your child. Pain builds up quickly when one feels invalidated time and again. The correct singular usage, by the way, is “they are.” They/them pronouns are used in the exact same way when you’re talking about a single person as when you’re talking about a group of people. While using they/them pronouns for an individual may seem like a challenge, chances are you already use those pronouns without realizing it. If you found a cell phone, I bet you’d say, “Somebody lost their cell phone,” referring to a single person. Right? That being said, mistakes do happen. However, think about how you react when you’ve messed up. Do you tell them “the whole thing is quite ridiculous”? That they’re expecting too much of you? That they’re too sensitive? That you can’t just change overnight? Do you roll your eyes and shake your head? Or do you apologize immediately and correct yourself? I couldn’t help but notice how the tone of your letter changed after describing how emotional your child gets when you use the wrong pronouns. How you respond to their reaction is equally as important. If you’re serious about mending your relationship with your kid, it is absolutely necessary moving forward to use your child’s pronouns. After all, it’s up to you to make your child feel loved, understood, and respected. Here are a few tips to help you.
Practice, practice, practice.
The more you use they/them/their pronouns, the easier they’ll be to remember—and you don’t have to wait for your child to come over. Talk about your child with your spouse using they/them pronouns. Practice how you’d introduce your child. For example: “Meet my child. They are a teacher. Working with children is important to them. Their specialty is music.” Write it out, tape it to the fridge, and practice saying it daily.Think before you speak.
Yes, you can do this, even if you’re a fast talker. It may feel awkward at first, but you’ll get used to slowing down and being more intentional with your speech. It’s the same technique you’d use if you traveled to Mexico and were learning to say “Hola” instead of “Hi.” You’d have to think about it first, but soon enough you’d just start using it without thinking twice.Visualize.
New habits can take several weeks to form. Along with practicing aloud, visualize yourself interacting with your child and using the correct pronouns. If you work on changing every day, you can retrain your brain.Be sincere.
Mistakes are common as you unlearn habits of speech. If you do mess up during this process, keep your cool and make a heartfelt apology. You could say something like, “I’m so sorry I didn’t use the correct pronoun for you. Let me try again.” Then correct yourself and move on in conversation. As you commit to efforts that will bring you and your child closer, please know that they/them/their pronouns are here to stay. The Washington Post, The New York Times and the Associated Press all use “they,” “them,” and “their” as singular pronouns when referring to people who identify as non-binary. It’s also common practice on college campuses for students to introduce themselves with their name, their hometown, and their pronouns. So, if you are ready to make the effort to build trust with your child, share the news with them. Tell them you’re committed to respecting them. Say how much you want them to feel loved and validated. And if there’s any crying, it will most likely be tears of relief and happiness. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: He, Zie or They: Gender-specific pronouns are personal. Video Friday: Bullying Prevention Month & gender-neutral pronouns redux.April 13, 2018
- Mar 2018
- Between the Shades: Putting faces to the letters LGBTQ+
Gender identity. The sex we’re assigned at birth. Sexuality. Gender expression. The world’s straight majority, of which I am one, often misunderstands the intersection of those things for people who are gay, bisexual, trans, queer, and intersex. In her new documentary, Between the Shades, Director Jill Salvino puts faces to the letters that make up LGBTQ+ and explores how those letters have evolved. It's a provocative film that examines the immense power of labels and, ultimately, the transcendence of love. Of course, for some in the queer community there is no singular label that fits. As one person in the film explains, labels are what society attempts to put on you, while identity is how you define yourself. I know that from my adult kid Harry, who has no pronoun preference and whose gender expression defies labeling. He’s one of the 50 participants in the documentary who shares experiences, feelings, and viewpoints, with complete candor and tremendous heart. In fact Harry is the first face you'll see on the trailer for Between the Shades. Please watch. Between the Shades premiered at the SOHO International Film Festival last year. Since then the full-length feature has been showing at juried film festivals around the country. You can see it at QFest in St. Louis on April 7 and at the Thin Line documentary film festival in Dallas, April 20-21. Between the Shades will soon have national distribution. And negotiations are underway to make the film available to schools, where kids need to hear positive and empowering messages about diversity.
There is really no better way to understand people than to hear them tell their own stories.
I hope Between the Shades reaches as many audiences as possible, especially in the states that lack protections for LGBTQ+ people. There’s a line in the film where writer Andrew Tobias talks about how things have gotten a lot better for queer people in the big cities. “But if you’re living in Mississippi it’s probably a whole lot different,” he says. Ironically, during a talkback at the recent Queens Film Festival, Jill Salvino noted how some people at the screening in Oxford, Mississippi said they didn’t know anyone who was transgender before seeing her documentary. [caption id="attachment_7733" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Director Jill Salvino, Harry and me of the set of Between the Shades, Feb. 2016[/caption]America Needs This Movie
I imagine Between the Shades will introduce many moviegoers to the diversity of LGBTQI people. And that's a good start to furthering family harmony, workplace acceptance, and social equality. The participants in Jill Salvino's film say they feel a social responsibility to give the queer community a voice. "They also want to help normalize being LGBTQI for younger people who may feel scared and alone," she told me. There is really no better way to understand people than to hear them tell their own stories. Bottom line, we’re all human. We all want to be accepted for who we are. We want to love and be loved. And this documentary is bound to be a classic reminder of that. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Life lessons learned from a drag queen." "Labels are for soup cans." "Transgender? Homophobia? May love conquer all."March 30, 2018
- Gender reveal parties and revelations.
My friend’s 30-something nephew told us about the seven weddings he attended around the country over the past several months. He’d also been to his share of couples’ showers. “I guess the gender reveal parties are up next,” he groaned. Ugh, I thought. I first learned about these new pre-birth parties a few years ago and thought it was a joke. The recent season of the Grace and Frankie web TV series featured a gender reveal party. And now the term was apparently rolling off the tongues of 30-somethings. I did a Google search when I got home and sure enough—gender reveal parties have gone mainstream. The first image was of Party City’s “Girl or Boy Gender Reveal Party Kit for 16.” Another showed an Etsy shop’s custom pink or blue-filled baseballs or golf ball “bombs” for the big “reveal.” [caption id="attachment_7699" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Image: WHFarmsInc[/caption] For the unfamiliar, expectant parents get their friends and family together for a party where the gender of their baby is “revealed.” Sometimes even the parents don’t know beforehand. So the ultrasound tech writes down the sex of the baby and seals it in an envelope. A bakery then makes either a pink or blue-centered cake for the party. (By the way, just for background, it wasn’t until the 1940s that the generally accepted rule of pink for boys and blue for girls was switched up. That’s when children’s clothing manufacturers and retailers arbitrarily decided to reverse gender-specific colors in their advertising.)
Sex vs. gender.
The reason these gender reveal parties annoy me so much is that all an ultrasound reveals is a baby’s physical anatomy. Yep, in front of family and friends, a baby's gender is assigned based on their body parts. But it’s really the child's sex that's being assigned. From my point of view, the better name for gender reveal parties would be external genitalia reveal parties. When I told my 27-year-old kid Harry about the gender reveal party trend, their response was a resounding, “Ewwww.” Harry identifies as nonbinary. That means Harry’s gender identity is neither male/female nor man/woman. Harry is simply a unique, individual human. What my pregnancy ultrasound revealed didn't matter. Harry has never fit society’s limiting stereotyped traits, characteristics or behaviors for a kid assigned male at birth.All on the same gender page.
A rich new vocabulary has developed in our shifting landscape of beliefs about gender. So I want to step back a bit and clarify a few terms. Even some of the more common ones can be confusing. I was clueless the first time I saw the words “gender identity” in print. So I wouldn’t have been able to explain the difference between gender identity and sexual orientation then either. To me, sex and gender were interchangeable, and just one of two boxes to check on a driver’s license application. Speaking of, amid an expanded understanding about gender, California now recognizes a third gender on state ID document. I’m sure there will be more terms in the future, beyond the 60 or so gender identifiers Facebook offers. In fact college kids are probably coming up with new identifiers that no one else is aware of yet. But for now, here's a quick primer of general terms.The sex and gender basics.
Sex refers to one’s physical anatomy, specifically one’s genitalia. Secondarily, it also includes reproductive organs and genetics. Sex Assigned at Birth is the assignment of people as male, female, or intersex based on their physical anatomy at birth. Gender typically refers to socially constructed roles, behaviors and norms that a given society deems appropriate for men and women. Those same social constructs shape definitions of “masculine” or “feminine” too. Gender Identity is one’s own personal, inner sense of being a man or a woman (or boy or girl), neither (like my kid Harry) or both. For transgender people, their internal gender identity and their sex assigned at birth are not the same. Gender Expression/Presentation is the way someone expresses or presents their gender identity through clothing, hairstyle, makeup, or mannerisms. Sexual Orientation refers to someone's romantic, physical or emotional attraction to another person. It is completely separate from gender identity. As for gender reveal parties, gender is not about body parts. A pregnancy ultrasound reveals a baby's assigned sex. It’s not until babies start talking and experience their culture’s gender expectations that they'll be able to tell you who they know themselves to be. For that, all we have to do is listen. In anticipation of future conversations -- with kids or adults -- check out the fabulous Gender Unicorn illustration below. In the meantime, just invite your friends over for a nice brunch. Cake optional. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "For every girl who...there's a boy who" "Talking to children about gender expression isn't always easy." "The day I fell in love with Jean Paul Gaultier."March 9, 2018
- Feb 2018
- The unlikely queer icon.
If someone asked me to name a gay or queer icon, my go-to responses would most likely be a glamorous female celebrity singer, like Cher or Diana Ross. But, Karen Carpenter? Uh, no. So when singer-songwriter Justin Vivian Bond described Karen Carpenter as a queer icon during a solo tribute performance to the Carpenters Thursday night, my jaw dropped.
Karen & me.
I was a war-protesting senior in high school when the brother-sister duo Karen and Richard Carpenter debuted on the pop charts in 1970. Their first songs “Close to You” and “We’ve Only Just Begun” were huge hits, but way syrupy for my Woodstock-era tastes. From my perspective, the Carpenters were the super-straight, all-American singers that Nixon liked. I had no idea how unhappy Karen was. When Karen Carpenter died from heart failure in 1983, I was shocked. She was 32 years old. The same age as me. I’d never heard of anorexia nervosa before her death. I felt sorry for her tragically sad ending.My son who wears heels & Karen.
I didn’t think about Karen Carpenter again until 2000. The Nickelodeon channel was advertising a Carpenter’s greatest singles CD and my kid Harry, pictured above, then age 10, begged his dad and me to order it for him. He’d fallen for the song, “Top of the World.” I’m sure Harry’s dad and I exchanged eye rolls at the request, and again later when Harry played the CD nonstop in the living room. Harry was horrified to hear Karen had died at such a young age from complications of anorexia. In addition to knowing the words to all of the Carpenters top songs, Harry became an expert on eating disorders. I think he loved Karen all the more.Karen & Mx. Justin Vivian Bond.
Thanks to Mx. Bond’s between-song monologues, I learned Karen had been a tomboy. She liked sports and had a passion for drumming. She’d been the original drummer for the Carpenters until the record label made her get out from behind those drums and sing up front. Karen was very uncomfortable with the dresses, big hair and “forced feminization” that accompanied the Carpenter’s rise to fame. Karen felt trapped. She wasn’t allowed to be herself, and she hated that. Even their songs weren’t what she would have chosen to sing. In the mid-70’s she started to slowly starve herself to death.“She gave voice to all young queer kids’ insecurities.”
Listening to Mx. Bond tell Karen’s story and perform the Carpenters’ songs, I slowly became a fan. Even though she didn’t write the songs, the lyrics reflected her suffering. In “Goodbye to Love” the line “No one ever cared if I should live or die” pained me. And I knew those words resonated with many of my male gay friends who’d grown up feeling self-conscious, lonely, and fearful of what the future might hold for them. As Mx. Bond said, “She gave voice to all young queer kids’ insecurities.” And I understood Karen’s queer icon status.Rainy days and Mondays.
I flashed to Harry discovering Karen Carpenter. He was in fifth grade then, the year I worried most about how he was treated at school. Some classmates teased, tormented and physically harmed Harry for his gender expression and perceived gayness. If he ever cried himself to sleep, I imagined him finding hope and safety in the words of his favorite tune, “Top of the World”: “Everything I want the world to be is now comin' true especially for me” Then I ached for him hearing these words from “Rainy Days and Mondays”: "Sometimes I’d like to quit, nothin’ ever seems to fit…Nothin’ is really wrong, feelin’ like I don’t belong” Now here’s the thing. There are still LGBTQ, questioning, and gender expansive children who feel persecuted and unsafe at school. And while there are anti-bullying programs in public schools, the Republican administration has turned its back on transgender kids. So it’s our job as parents, family members, guardians, educators, and adults to speak up and take action whenever we can to protect these vulnerable children who want nothing more than to just be accepted for who they are. In addition to us, these children need queer icons and other heroes to give them hope and cheer them on. They need empathy and words that lift them up. And they can all benefit from shared stories of strength through adversity. Every child deserves to feel on top of the world. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Is an 8-year-old too young to know he's gay?" "New LGBTQ history book for teens is a must-read for straight parents." "We must rise up for transgender children."February 19, 2018
- ‘Should I indulge my young son’s interest in belly dancing?’
My kid Harry's first exposure to Middle Eastern dance came courtesy of Disney. The animated flick Aladdin played non-stop at our house for a couple of years in the mid '90s. Jasmine and her long black hair became the star of his Barbie collection. The song "Prince Ali" was his favorite dance tune. He loved the beat and the moves. If he'd asked to take "belly dancing" classes, I might have wrestled with the age-old "What will other people think?" A mom wrote to MyKidIsGay.com wondering the same thing. I learned a lot answering her question. You'll see from my reply below why I now put quote marks around "belly dancing." "My GNC son is 9 and recently discovered belly dancing. He is teaching himself from YouTube videos that I have carefully prescreened. He’s good at it and I’m kind of proud of his grace and fluidity, but I am very conflicted about indulging an interest that most of society perceives as highly sexualized. Would I be letting a daughter do hip and belly rolls? We’ve set ground rules. OK at home but not appropriate out in the world until he’s older (our 'make-up is for middle school' rule.)" Wow…a nine-year-old boy who’s good at belly dancing? That’s amazing! I can understand how proud you are of his poise and dance abilities. Seriously, have you ever tried an abdominal roll? I wish I had that much coordination and body control. Most of society knows very little about the origins of what we call “belly dancing” – I have to admit I didn’t know much either. I learned a few things since receiving your question.
Here's what I did not know:
- The correct name for “belly dancing” is Middle Eastern dance.
- Middle Eastern dance dates back to 1000 B.C.
- Middle Eastern dance is part of the culture in many Arabic-speaking countries.
- Children learn their country of origin’s folk dances from grandparents, aunts and uncles, and cousins at weddings and other family celebrations.
- The name “belly dance” was adopted in the U.S. when Middle Eastern dance premiered at the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair. (That was the Victorian era. Ahem.)
- The term “belly dance” is considered fairly offensive in the Middle East, where it’s called Raqs Sharqi (pr. rock sharky) and translates as “oriental dance.”
Society has it wrong.
He’s a gender nonconforming kid. So he’s probably already experienced society’s rigid assignment of gender to toys, clothes and colors. Those established norms are changing slowly, but still, many adhere to outdated “rules.” Chances are he’s also been exposed to the erroneous belief that recreational dance is “too feminine” an activity for boys. Now he’ll be exposed to another aspect of society’s negative misperceptions. This time, instead of ballet or jazz, limiting beliefs will be aimed at a cultural dance. And the bias extends to adult dancers too. As parents of gender nonconforming kids we must be mindful not to let society’s restricted thinking limit our children’s creativity, self-expression, and inner authenticity. Please know that in this piece I make the same suggestions were it your daughter who’d discovered Middle Eastern dance. If you haven’t already, start educating your son about belly dancing, and give him some ways to talk about it that will inform others and elevate the art. Undoubtedly the day will come on the playground when some double-jointed kid will ask, “Can you do this?” while bending their thumb back to touch their forearm. Before you know it, another kid is inverting their elbow or wiggling their ears. Your kid should be able to show off his abdominal control!Anticipate questions.
When you mention your son’s new hobby to relatives or friends, you might get a raised eyebrow or two, followed by the questions you’ll half-expect but still cringe to hear. Queries like, “What? Isn’t that type of dancing for strippers?” Or, “Isn’t that erotic dancing?” Or, “Is that type of dance appropriate for children?” Think about arming your son with some prepared answers. In other words, the same kind of replies you may have armed him with if he liked to wear pink shorts in kindergarten or carry a Dora the Explorer backpack in first grade. Ever since the turn of the last century, the entertainment industry, followed by movies and TV, continues to portray many cultural dances as erotic. I mean, have you seen the Tango or the Samba performed on Dancing with the Stars lately? So there are some long-standing barriers to overcome when it comes to your son’s new favorite pastime. But there’s a good chance that he and you can both become ambassadors for centuries-old folk dances. Encourage your son to examine the cultures, traditions, and history of the Middle Eastern and North African countries where the dances originated. Maybe he’ll even do a Social Studies report on Middle Eastern dance in school some day. In the meantime, continue to be proud of him. Encourage his love of dance. Be happy he’s found a hobby that’s both fun and good aerobic exercise. And if you’re lucky, maybe you can get him to teach you an ab roll. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "When your son wants to wear eyeliner to Catholic school." "Our son likes nail polish, but our relatives gift only stereotyped 'boy' toys." "Does worrying about my gender nonconforming son make me a bad mom?"February 2, 2018
- Jan 2018
- Proud mom of an irreverent drag queen.
My grown kid Harry, a.k.a irreverent drag queen Amber Alert, first performed drag in pre-school. His debut theatrical show was in the after-school program in first grade. He insisted on taking a dress and feathered boa from his dress-up box to school. He was staging a production of 101 Dalmations, in which he’d cast himself as Cruella de Vil. I don’t see as many of Amber’s shows as I’d like. Her gigs often begin at midnight or later. So I was excited this week when she told me she’d be in a show that started at 8pm. She was reprising her Ivana Trump character for a show curated by the leftist performance collective Citizens United. A little background: On November 8, 2016, Citizens United gathered a group of drag queens, poets and punk musicians to commemorate what they assumed would be the election of the first woman president of the United States. On January 18, 2017, they reassembled on the eve of our first fascist inauguration. This week, one year later, they convened to (re)consider: “What Happened?”
Laughter in the orange-colored face of adversity.
The performers shared works that were created out of the stresses, anxiety and depression that comes with shocking executive orders and daily breaking news. They moved us with heartfelt brilliance. Amid the reminders of so many lives turned upside down, it was drag queen Amber Alert and performance artist Chris Tyler who gave the audience some much-needed laughter in the orange-colored face of adversity. They opened the show with a 30-second clip of President Obama’s successor and his daughter, Ivanka, appearing on The Wendy Williams Show in 2013. The voting majority of people knew before the election what despicable, deplorable Donald himself summed up in 30 seconds. Then Chris took the stage as Ivanka Trump to lip sync “Daddy Issues” by Demi Lovato. The performance soon became a mother-daughter act. Yep, my one-and-only Amber Alert, as Ivana Trump, joined in on background vocals. [caption id="attachment_7564" align="aligncenter" width="600"] l. to r. Amber Alert as Ivana, Chris Tyler as Ivanka, at Citizen United's "What Happened?" show[/caption]A Hidden Valley dystopia.
For their closing number, we find Ivanka and Ivana in a New York City dystopia. They are trapped in the penthouse of Trump Tower. It's the only safe place in the city. And the only provisions are squeeze bottles of Hidden Valley Ranch Dressing. In this touching scene, Ivana belts out Tammy Wynette’s “Stand By Your Man.” I realized that night how I have internalized each setback decreed by our so-called leader and the Republican administration. So Amber and Chris’s comedy sketches were just the coping mechanism I needed. It is, after all, the one-year anniversary of our country’s initial unraveling. Ivana and Ivanka helped me step back, de-stress and feel ready to move forward again on a more positive note.No laughing matter.
My hopes for the future now rest with Special Counsel Robert Mueller. I have faith, too, that midterm election results give Democrats control of the House and Senate. And I'm energized by you and all who continue to march, speak up and speak out for equality, fairness, and justice. Doing what’s right, fighting for what’s right is stressful. So while we do the work, remember that humor can help trigger a positive swing in attitude. Our current state of affairs is no laughing matter. But I also know that laughter can boost immunity, trigger the release of endorphins, and improve blood flow. Finally, I want to give a special shout out to all the performers at Ars Nova Wednesday night for sharing their art. And to Chris Tyler’s Ivanka and Amber Alert’s Ivana, who made the best of a bad situation by making us laugh again. I remain one proud mom of a comedic and irreverent drag queen named Amber Alert. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “Fighting for kids in the gender revolution.” “LGBTQ kids need us more than ever.” “A look to the future for gender-nonconforming kids.”January 19, 2018
- Making every moment count for transgender & gender nonco ...
An entire New Year stretches before us! Like many, I’ve set my intentions on what I want to accomplish this year. I remain passionate about helping create positive change for transgender and gender nonconforming kids. I want to see their parents love them more and worry about them less. And I also want to work harder to make our world a safer and more equal place not just for transgender and gender nonconforming kids, but all LGBTQ+ people. I’m a list and post-it note person. I set monthly, weekly and daily goals for myself. You probably have a list or calendar filling up, too. But I know how we feel about ourselves moment-by-moment is what really counts, regardless of the day or the year. I was reminded of that this week at neighbor Nicole’s fourth birthday celebration. Her 7-year-old cousin Ray had an important nonverbal message for everyone in the room. As for Ray’s dad, well, not so much. Ray, Nicole and the other kids danced to Disney tunes in the middle of the room with feathered boa from the “Take a Selfie!” prop table. They spun around, jumped and giggled. Ray proved quite the dancer, twirling his green, yellow and purple boa overhead like a rhythmic gymnastics ribbon. At a song break, the girls left the dance floor. They exchanged their boas for sparkly crowns, Mardi Gras beads and oversized sunglasses. They posed against the “selfie” backdrop while an aunt took photos. Ray kept dancing. Ray didn’t care that he was by himself. His grin filled his whole face while he mastered more moves with the flowing feather boa. That’s when Ray’s dad walked over and took away the boa. “You don’t need that,” he said. Ray stopped dancing. His face fell. “He does need that!” I wanted to say. But I didn’t know his dad or Ray for that matter. All I knew was that in the moments before, Ray had been full of spontaneity and joy. Later, Ray and the girls were back on the dance floor with their feathered boas. Ray’s dad called him over. “Give me that,” he said, sliding the boa from Ray’s neck. “You’re getting feathers all over the place.” Ray opened his mouth to speak, but instead turned and walked away. I’m sure he noticed that while there might have been a feather or two on the floor, no one was taking boas away from the girls. Again, I held my tongue, and it was hard for me. I had just witnessed a father controlling the behavior of his son. So I knew Ray’s father expected him to conform to society’s established ideas about what’s appropriate for children to play with. His dad had assigned a gender to an accessory and was teaching that to Ray. Was Ray confident in those moments? Did he feel good self-esteem? Ray’s wide eyes and downturned mouth said probably not. He looked confused, and I didn’t think he was feeling too good about himself at that moment. As a result, I feared someday Ray would be made to feel shame for his choice of playthings or activities. Maybe Ray is a gender nonconforming kid, maybe not. Either way, I was reminded that more parents and families need to see toys as just toys, colors as just colors, clothes as just clothes and kids as just kids. To create positive change in our society we need to bring up confident, hopeful, optimistic and resilient children. We need to empower all kids with the freedom of expression and joy that comes naturally to them. And we do that moment by moment, with love, acceptance, support and respect.
For the families of transgender, gender nonconforming & all kids.
It's the first week of January, so I have four* suggested add-ons for your list of New Year’s resolutions. Especially relevant are the ideas that affirm our collective desires for freedom, joy and personal growth. Please feel free to share them with every adult and child you know.- I will approve of myself, my characteristics, my abilities, my likes and dislikes, my inclinations and disinclinations, realizing that these form my unique individuality. I have them for a reason.
- I will approve of and rejoice in my accomplishments, and I will be as vigorous in listing these – as rigorous in remembering them – as I have ever been in remembering and enumerating my failures or lacks of accomplishment.
- I will remember the tremendous energy, joyful spontaneity, possibilities and potential that lie within me to create that which I can imagine for myself.
- I will realize that the future is a probability. In terms of everyday experiences, nothing exists there yet. It is virgin territory, planted by my feelings and thoughts in the present. Therefore I will plant accomplishments and successes, and I will do this by focusing on how I want and expect the future to be for me.
January 5, 2018
- Dec 2017
- Transgender youth, the gender revolution & my mistakes: the ...
The so-called leader of the free world recently banned the CDC from using the word "transgender," along with six other words and phrases, including "diversity" and "vulnerability." He may think he can erase LGBTQ people, but queer people -- including transgender youth -- have existed in every generation throughout world history. And, no, they will not be silenced or erased. I'm happy to share the blog posts that readers' clicks picked as the the most popular in 2017. I think these five speak to the hope of a better future that exists for transgender youth, gender nonconforming kids, and self-described nonbinary Millennials. And I wasn't surprised that my big Halloween mistakes were included in the top picks. We can all learn from our own and each other's screw ups! Each numbered subhead below is a link. If you'd like to do your own year in review, you can scroll through all 2017 posts here.
2. Fighting for kids in the gender revolution.
3. We must rise up for transgender children.
4. President Obama's letter to moms of LGBTQ kids.
5. This mom's biggest Halloween mistakes.
Transgender youth deserve our attention.
Rolled back protections for LGBTQ people will most likely continue as long as President Obama's successor occupies the White House and a Republican-led Congress approves his policies. Please speak up for transgender kids in 2018. Please talk often of a world filled diversity and respect for all. And please remember the vulnerability of marginalized communities. I wish you much love, peace and understanding it in the New Year. Love always wins. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: From the wisdom of a trans girl to potential parent bullies: your top picks of 2016. “From homophobes to genderqueer: the top fave blog posts of 2015.” “A 2014 roundup of most popular posts on My Son Wears Heels.”December 29, 2017
- My Santa screwup.
Four-year-old Mateo is convinced there’s a Santa Claus. I mean if you can text your gift wish directly to one of Santa’s elves at the North Pole, he has to be real. Right? And the elf’s reply to him was “right there” on the mobile phone of his neighbor, who’s six. So Santa has to be real. No Santa screwup there, if you ask me. But before his text exchange with the elf, Mateo’s mom told me he had asked her repeatedly: Is Santa real? Is Santa real?
The Good Answer
Hearing the question fired in rapid succession made my heart race. My now-27-year-old child Harry’s unexpected Santa inquiry decades earlier flashed before me. I had to know how she replied to those four-year-old eyes filled with wonder. “I told him that no one really knows for sure, because no one’s ever seen him,” she said. “Some people dress up as Santa – the same way he plays dress-up, but no one has ever seen the real Santa.” “That was a good answer,” I said, impressed with her ability to hold onto the magic of Santa Claus.“I still wish I could have had a complete do-over on the Santa question.”
“It was hard,” Linda confessed. “I really don’t like the idea of lying to Mateo.” “Well, your answer was way better than mine,” I assured her. “I still wish I could have had a complete do-over on the Santa question.” Harry was eight, I told her. We were driving in the car. I had just picked him up from the summer rec program. Harry informed me a kid told him that Santa wasn’t real. He wanted to know if that was true. I hesitated. My kid was asking for the truth, and, believing honest answers were important, but not prepared with a good answer, I gave it to him. I said, “Yes, Harry, it’s true.” And he burst into tears.A Tough Conversation
I quickly pulled over to the curb to console my heartbroken kid. His sadness quickly became my own. I apologized for not stopping the car sooner talk about it. And I was sorry for not being more sensitive in my answer. I drew as many analogies as I could to imaginary play that encourages kids to dream big and believe those dreams can come true. It was a tough conversation."Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus."
I shared with Mateo’s mom that two months too late, in September 1998, I read an article in the hometown Milwaukee paper about an editorial from 1897 that ran in The (New York) Sun. The opinion piece had answered eight-year-old Virginia’s question, “Is there a Santa Claus?” with “Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus.” The editor wrote, “(Santa) exists as certainly as love and generosity and devotion exist, and you know that they abound and give to your life its highest beauty and joy.” He reminded Virginia of fairies and how just because no one ever sees them dancing on the lawn doesn’t mean they don’t exist. “Nobody can conceive or imagine all the wonders there are unseen and unseeable in the world,” he added. Personally, I still believe that last line!Reality Suspended
I began reading Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone to Harry that same September. He was a wizard for Halloween that year, and made his very own wizard license. With reality suspended, I felt better about my Santa screwup. Later in the year I asked Harry to give me a Christmas/Hanukkah gift wish list. The page he gave me was titled “Harry’s Wish List” instead of the usual “List for Santa.” “You know, Harry,” I said, “Santa can still come to our house if you want.” His eyes brightened like a Christmas tree. Then with a smile and a nod, I knew there would still be magic at our house that season. There were no cookies left out for Santa or carrots for the reindeer that year. Still, the jolly man in the big red suit brought Harry the Holiday Teddy Beanie. And for Christmas 1999, he wrapped up a Ferbie toy. As for the real Santa, well, he's real as long as you believe in him. Let my Santa screwup guide your sleigh tonight. [caption id="attachment_7478" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry & Me in our Christmas hats, 1998[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The year I said no to Kwanzaa & other holiday memories." "My son's first drag idol was a cross-dressing rabbit." "Gender issues at the North Pole."December 22, 2017
- My son likes nail polish, but our relatives gift only stereo ...
Kids know what they like when it comes to toys. The more progressive among us have picked up on that. We've moved beyond the gender-stereotyped toys that limit kids' choices at play. Even some retailers have eliminated the pink aisles and blue aisles altogether, dividing toys by type instead of by gender. So what happens when your child has a gender-nonconforming holiday wish list, but your relatives always default to the gender stereotyped "boy" toys? That's the tricky question the parent of a seven-year-old sent in anonymously to the supportive folks at My Kid Is Gay. The full question and my advice follow. "My son likes all things pink and sparkly and has always preferred "girl toys" like dolls and dress-up. The holidays are a weird time, though, because his aunts and uncles still gift him "boy" toys that he couldn't care less about. They say they don't have a problem with it but are pretty conservative and I'm not sure they would be on board with buying a 7-year-old boy nail polish. Is this something I can talk to them about, or should we just keep accepting the gifts graciously year after year?" Your son sounds delightful – and wise, too. He knows sparkly things are fun for everyone. He’d probably have a high five for my artist neighbor, too, who describes pink as “the happy color.” As for your son’s conservative aunts and uncles, I’m sure you’d agree that they could use a little loosening up! But how to do that without the conversation being uncomfortable for you or them is the next question. Relatives who gender stereotype their nieces and nephews often have a difficult time stepping outside of the status quo on child’s play. Even though more and more people and toy stores alike are coming around to the idea that toys have no gender, there are still plenty of people who still see child’s play as black and white or, in this case, pink or blue. I imagine their brains’ electrical wiring misfires at the mere thought of their nephew polishing his fingernails. The idea just doesn’t compute for them. But thanks to the plasticity of the human brain, a thoughtful shift in expectations is possible. You know all the hats you wear as a parent. There’s personal assistant, personal shopper, chauffeur, fix-it expert, head cheerleader, and snuggle specialist, to name a few. Well, sometimes there are the added duties of gift-recipient advocate and relatives’ educator. The challenge with that special ops assignment is how to present your case in a nonthreatening way, so I understand your hesitancy to even broach the subject with them. A phone call without warning might put them on the defensive. Even bringing up the stereotyped toy issue in a regularly scheduled chat could catch them off guard. And that might be uncomfortable for all of you. My suggestion is to skip the call and just send a warm and very brief email instead. Think of it as a little nudging communication from you that ideally will trigger some new thinking, re-learning, and practice on their part.
Here’s what I might write if I were in your shoes:
“Dear Aunt and Uncle, In your continuing efforts to be your nephew’s favorites, I wanted to pass along some gift ideas that would make his holiday this year extra special. He would be over the moon with any one of these things:- A nail polish set
- The game Twister
- Smooshins Surprise Maker
- Kids Walkie Talkies
- A Toys R Us gift card
The out-of-towners.
If aunts and uncles live out of town, you could consider a different opening paragraph, to be a bit more direct about the distance between you. For example, you could open with something along the lines of: “I know it can be tricky shopping from far away for a seven-year-old who likes nontraditional toys. So rather than default to a stereotyped ‘boy’ toy, I wanted to share some ideas that would absolutely thrill him.” You get the idea. Of course, any version of my suggestions would include your own personal touches. I think this approach might be just the gentle push your relatives need to better understand and respect your son’s uniqueness. And that in turn would make this an uplifting, loving, and sparkly holiday season for you all. If, however, they reply with any pushback or opt to send a stereotyped “boy” toy anyway, then feel free to take additional action. Perhaps a more serious conversation with them about acceptance and celebrating their nephew’s differences would be an appropriate way to start the New Year. Right after your son’s mani-pedi. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Holiday gift ideas for gender nonconforming kids." "Gender issues at the North Pole." "When boys don't like being boys."December 8, 2017
- World AIDS Day: Memories, Art and Action
The red ribbon that symbolizes support for the fight against HIV/AIDS filled my phone screen. I saw First World AIDS Day Observed Worldwide and the date 1988. I took in my daily early morning lesson in LGBTQ+ history on the free mobile app Quist. My mind flooded with memories of my close friend Harry S., one of the namesakes for my own Harry. And my heart ached. Harry S. was an artist and designer living with AIDS in Los Angeles. He was smart, movie-star handsome, and one of the most fun people I've ever known. Harry was also friends with Pee-wee Herman. We were all in New York City at the same time in June, 1992. Harry and I had a dinner party for Pee-wee and some friends, and we cooked bow-tie pasta. Six months later, Harry died on Christmas Eve, at the age of 36. That was the year the clinical trials of new combination drug therapies had begun, and the year President Clinton established a new White House Office of National AIDS Policy.
There’s a piece of my flannel shirt in a quilt dedicated to him in the AIDS Memorial Quilt.
Harry S. and I grew up across the street from each other in Milwaukee. His sister was my best friend, and my brother was his. The four of us were like siblings. My son Harry met his Uncle Harry only once, on a visit to Los Angeles in 1991. My Harry took his first steps at Uncle Harry’s house. A photograph from Uncle Harry’s senior thesis performance piece at CalArts hangs on the wall to my left as I write this. There’s a piece of my flannel shirt in a quilt dedicated to him in the AIDS Memorial Quilt. And there’s a piece of my heart reserved just for him. Today has meaning for me not only because of Harry and the thousands of others memorialized on the quilt, but for the millions living with HIV/AIDS today. They are all in my heart.AIDS EDUCATION POSTERS NOW ART COLLECTION
I also checked HuffPost "Queer Voices" to see how the U.S. was observing World AIDS Day. A chilling graphic in orange and black stopped me cold. It featured side-by-side images of a target and then President Reagan, his portrait captioned “He Kills Me.” Indirectly, Reagan killed thousands with his silence. He said nothing for years after the first AIDS cases were discovered in 1981 and a national health crisis developed. [caption id="attachment_7258" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Donald Moffet, He Kills Me, 1987[/caption] In a piece titled “Visualizing the AIDS Epidemic,” I leaned the "He Kills Me" poster is one of over 8,000 AIDS education posters donated to the University of Rochester by Dr. Edward C. Atwater beginning in 2007. The extensive collection dates from 1982 through today and includes posters from 129 countries/regions, covered in 76 languages and dialects. The entire collection has been digitized, so take a minute or two this World AIDS Day to scroll through a few pages. The messages of awareness and education remind all of us that AIDS does not discriminate. It continues to affect people around the world, people of any gender identity, any sexual orientation, and any color, from young kids to seniors.THE ORANGE MENACE’S MENACING PROCLAMATION
I clenched my teeth as I read the World AIDS Day commemorative proclamation issued by President Obama’s successor that shamefully neglected to mention LGBTQ people or people of color.But here are the facts:
- An estimated 36.7 million people are living with HIV/AIDS around the world, with 1.1 million of those residing in the U.S.
- In 2015, 48 percent of those diagnosed with AIDS in the U.S. were African-Americans.
- The Centers for Disease Control in 2014 found that gay and bisexual men made up an estimated 70 percent of new HIV infections in the U.S.
- While data on the transgender community is limited, the CDC also found that an estimated 22 percent of all trans women are HIV positive.
December 1, 2017
- Nov 2017
- All the feels at Gender Conference East.
I boarded the Hilton hotel’s airport shuttle behind a mom and her tween. I wasn’t sure if they’d flown into Newark or taken the train like me. But I knew without exchanging more than a smile that they were headed to the Youth and Family Day at Gender Conference East, same as me. As a co-presenter, I wanted to come the night before to attend the Family Meet and Greet. The mom-tween pair slid into the first row of seats and as I sat down behind them I had the eerie sense that I was seeing counterparts of Harry and me, if he were now 12 years old instead of 27. The child looked like a younger version of Harry, with long, curly hair, chiseled features, soft eyes, and an easy smile. They wore a purple, green, and yellow print pencil dress over thick neutral-colored leggings. The look could have been pulled right from Harry’s wardrobe. The mom, petite like me, wore jeans and sneakers, with her thick wavy hair pulled back. “I’m really excited to be here,” the child said. They rested their head on mom’s shoulder. "Last year I was nervous, but now I’m excited to see the kids I met last time.” The mom might have been nervous the year before, too. I remembered how lonely and in search of support I'd felt being the mother of a young child whose gender identity and gender expression differed from the majority of kids -- those that fit society’s established gender norms.
A sense of loss washed over me for not having had what this mom and child were about to experience.
A dull ache filled my chest and I got a little misty. I dabbed the corners of my eyes, not understanding the sudden rush of sadness. A sense of loss washed over me. This mom and child were about to experience something I did not -- a full-day conference designed to provide support, nurturing and empowerment for parents, youth, families and caregivers. I stood behind Harry’s and my doppelgangers at the hotel check-in desk. I reveled at physical proximity and loving touches. They reminded me of my still close relationship with Harry. I wanted to embrace this mom and her child and say how happy I was that they could be in such a safe, welcoming place of community. Eager to see all of the kids and connect with some other parents, I dropped off my bag and went down to the hotel ballroom for the Family Meet and Greet. Dozens of happy, noisy children, doing art projects filled the room of wall-to-wall tables. Some hung new works on the wall. Others giggled as they chased each other, weaving in and out of standing adults.Without a young child, I was definitely the observer.
I left after a few minutes of taking it all in, infused with the aura of love and goodness that comes with quality family time. Without a young child, I was definitely the observer. I know I would have been one of those parents two decades ago. Maybe they could have been you, too. Or maybe they are you now. There were 540 people at Gender Conference East, including nearly 200 children, ages 3 to 16, all brought together by the good folks at the Gender & Family Project, PFLAG NYC, and Hetrick-Martin Institute. I attended multiple Family and Youth Day sessions, choosing presentations that allowed me to hear firsthand more about the issues facing families of trans and gender diverse kids, and witness all of the support that exists for them and among them. Other programs I sat in on definitely informed my my advocacy and activism of behalf of these gender-revolution kids. As a result, my desire for their bright and safe future was fortified that day. At the conference closing I saw the same child with whom I’d shared a ride to the hotel. They stood with two other kids, eager to meet up with a third who’d just entered the room. “There’s Sam,” the child from the shuttle said. “She looks so pretty!” I caught my breath to hold back the tears that often come with progress. These kids had found other kids like them, with whom they could just be themselves. And it didn't matter whether their pronouns were she, he or they. I had a feeling they would most likely become BFFs. And most likely the parents of those kids had found their own community that day, too.DOZENS OF GENDER & LGBTQ+ CONFERENCES AROUND THE WORLD
In addition to Gender Conference East, there are a number of TransKids, TransFamilies and Trans Youth conferences, including one in the UK. If you’re the parent, family member or caregiver for a trans, gender nonconforming or nonbinary child, I encourage you to find a conference that’s a good match to your geography, calendar and pocketbook. Or please share this link with someone you think could use a strong community of support and validation for all their doing right for their child. [caption id="attachment_7157" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Postcards from gaycenter.org's exhibit booth at Gender Conference East. Art by Daniel Arzola @arzola_d[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Transgender kids are changing the world." "The fierce dads of gender nonconforming kids." "Don't be your gender creative kid's first bully."November 17, 2017
- A Transgender Air Force?
When Mara Keisling, executive director of the National Center for Transgender Equality (NCTE), held up a “TRANS AF” t-shirt at a fundraising event in New York City Monday night, the question that popped into my head was, Transgender Air Force? "When I first saw it," she said, "I thought people were going to think it was for some sort of Transgender Air Force." I wasn’t sure why laughter broke out. Then she explained for those of us (like me) who were "old" like her that AF is modern-day slang for "As Fuck." Based on everything she told us about the NCTE Action Fund, I couldn’t wait to slap on a “FIERCE AF” sticker and order a “FIERCE AF” t-shirt. And if I’m not saying “fierce as fuck” every day, I’m surely thinking it as I focus on actions needed to fight the actions taken by the most anti-LGBTQ President and administration in our country’s history. These are deeply troubling and often-terrifying times for transgender and gender nonconforming people, especially trans and gender nonconforming children. People are being harmed. And if you’re a person of color, Muslim, an immigrant, a woman, or disabled, we know that discrimination is compounded.
“We have not come this far to only come this far.” ~Mara Keisling
In just a few weeks, it will be 15 years that NCTE has worked to influence policy and society at the local, state and federal levels. Around the country in the last three years NCTE has faced almost 150 anti-trans bills at the state level, and they beat every one of them with the exception of HB2, North Carolina’s so-called Bathroom Bill, which sanctioned discrimination against transgender people. But NCTE hadn’t been able to endorse trans candidates or criticize discriminatory legislators up for re-election, until now that is. Last month it launched the NCTE Action Fund as an assertive political advocacy organization to increase the strength and capacity of the movement to better respond to attacks and the rollback of civil rights protections for nearly two million transgender people in the U.S.Here’s what the Action Fund will be able to do:
- Endorse and help to elect transgender candidates;
- Mobilize trans voters and their families with new tools;
- Hold policymakers accountable when they attack the trans community to show them the price of discrimination;
- Fight bills at the state and federal levels that take aim at transgender people, especially those targeting children;
- And elect a president that believes in fairness for everyone.
November 3, 2017
- Oct 2017
- The biggest Halloween mistakes I made as a mom.
I watched children in my neighborhood follow their mom or dad into the nearby Halloween Spirit store after school yesterday. I smiled, because I know how kids love the fantasy and imaginative play of Halloween. But then memories of my worst Halloween mistakes as a mom flooded in.
BIG HALLOWEEN MISTAKE #1
I excitedly explained to two-tear-old Harry all that would happen at our annual Halloween block party in Milwaukee: trick-or-treating at night, a piñata, fireworks, and everyone dressed in costumes. I told him that he could be anyone he wanted. As you’ll read in my first big Halloween mistake, I surreptitiously re-directed him from Wendy to Peter. Harry, now 27, reminded me decades later of the irony in that decision.I worried about what others might think of his dad and me for letting our boy be a girl.
BIG HALLOWEEN MISTAKE #2
Then when Harry was four, skipping the year he wanted to be a skeleton, I made my second biggest Halloween mistake. That mistake used to haunt me more than the first, because Harry remembers that one. On both occasions my gender nonconforming Harry wanted to go trick-or-treating as a girl. But I didn’t let him. I cared more about protecting him from teasing. And I worried about what others might think of his dad and me for letting our boy be a girl. See the pattern: I, I, I and me. I’m going to cut myself some slack now. At least that’s what my closest girlfriends tell me to do whenever I bring up the errors of my early Halloween ways. I knew Harry liked Barbie dolls and other so-called “girl toys." He had, after all, told me at age two, “Inside my head I’m a girl.” What I didn’t know were the terms gender nonconforming, gender creative, gender expansive, gender diverse, gender fluid or transgender. Those words didn't exist in the early '90s. And I had no idea what gender identity meant either. In fact I’d never heard of it.WHAT GENDER CREATIVE KIDS NEED
Even though I have forgiven myself those two big Halloween mistakes, I still wish I’d been secure enough to let Harry be a two-year-old Wendy or the Pink Power Ranger at age four. How fun it would be to share those photos here today and inspire other worried parents of gender expansive kids. But I didn't know then what I know now:- Children’s gender identity and expression develop over time, and they may or may not match society’s established gender stereotypes.
- Kids need freedom of expression to discover themselves.
- There is no such thing as “girl” or “boy” clothes, toys, colors or costumes.
- A happy child’s likes or dislikes are not about you.
- Let your child be. Especially at Halloween.
October 19, 2017
- My Fall Photo Album: Bushwig 2017 & Biden
NON-STOP QUEENS
My friend Sharon and I hopped into a taxi and headed to the opening of Bushwig 2017, Brooklyn's weekend-long explosion of drag, music and love. I unfolded the three-page line-up of the 120+ performers I'd printed out in advance. Sharon and I reviewed it in the car, circling the shows we were most eager to see, based on our past Bushwig adventures. It became obvious we'd be traveling back-and-forth between the catwalk at the main stage and the outdoor music venue in the back. Mz. Amber Alert (above), aka my drag artist kid Harry, was hosting that first day of Bushwig 2017 and performing on Day 2. She was being interviewed when we arrived, but I got her to to strike a quick pose for me outside the entrance. So here, for your scrolling pleasure, are some of my fave photos from Bushwig 2017's main event. I only wish we'd been able to see everyone!MY TOP PIX FROM BUSHWIG 2017
[caption id="attachment_7017" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Ava Patron[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7015" align="aligncenter" width="450"] A little host banter from Thorgy Thor, RuPaul's Drag Race S9[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7014" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Ms. Ter[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7010" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Zane Zena[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7011" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Charlene[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7096" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Mahal Kita[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7042" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Mini Horrorwitz (Amber on the floor as defeated Hitler.)[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7044" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Bushwig co-founder Horrorchata[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7048" align="aligncenter" width="450"] DiDa Ritz, Ru Paul's Drag Race S4[/caption] Yup, it was love, love, love, love, LOVE. With non-stop performers over two full afternoons-into-nights, Bushwig is an entertainment extravaganza everyone should see at least once in their life. Sharon and I decided that next year we need to spend more time touring the 50,000 sq. ft. space and grounds. We missed capturing a lot of over-the-top looks, and not just from the performers! Like Sharon says, "When you're going to see drag queens, you've got to up your game." If you want to get in on the fun, sign up for my newsletter, and I'll let you know send you the pre-sale starts for Bushwig 2018! As for Amber Alert's lip-sync performance of Cher's "Turn Back Time," well there were so many reveals that I had to create a special section just for her. Plus, she is my daughter. So here goes: [caption id="attachment_7063" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Amber Alert[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7064" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Amber's reveal #1[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7065" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Reveal #2[/caption] [caption id="attachment_7066" align="aligncenter" width="338"] Amber's finale reveal[/caption] That's my child -- a born entertainer from the age of two. And now, from the true queens of Bushwig 2017 to a real prince...#STILLMYVICEPRESIDENT
I had the extreme pleasure of seeing Joseph R. Biden honored this week at the NYC Anti-Violence Project's 21st Annual Courage Awards, along with other recipients David France, Victoria Cruz, and the cast and crew of The Death and Life of Marsha P. Johnson, and VICE Media. With the current Republican administration's lack of regard or compassion -- and what I'd call outright contempt -- for LGBTQ+ folks, people of color, women, children, Muslims, Jews, and those with disabilities, Joe Biden's remarks gave me a boost of hope and inspired more outspoken courage.The Joe Biden quotes I typed into my phone:
"The law doesn't matter unless it's enforced." "We can change the culture. It is within our power to do it." "Every single person is entitled to be treated with dignity, deserves to be treated with dignity." "Stand with those who feel powerless, to inspire them to take action." "Silence is complicity." Those powerful words are now on a continuous loop in my head. We can can change the culture...Inspire those who feel powerless to take action...Silence is complicit. [caption id="attachment_7082" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Beverly Tillery, center; Victoria Cruz, left, wearing a "We Make a Difference" tee[/caption] Then, before she welcomed trans activist Victoria Cruz to the podium, AVP Executive Director Beverly Tillery asked everyone in the room to "raise our voices as loudly as possible in a shout for freedom, safety, and justice." And we did. "Together, we can accomplish anything," she said. And I believe that. So let's do it! Call or email your representatives in Congress and demand equality, justice, protection and aid for all Americans who need it. Sign petitions; speak up at neighborhood meetings and town halls. Participate in demonstrations when you can, get your friends and family involved. And if you don't have time, give as little or as many dollars as you can to the non-profit organizations who work 24/7 defending the unalienable rights our Constitution guarantees us. Thanks, y'all. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "LGBTQ kids need us more than ever." "Life lessons learned from a drag queen." "An explosion of drag performance, music & love? Must be Bushwig 2015!"October 14, 2017
- 'Does worrying about my gender nonconforming son make me a b ...
Having a child who pushes boundaries when it comes to clothes, makeup, and hair can often create worries for their parents. The mom who wrote to the editors at My Kid Is Gay asking for advice on how to handle her biggest fear also had some doubts about herself. My reply follows her questions below that were sent in anonymously. “My son, who is gender nonconforming, tends to push boundaries when it comes to clothes, makeup, and hair. I personally don’t mind, but I worry that it makes him a target for bullying. Should I talk to him about it or not? I don’t want him to think I’m ashamed of him, although I admit there have been times that I’ve gone places with him and wished he would have dressed more traditionally because I knew the people we were meeting were fairly conservative. Does that make me a bad mom?” Both of your sincerely honest questions here are so important that I had a difficult time deciding which to answer first here. But I want to address the last one upfront, because the doubt you’ve cast on yourself being a good mom doesn’t benefit you or your son. From your lead-in description of him, I can tell the anxieties you’re feeling are grounded in love, respect, and a desire to protect him from adults resistant to cultural change as well any unaccepting peers. To recognize that gender nonconformity is synonymous with pushing boundaries tells me that you are most certainly a champion mom.
The people with conventional views over how a boy dresses are the ones whose beliefs need to be challenged.
You understand your son’s gender expression as a means of self-exploration and discovery, and I’m sure he knows that. In fact, your lead-in statement recognizing and validating his creativity is all you need to remind yourself of when meeting with the “fairly conservative.” The people with conventional views and raised eyebrows over how a boy dresses, styles their hair, or what they apply to their face are the ones whose beliefs need to be challenged. And please know, too, that your son’s boundary pushing in the name of fashion, self-confidence, and personal power will eventually create positive change for others like him. I can relate, though, to the secret feeling of letting him down by wishing at times that he would dress differently. I had a strong twinge of guilty embarrassment too when my now-27-year-old son, Harry, informed me he’d be accepting his high school diploma wearing five-inch, red stiletto heels to match his cap and gown. I begged him to re-consider. I worried he’d be judged by the conservative parents in the auditorium for pushing the personal expression envelope a bit too far. I was also concerned that his graduation outfit would somehow reflect poorly on my parenting skills. [caption id="attachment_6986" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Harry's high school graduation. Photo by Ken Hanson.[/caption] However, the cheers and applause that broke out as Harry sashayed across the stage at his commencement in killer heels filled me with a mixture of relief and pride. My son was being celebrated for having the confidence and personal power to simply be himself! While his dad sat next to me taking photos, I joined the hands clapping their approval for our son. I also realized that Harry’s graduation ceremony was all about him, not about me. It was his focus on freedom of expression and the accompanying joy that mattered most, not the social comfort of his parents or anyone else.The real lesson for us moms of gender nonconforming children is something they already decided for themselves.
Like your son, my kid Harry’s strong sense of self, creativity, and elements of surprise had no doubt pushed our society’s comfort zone of “sameness,” and very likely made people think differently about established gender norms. The real lesson for us moms of gender nonconforming children is something they already decided for themselves: what other people think doesn’t matter. As for your son’s school life, I think it’s natural for the mom of a transgender or gender nonconforming child to fear for their safety. I used to worry, too, that my son would be bullied for his gender expression, and that was long before the Human Rights Campaign reported study results that found that LGBT youth are twice as likely as their peers to say they’ve been physically assaulted, kicked, or shoved. We now know that today’s widespread cyber bullying can also be just as devastating as being bullied in real life. So yes, it’s important for you to check in with your son about bullying, and I do think there are ways to ask about it without projecting your fears onto him. For example, without asking a direct question about the possible bullying behavior of others, you could tell him you’ve been wondering how the other students have reacted to his personal style, or ask how the fashion sense of others holds up to his.12% of millennials identify as transgender or gender nonconforming.
I assure you chances are good that your son isn’t the only breaker of gender norms at his school. GLAAD’s 2017 Accelerating Acceptance report that found 12% of millennials identify as transgender or gender nonconforming. This is the same generation familiar with the “beauty boys” of YouTube and Instagram, who have anywhere from hundreds of thousands to more than a million followers. I admit I used to worry, too, about how my son would be treated at school. I wanted him to fit in, but I quickly learned another important lesson: fitting in means being accepted for who you are. In addition to helping keep your two-way line of communication open, your interest in reactions to his gender expression assures him that you’re proud of him, there for him, and will always have his back. As the good mom that you are, continue to examine your feelings of worry for the lessons that reside there. Celebrate your child for the amazing human he is. Finally, repeat often: my gender nonconforming son tends to push boundaries when it comes to clothes, makeup, and hair. He’s really on the leading edge of thought, and that bodes well for the future of all kids. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "When your son wants to wear eyeliner to Catholic school." "In defiance of gender roles: Clothes!" "Is an 8-year-old too young to know he's gay?"October 6, 2017
- Sep 2017
- Edie Windsor’s fight lives on.
My first face-to-face with iconic LGBTQ rights activist Edie Windsor was actually an encounter with only the two-dimensional images of her that appeared on signs and homemade masks carried by marchers in the 2013 New York City Pride Parade. Her face was everywhere that day. Edie was a grand marshal of the march that year, but just days earlier the U.S. Supreme Court had delivered a landmark decision in her United States v. Windsor case, ruling that couples in same-sex marriages were equally entitled to all federal spousal benefits. And just like that, 84-year-old Edie Windsor became a national hero. Her victory led the way for our country's highest court to declare marriage equality the law of the land in June 2015. And still, the courageous light that was Edie Windsor (June 20, 1929 - September 12, 2017) continued her passionate fight for freedom, equality and justice among LGBTQ communities, especially young people. Of all the stories I’ve read since her passing this week, the one that triggered instant tears was an account by HuffPost's Mollie Reilly of Edie's reaction to the Supreme Court’s ruling in her favor. She had been thinking about the future of LGBTQ kids. “I cried, I cried,” Windsor said of when the ruling came down. “Children born today will grow up in a world without DOMA,” she said. “And those same children who happen to be gay will be free to love and get married – as Thea and I did – but with the same federal benefits, protection and dignity as everyone else.” When I met Edie Windsor face-to-face, I knew we were both thinking about LGBTQ+ youth -- about their future to freely be themselves, to love and be loved, and their protections under the law. It was the same night the Republican Administration announced its withdrawal of federal guidance that protected transgender and gender-nonconforming students in public schools from being discriminated against based on their gender identity.
I watched the firecracker that was Edie Windsor jump to her feet applauding, and I felt her energy ignite the room.
We both attended a February preview of the first episode of the ABC-TV miniseries, “When We Rise,” a docudrama that follows the lives of three young people in the early ’70s who became trailblazers of the LGBTQ rights movement. I was there as a board member for It Gets Better Project and was set to introduce the moderator for a panel discussion following the screening. Edie Windsor was there because, well, she was Edie Windsor, a pioneer for gay and trans rights herself since the sixties. I had no idea she was in the audience until Dustin Lance Black, the show’s writer and director, called her out during his welcoming remarks. The full house whooped and cheered in a standing ovation.As for being a freedom fighter, she was the real deal, with a spirit that exuded love and positivity.
As the lights came up after the screening, I watched the firecracker that was Edie Windsor jump to her feet applauding, and I felt her energy ignite the room. After the panel discussion I had a chance to meet her. Wearing an impeccably tailored black pantsuit and her signature long strand of pearls, she took my hand and greeted me with the smile and warmth of a close friend. As for being a freedom fighter, she was the real deal, with a spirit that exuded love and positivity. Her dedication and commitment to equal rights has enriched my life, spurred me on to my own brand of advocacy and activism, and inspired me to follow her lead in the fight for the youth of today and tomorrow. And for today at least, I’ll be wearing my longest pearls.“Don’t postpone joy." --Edie Windsor
[caption id="attachment_6893" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Judith Kasen-Windsor and Edie Windsor were married in 2016.[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “We must rise up for transgender children.” “6 ways to be a better LGBTQ ally.”September 15, 2017
- Kids' books that celebrate the gender spectrum.
[caption id="attachment_6821" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Early reader Harry, age 10 months[/caption] Thousands of kids in New York City went back to school this week, headed for classrooms and a school library filled with books to stimulate imaginations while teaching diversity among people, places and perspectives. And while teachers and librarians work to instill a love of reading, I want to laud two new books that speak to identity, personal expression and acceptance of differences. I share them with a sense of urgency today, because yesterday I read an article about the West Chicago Library refusing to remove an LGBTQ picture book about a Pride celebration from its children’s section. According to the story, the host of a conservative Christian podcast complained about the images in the book and wanted it “at the very least” moved to the shelves for parents. [caption id="attachment_6820" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Photo: Amazon[/caption] I haven’t read This Day in June, by Gayle E. Pitman, but the images I see on the cover depict people of different ages and colors celebrating all types of families at a Pride festival. And what child can’t relate to rainbows, hearts, dress-up, parades and community? In fact, it was the so-called-Christian complainer’s 3-year-old daughter who pulled the book off the shelf in the first place. Here's what I know: Fear is learned. Hatred is learned. Intolerance of differences is learned. Transphobia and homophobia are learned. And none are learned from children’s picture books at the public library.
The uniqueness of others is something to be cheered, not feared.
I'm hopeful you'll continue to add LGBTQ-themed books to your child’s home library. There are so many colorful stories in print that can help kids in your family -- and you -- understand that their precious individuality and the uniqueness of others is something to be cheered, not feared. These books celebrating diversity make wonderful gifts for other children, too, or for your local school library. I have read and can highly recommend the newest LGBTQ children's picture books: Sparkle Boy, by Lesléa Newman and Who Are You?, by Brook Pessin-Whedbee. I wish I’d had Newman’s latest children's book for my gender-nonconforming kid Harry when he was a toddler in the early ‘90s. The story would have assured him that bedazzled clothes, glittery nail polish and shiny jewelry are simply fun choices of personal expression. And it would have been a good cue for his dad and me to ask, “Why not?” with more confidence. The real lesson in the book comes from Sparkle Boy Casey’s sister Jessie, who thinks boys aren’t supposed to wear skirts, polish or bracelets. But when she defends her little brother against boys who tease him at the library, she realizes they can both like the same things. (Newman, by the way, is also the author of the children’s book, Heather Has Two Mommies.) Who Are You?: A Kid’s Guide to Gender Identity is the best book I’ve seen to help children 5+ understand the broad, colorful spectrum of gender diversity. And it’s not just for children! Reading these pages would have given me a much better answer than the one I came up with when Harry asked me at two years old how I knew he was a boy. And remembering how I didn’t understand the word cisgender until about five years ago, I have a feeling there are plenty of adults who would appreciate this straightforward primer on bodies, gender identity and personal expression. It also busts the gender stereotypes still so often imposed on kids. There’s a short page-by-page guide for adults in the back, and the inside back cover holds the bonus of an interactive rainbow wheels for kids to explore what they have, what they are and what they like. I hope you’ll bookmark this page to remember these books and also refer to the lists below of LGBTQ children’s and picture books that were put together by two of the children's librarians at the Scarsdale Library for a talk I gave there last March. Happy reading and happy celebrating, y’all! [caption id="attachment_6823" align="aligncenter" width="388"] Prepared by Children's Librarians Eileen Corbett & Sarah Rodriguez, The Scarsdale Public Library, March 2017[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “5 back-to-school books that celebrate kids of all genders.” “New LGBTQ history book for teens is a must-read for straight parents.” “LGBTQ kids need us more than ever.” “Transgender kids are changing the world.”September 8, 2017
- Aug 2017
- The sisterhood of drag.
I opened the email confirmation my kid Harry sent me for her* upcoming flight to Toronto and smiled. The ticket had been issued to “Sister” Harry James. I immediately flashed on Harry and her neighborhood bestie Erica dressed up as nuns for Halloween 2002. I was surprised Harry hadn’t chosen the name prefix “Mx” from Air Canada’s list of options. (Mx is the gender-neutral equivalent of “Mr” or “Ms” and the obvious option for nonbinary people, like Harry.) For fun, when booking travel for the two of us in the past, I’ve chosen the title Doctor or Rabbi for Harry. So I thought she was just playing along. But I soon realized it was I who had overlooked the obvious. A few days after sending me her passenger info, Harry took me to see the monthly sell-out drag show, “Nightgowns,” curated, produced and hosted by Sasha Velour, winner of RuPaul’s Drag Race Season 9. In addition to her recent celebrity as American’s Drag Superstar, Sasha is also creative director of Velour: The Drag Magazine and a notable queer Brooklyn-based artist. Let me just say this about Sasha and me: She is a remarkable human being, and I am a huge fan. It was at "Nightgowns," in an onstage introductory convo between Sasha Velour and her co-host Olive d’Nightlife, that I came to understand what I thought might be the true meaning of “Sister Harry.” [caption id="attachment_6687" align="aligncenter" width="500"] l to r: Sasha Velour and Olive d'Nightlife[/caption] Cocktails in hand, Olive raised her glass to celebrate the beautiful third edition of Velour. “And now we must toast to the theme of this magazine,” she said. “Sisters and sisterhoods, those that you’re born into and those that we get to create.” “Especially the ones we get to create using our fabulous queer sensibilities,” Sasha replied. “To all of our families that nourish us and create us.” I felt a tingling run from my scalp to my fingertips. And as the audience whooped and applauded, I was filled by the love in that space. I turned for a second to pat Harry’s arm. I knew in that moment that my kid was part of a big and powerful community, a family that would always be there for her even when her born-into family wasn’t close by. I understood Harry referring to her drag artist friends Charlene and Lucy, among others, as sisters. And I felt I knew Sister Harry a little bit better, too. [caption id="attachment_6741" align="aligncenter" width="500"] l to r: Sisters Charlene and Harry. Photo by: Gypsy Hill[/caption] Lastly, Sasha and Olive toasted to drag, to all the kinds of drag. And according to Sasha, the more different the types of drag the better. She gave props to drag kings, drag queens, trans performers, non-binary artists, lady queens, and trans lady queens. Then she challenged us to think of other kinds of drag. “The future of drag is not complete without all of us,” she said. “We will not rest until drag beauty is everywhere.” [caption id="attachment_6740" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Sasha Velour's lip-sync performance to Edith Piaf's "No Regrets" (in English)[/caption] Inspired by the sisterhood of drag performers, I couldn’t wait to devour every page of Velour #3. When I'd finished, the magazine was filled with dozens of pastel-colored sticky tabs marking passages that had taught me something new or made me think hard about what it means to be a creative person with “fabulous queer sensibilities” and identify as a drag sister. [caption id="attachment_6758" align="aligncenter" width="375"] Velour: The Drag Magazine[/caption] In the editor’s letter, co-written by Sasha and Olive, Sasha describes drag as a showcase for how beautiful, glamorous, funny and emotional it can be to live free from strict gender roles, or binaries. My eyes brimmed reading that, because I had witnessed that same beauty, humor and joy in Harry as a toddler. Whether dancing in a bridal gown she’d created with a roll of toilet paper at age 2, twirling a tulle skirt in the kindergarten drama corner, or layering pieces from her own dress-up box, my little drag-queen-in-the-making’s heart was filled with pure joy – the joy that I have since come to recognize as the purpose of life. That innate happiness is effortless for children who are given the freedom to express their inner selves fully and openly. And I know that joy can be tapped at any age. Reading the “Sister” issue of Velour magazine confirmed what I already knew to be true: drag queens are insightful and intuitive uplifters. They represent the creative spirit in all of us to project our creativity and inner beauty outward, for all to enjoy. I’m grateful that Sister Harry – and her drag persona Sister Amber Alert – have their close-knit drag sisterhood. I know they are cared for, protected and safe within that big, fun family. If you're the parent or family member of an up-and-coming young drag queen, someone possibly still in kindergarten or middle school, please know that your child has a sisterhood of love and support waiting that will never let them down. [caption id="attachment_6744" align="aligncenter" width="500"] The one and only RuPaul[/caption] *Note: Harry told me recently that I can use any pronoun I want when referring to him. "Mom, I just don't care!" So I often use he/him/his and she/her/hers interchangeably. Because this post is about sisterhood, I've chosen "she/her/hers." IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "My son's first drag idol was a cross-dressing rabbit." "Life lessons learned from a drag queen." "A beauty tip & big questions from my fave drag queen."
August 25, 2017
- Gender stereotyping redux.
After a recent run-in with a children’s sticker, I wrote the piece “Stickers don’t have a gender.” I thought a 2-year-old girl at the local dry cleaner looked puzzled when she was expected to like a Hello Kitty sticker. The owner of the shop had just assumed a girl would be happier with Hello Kitty than she would with Pixar Cars. Later, the toddler’s mom told me her daughter actually would have preferred the Cars option. So I blogged about how the gendering of toys, colors and clothing “confuses” kids. Then I received some thoughtful comments on social media. Here are a few of the shared thoughts that made me re-think my word choice: “I would say it restricts them. The only thing that confused me was when I confessed I had a crush on another boy in first grade, and everyone called me a fag. Didn't know what it meant.” It sure as hell confused me. It was a lot of arbitrary rules of what I was supposed to like and not like, and everyone was very sure of it and very disappointed of me…” “I disagree tbh, I’ve dealt with a lot of kids and in my experience at least there has been no confusion.” I agree that the stereotypes confuse them. I just don’t think that they should be born genderless as it complicates things and for now, at that young age, they and their friends won’t be able to comprehend it.” I thanked the person who suggested gender stereotyping “restricts” kids. It really speaks to a more universal truth, because gender stereotypes pigeonhole children into the either-or binary boxes of pink and blue. And I realized it was only “some” children who might be confused by our society's established expectations about gender. My adult non-binary child Harry, who has preferred dresses and skirts since pre-school, was only six when he told me, “Girls have a real advantage, because they can wear whatever they want and play sports.” He wasn’t confused; he was simply annoyed. It was the last comment above however that really struck me, from the person who believed children shouldn’t be “born genderless” and that they can’t understand the idea of gender neutral. They were addressing not just the stereotyping of toys and clothes, but the whole idea of traditional gender roles and norms for kids. And I zeroed in on perhaps the best description of gender stereotyping: It limits kids.
“It’s all about democracy – for children to have the right to be how they feel they are.” --Lotta Rajalin, founder of the Swedish preschool Egalia
In case you missed it, take the time to watch the recent VICE special “Raised without Gender.” The half-hour show takes a close at Sweden, the world’s most progressive country when it comes to questioning gender and allowing children to grow up outside of the gender binary. It had me wishing I could have raised Harry in Sweden. The country introduced the gender-neutral pronoun “hen” in the '60s and it was added to the dictionary two years ago. A 1998 amendment to the Swedish government’s Education Act forbids enforcing gender stereotypes. A guide states: “The preschool should counteract traditional gender roles. Girls and boys should have the same opportunities to try things and develop interests without the limitation of typical gender norms. “It’s all about democracy – for children to have the right to be how they feel they are,” says Lotta Rajalin, who founded the country’s first gender-neutral preschool, Egalia, in 2010. “We are not limiting, we’re adding. We’re not changing children, we are changing our own thoughts.” As for the future, I'm hopeful the ongoing conversations about gender identity and gender expression, along with the sea change of hearts and minds on the subject both here and abroad, will give kids the freedom to discover gender all by themselves. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Fighting for kids in the gender revolution." "President Obama's letter to moms of LGBTQ kids." "We must rise up for transgender children."August 11, 2017
- Jul 2017
- Stickers don't have a gender.
Wearing a chambray dress and purple sun hat, a two-year-old girl entered my local drycleaners holding onto the side of an empty a stroller pushed by her mom. “Get the Hello Kitty stickers,” the shop’s owner Kim whispered excitedly to her associate, George. She was off to the side waiting for my cleaning to come around on the conveyor. “I give all the kids a sticker,” she said with a wink. I watched as George held out a sheet of Hello Kitty stickers. “What about this one?” he asked. She turned her gaze to the floor, so he peeled off a sticky and gently pressed it to her forearm. She looked at it expressionless. By then, Kim was at George’s side, beaming with expectation that her little surprise had delighted yet another pint-sized customer. But I didn’t think the girl looked all that happy; I thought she look puzzled. “Hey, Kim,” I said, “I’m wondering if you give all the kids Hello Kitty.” “Oh, no,” she replied with certainty. “Little Kitty is for girls. Boys get Disney cars.” “Well, I’ll tell you,” I said smiling, “My boy would have wanted the Hello Kitty sticker.” I didn’t know whether or not Kim was flashing back to any of beaded dresses and tops of Harry’s I used to bring in during his summers home from college, but she was definitely processing my comment. “Maybe next time try letting the kids choose which they want. You might be surprised.” “Huh,” Kim remarked, as if the idea had never crossed her mind.
Moms today still notice when people put society’s expectations for boys and girls onto their kids.
“Thank you for that,” the mom said when we both got outside. “I know Sarah would have preferred one of the car stickers. I’ve run into this before, at her preschool and even with relatives, where people just assume she’s going to want the ‘girl’ toy or activity.” She gestured air quotes at “girl.” On my way home, I remembered strangers’ expectations of Harry at two years old, when his very clear preference was for Barbie dolls, My Little Pony and Polly Pocket. We’ve come a long way in understanding the burden we put on kids to conform to established norms, but moms today still notice when people put society’s expectations for boys and girls onto their kids.There’s not just one way to be a boy or a girl.
We see the messages our children get from others that they’re supposed to like certain toys, clothes and colors based solely on their body parts. And we see how those messages confuse kids, because they know what they like, what they want to play with or wear, and it has nothing to do with the sex they were assigned at birth or the gender role they’re expected to take on because of that assignment. From my point of view it’s up to us adults to challenge gender stereotypes when we see them and clue others into a little gender-stereotyping awareness. We can suggest that they think differently about what they’ve learned about expectations for boys and girls and consider some re-learning. It’s also our responsibility to teach all children that there’s not just one way to be a boy or a girl. There are simply many ways to be a kid: boy, girl, a little bit of both or perhaps, like my kid Harry, neither. And none of the ways to be kid is based on body parts. It’s based on what they know about themselves. So let’s encourage kids to like what they like, even if it’s different from what other kids like. A child is just a small human with a soul, spirit and energy. We must allow children to express their joy – and approve of it – on every step of their journey to discovering their true selves. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "4 lessons for parents of gender-nonconforming kids." "Baby gifts: my double whammy of gender stereotyping." "The 'gender angel' for gender-nonconforming kids."July 28, 2017
- Is an 8-year-old too young to know he's gay?
his Let' say you're the straight parent of a young child who happily tells you they're gay. Do you know how you would react or respond? This latest column for My Kid Is Gay offers some "do's" and "don'ts" to bring out your best inner parent. My advice follows the question that asks if an 8-year-old is too young to know he's gay. “My 8-year-old son is self-identifying as gay. He has grown up in a household where sexuality is openly discussed and his aunt is gay. Is this too young to understand? I asked him if he understood what gay meant. He said, "Um, Mom, I want to marry a boy when I grown up." My husband and I have a difference of opinion on how to proceed. Please help.”
Not all kids are straight.
First off, I want to congratulate you and your husband for creating a gay-positive environment in your home. When every parent can say their child is growing up in a home where sexuality is openly discussed, we will have moved that much closer to a society that fully accepts and respects the spectrum that exists in how we love and who we love. I’m hopeful you both realize how loved and safe your son must feel to share what he knows about himself with you. As a society we tend to assume that all kids are straight, but that is just not true. In addition to teaching your son about sexuality and the variety that exists in romantic attractions, I applaud you for giving him the language to express his sensibility of love and affection. His simple explanation of wanting to marry a boy when he grows up reflects an understanding of what the possibilities are for love, and how natural it is to be gay.Most people think that gay people come out as teenagers (or later).
Your son’s answer about what it means to be gay also makes me wonder if maybe he has a crush on another boy. And that, too, would be perfectly natural! Experts say kids usually develop their first childhood crush at age 5 or 6. Kindergarten teachers will tell you that playground weddings at recess are not uncommon, and I can even remember my son fashioning a wedding dress out of toilet paper before he was 3. If your son is crushing, he obviously isn’t feeling any pressure to crush on a girl or think there’s something wrong with him for wanting to marry a boy someday. Even adults who think a first crush is cute and innocent -- and not an indicator of the child’s sexuality -- typically still default to the idea that a child is going to fall in love with and marry someone of the same gender. That tends to be true even when there’s someone in the family who’s gay, like his aunt.An 8-year-old is not too young to know who he is.
It sounds to me like you and/or your husband assumed your 8-year-old was straight, and now that he’s told you otherwise, with a good grasp of what it means to be gay, you are surprised and don’t understand how he could know that at his age. I don’t think you’re alone in that belief, but I’m here to tell you that an 8-year-old is not too young to know he's gay. Most people think that gay people come out as teenagers (or later), and that they couldn’t possibly know about sexuality before puberty. But with heightened visibility of LGBTQ people and a progressive shift in social attitudes – your own family, for example – children are feeling safe to come out at younger ages. My son was eight years old when he told his dad and me in 1998 that he was “different from other boys.” He didn’t have the education or language that your son has to be so articulate, nor did he have LGBTQ-themed children’s books or the vast number of openly LGBTQIA celebrities in music, sports, or television that exist today.Some parents worry about their child being happy or having a difficult life because they’re gay.
You asked for advice on how to proceed, and that’s normal. This is presumably uncharted territory for you and your husband. Some parents worry about their child being happy or having a difficult life because they’re gay. So if you’re among them, here are a few Do’s and Don’ts I have for you on how to proceed as the parents of a happily out, gay 8-year-old.Do's for parents.
DO: Believe him. Trust your son to know himself, regardless of his age. How he thinks about his sexuality today might change, or it might not. My son first came out to his dad and me as bisexual. Later, he told us he was gay and later still as nonbinary. Validate and accept him for where he is today. DO: Love him unconditionally, whether he’s gay, bisexual, or straight. Tell him you love him and always will, just for being the amazing kid he is. DO: Follow your son’s lead and be open to further discussion. Let him know he can always talk to you about anything and that you’re there to answer any questions he might have about love or relationships as best you can. DO: Be patient. Personal growth is a lifetime journey of discovering who we are, and our orientation is just one small part of that. DO: Talk to his aunt. You might be surprised to learn there was a time gap between when she realized she was gay and when she first told someone. Talking to other gay people, too, can help put the coming out age in perspective for you. DO: Mention his orientation to his teachers (with your son’s permission, of course). Let them know you expect him to be fully supported at school. DO: Take some time for yourself to get comfortable with the idea that your son identifies as gay. If you have more questions, I strongly recommend you pick of up copy of This Is a Book for Parents of Gay Kids. The book’s question-and-answer format makes it easy to find just what you’re looking for. DO: Find a parent support group. If you or your husband are having difficulty adjusting to the idea that your second grader is gay, seek out your local PFLAG chapter. You’ll quickly learn that you’re not alone. DO: Educate yourself. Understand the issues that LGBTQIA kids face in school. Become involved in the movement for equality. That could mean simply becoming a voice for your child’s rights as an individual. Familiarize yourself with LGBTQ history. Kids and adults alike should know that queer people stretch back across every generation of human existence. And that there’s nothing wrong or abnormal about being gay. Finally learn the language of sexual orientation, gender identity, and gender expression. There’s a good chance your son may already know more terms than you or your husband do. DO: Hug your son often. Tell him you love him. Repeat. Because an 8 year old is not too young to know he's gay.Don'ts for parents.
DON’T: Focus on your expectations. Your child's coming out has nothing to do with you or what you imagined their life would be like. DON’T: Worry so much. Save that for when they want a driver’s license! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "What if your child comes out on social media before telling you?" "When a child comes out to only one parent." "When a dad thinks being gay is being a 'sissy.'"July 14, 2017
- Jun 2017
- Photos & footnotes from #NYCPride.
A PRIDE PARTY WITH A VIEW
My last week of Pride Month reached some new heights, starting with a Penthouse Pride celebration to benefit It Gets Better. Photographer Levi Foster, actor Joslyn DeFreece and celeb EJ Johnson hosted the beautiful Saturday afternoon event atop The Standard Hotel in New York City's East Village. [caption id="attachment_6600" align="aligncenter" width="600"] l to r: Levi Foster, EJ Johnson and Joslyn DeFreece (Image: Diana Zapata, dianazapata.com)[/caption] In welcoming everyone, each of the three hosts spoke from the heart about what their life was like as an LGBTQ youth and how it got better for them. As Levi Foster spoke of having no gay role models or sense of someone to identify with as a kid, I couldn’t help but think of my own child, Harry, growing up in the nineties. And I got a little misty when Levi compared It Gets Better to a lighthouse for youth around the world. “We are a vibrant, diverse community,” he said, “waiting for them with open arms.” [caption id="attachment_6607" align="aligncenter" width="401"] Levi Foster (Image: Diana Zapata, dianazapata.com)[/caption] The wonderful people I met at Penthouse Pride, were all so supportive of the It Gets Better Project's work to uplift, empower and connect LGBTQ+ youth across the globe through personal stories of hope, determination and resilience. There is an It Gets Better story for every kid who feels alone. [caption id="attachment_6608" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Image: Diana Zapata, dianazapata.com[/caption] And my bonus was catching up with the staff and other board members who are based in Los Angeles. I consider it a privilege to work with them. [caption id="attachment_6604" align="aligncenter" width="500"] l to r: Fellow It Gets Better Board Member Kassie Thornton, Executive Director Brian Wenke, Board Member Christy Spitzer Thornton & Me[/caption] After the event, Levi Foster talked about hosting a big NYC holiday party for It Gets Better. I know it’s a little hard to think about December right now, but that would be fun! [caption id="attachment_6605" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Best-dressed, Penthouse Pride Pup, Lola[/caption]BEHIND THE SCENES WITH PFLAG
I loved hanging out pre-Pride Parade with the loving and pride-filled parents, families, and friends of LGBTQ+ kids who make up the PFLAG chapters of New York, New Jersey and Connecticut. On Sunday, we numbered 260 proud activists! [caption id="attachment_6612" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Me and the mom whose eyelashes I want next year.[/caption] PFLAG National has been helping families stay close and stand up for their LGBTQ loved ones for 45 years. While I saw those feelings of love, protection and safety represented on signs, it was most evident on faces. You’ll see what I mean as you scroll down my album. We even had a celebrity among us! None other than nine-year-old drag star Desmond Napoles of Brooklyn. Desmond has marched in the NYC Pride Parade since 2015. The outfit he designed for 2017 was a head-to-toe tribute to drag superstar RuPaul, grounded with colorful sneakers. According to Desmond’s dad, he's not allowed to wear heels in the parade. Heels or not, the aspiring drag queen and writer sure knows how to strike a pose. And how I wish I'd had Desmond's mom, Wendylou, as a role model when Harry was that age and wanted to wear clothes from his dress-up box 24/7.BUSHWIG 2017!!!!!!!
Okay, I know it’s only been summer officially for about ten days, and I’ve already mentioned December, but early-bird tickets for Bushwig 2017 are now on sale! The two-day festival of drag, music and love will be held September 23rd and 24th at the Knockdown Center in Queens (of course), New York. [caption id="attachment_6621" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Design: BCALLA[/caption] Ru Paul’s Drag Race Season 9 winner Sasha Velour will headline. (I was definitely Team Sasha this season.) Other Drag Race alumni performing this year include Alaska, Violet Chachki, Thorgy Thor and Pearl. And, of course, Mz. Amber Alert, the ever-amazing blend of gorgeous/filthy (aka my kid Harry), will be taking the stage as well. Trust me, Bushwig is a reason to visit NYC in the fall! [caption id="attachment_6622" align="aligncenter" width="486"] Amber Alert and Me, Bushwig 2013[/caption] ‘QUEER KID STUFF’ Speaking of drag, if you’re not sure how you’d explain it to a child or even tell an adult what drag is all about, you’re going to love the new “Ms. Ter” episode in Lindsay Amer’s Queer Kid Stuff educational webseries. It really makes so much sense! Check it out below. So cool, right?! I’m going to adopt one of Ms. Ter’s descriptions of drag for the next I get asked about it. I absolutely LOVE the idea that drag queens are the hosts of the queer community. I wish you a Happy Fourth of July holiday. May it be filled with individual freedom, feelings of independence and equality, and a whole lotta Pride, because that never goes out of season. And for us parents, family, and friends of the LGBTQ+ community, let's remember how important it is to give trans and queer youth a voice each and every day. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Orlando: My tears, fears, and hopes." "My Gay Pride glow segues to fireworks of freedom." "Gay Pride is an outlook."June 30, 2017
- Irony and honor for First Mom of PFLAG.
In his inaugural year, the 45th president of our country has issued proclamations for June as National Home Ownership Month, National Ocean Month, and Great Outdoors Month. But in a shameful lack of action, he has failed to acknowledge June as Pride Month. Ironically, while “45” egregiously turns his back on the LGBTQ+ community, there’s another 45 that towers with honor above his lack of compassion and leadership. This year marks the 45th anniversary that Queens elementary school teacher and PFLAG co-founder Jeanne Manford became the lead support mom for LGBTQ youth and adult children everywhere. If you’re unfamiliar with Jeanne, I want to share some of her remarkable story with you this celebratory weekend of the NYC Pride March.
“I have a homosexual son and I love him.” –Jeanne Manford, Letter to the Editor, New York Post, April 29, 1972
Jeanne’s advocacy began with a letter. In April 1972, her gay activist son, Morty, was kicked and beaten at a political gathering by a leading opponent of New York City’s gay rights bill while police just stood by. Outraged, Jeanne wrote a letter to the editor of the New York Post defending her son and calling out the police for doing nothing to stop the attack. Her letter included this declaration: “I have a homosexual son and I love him.” Two months later, on June 25, 1972, Jeanne marched for the first time, with Morty, in New York’s Christopher Street Liberation Day Parade (the predecessor to today’s Pride March). They were commemorating the third anniversary of the Stonewall Rebellion, in which Morty had participated. Jeanne’s now-famous, hand-lettered sign read: “Parents of Gays Unite in Support for Our Children.” Being gay was still considered a mental illness in 1972, and there was tremendous hate spewed at LGBTQ people and their supporters."...few of them were out to their parents for fear of rejection."
In a 1996 interview with the Los Angeles Times, Jeanne recounted the cheers she received in that first parade, and that "young people were hugging me, kissing me, screaming, asking if I would talk to their parents ... [as] few of them were out to their parents for fear of rejection." It was that outpouring of love and appreciation that prompted Jean and her husband, Jules, to launch an organization comprised of the parents of gays and lesbians that she hoped would be "a bridge between the gay community and the heterosexual community.” The historic New York Times photograph above of Jeanne and Morty is a national scrapbook remembrance of the verve, determination, and parental devotion that led to the founding of PFLAG, today our country’s largest family and ally organization. And it also marks the beginning of decades of activism. [caption id="attachment_6564" align="aligncenter" width="500"] NPR image: Jeanne Maford, Pride Parade in Queens, NY 1993[/caption] In 1990, at 70 years old, Jeanne retired from teaching. The following year she was grand marshal of the NYC Pride March. Her advocacy work continued after Morty’s untimely death from AIDS in1992, at age 41. She was named grand marshal of the first Pride Parade in Queens in 1993, and organized a local PFLAG chapter there. In a televised speech in October 2009, at the annual Human Rights Campaign dinner, President Obama spoke as he so eloquently does of Jeanne Manford's founding of PFLAG. His three-minute tribute to Jeanne will move you emotionally and most likely also move you to act. A year after Jeanne Manford died, in February 2013, the White House announced that President Obama would honor her posthumously with the 2012 Presidential Citizens Medal for her work in co-founding PFLAG and her ongoing years of LGBTQ advocacy. Jeanne’s daughter Suzanne Manford Swan, accepted the award on her behalf at a White House ceremony on February 15. President Obama said of Jeanne’s initial letter to the New York Post, "that simple act" provided the impetus for a national organization "that has given so much support to parents and families and friends, and helped to change this country." Each year with the PFLAG group at NYC’s Pride Parade I’m reminded of Jeanne’s hope that families get the support and encouragement they need to love their LGBTQ kids unconditionally. I see her legacy personified in the energy of thousands of proud parents, families, and allies who march in Pride parades across the country. I hope you’ll join a Pride March if you can, or just go to one to cheer in the celebration. Please become engaged in this year of dire need: Call your elected state officials and demand equal rights and freedoms for LGBTQ people, donate an LGBTQ children’s book to community library or a queer history book to a school library, visit itgetsbetter.org to make a video of support for LGBTQ youth, or donate to any of the national nonprofits who work to change minds and make a difference in the lives of those who face continual discrimination, intolerance and, often times, violence. Like Jeanne Manford, let’s all commit to speak up and stand up against injustice wherever we see it. When following the rainbow, there’s always more work to be done. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "My NYC Pride weekend: Amber performs, rainbows wave & love wins." “Gay Pride is an outlook.”June 23, 2017
- Gender nonconforming kids need fierce dads
“I have a Harry,” a young dad in Minneapolis-St. Paul told me last month, as I signed a copy of my book for him. I’d heard that before and knew it meant that his five-year-old son liked playing with dolls and wearing mom’s heels. “I’m okay with it,” he said, “but my wife isn’t quite there yet.” While we didn’t get into the reasons his spouse was struggling to understand their child, I liked the optimism he projected with the word “yet.” I saw endless love, acceptance, and support reflected in his eyes. How fortunate that little boy and his no-doubt-worried mom are to have someone so secure and grounded in their family of three, I thought. I know firsthand that gender nonconforming kids need fierce dads. That dad crossed my mind this Father’s Day weekend. He’s a reminder of the growing number of straight, cisgender men who are rejecting society’s stereotypical ideas of masculinity and “proper” male role models for their sons. I reflected on comments my now-adult kid Harry’s awesome dad Ken made last September at my book event in hometown Milwaukee.
“Gay back then was the worst term of derision,” he said, “and it usually preceded getting beat up by somebody.”
“I think we mature generationally,” Ken began, as he told the story of how his father, a modern guy for his time, had worried about Ken as a creative kid who didn’t conform one hundred percent of the time attending a small-town high school. “Gay back then was the worst term of derision,” he said, “and it usually preceded getting beat up by somebody.”“I grew up caring about what other people thought and believing one had to have the approval of people, but Harry taught me otherwise.”
Safety first.
Ken shared that his first concern when Harry came out in high school was for our son's safety. “Because I loved him so much, my concern was that people would hurt him emotionally,” he said. “So my number one objective was to be there for him.” Ken told the audience that in the process of being there for Harry, he also learned from him. “I grew up caring about what other people thought and believing one had to have the approval of people, but Harry taught me otherwise,” Ken said, describing himself as lucky to be our kid's dad. “There’s a confidence about being himself; Harry defined for me self-love in a way that I thought was very healthy.” When I think about Ken’s dad as a high school student the sixties, Ken as Harry’s dad since the nineties, and the fierce 21st century dad of the fortunate five-year-old in Minnesota, I see the generational shift in knowledge and growth Ken talked about so thoughtfully last fall. And I’ve seen the confidence kids get from the freedom that comes with being allowed to be themselves and express gender as they see it in ways that give them absolute joy. The world needs boys who can nurture and girls who question authority. So I think it follows that fathers be as proud of their young sons who dress up as Wonder Woman as they are of their daughters who want to be Batman. Happy Father’s Day to the evolving, gender-revolutionary dads everywhere. Gender nonconforming kids need fierce dads. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “My (genderqueer) son’s awesome dad.” “Giving a boy a dress will not make him gay.” “Don’t be your gender creative kid’s first bully.”June 16, 2017
- LGBTQ history book for teens is a must-read for straight par ...
Last night I went to bed with George Takei. And Abraham Lincoln, too. The two men, along with 21 other influential queer figures from the Roman Empire to present day, joined me from the pages of Queer, There, and Everywhere, a new LGBTQ history book for teens by Quist app founder Sarah Prager. While I know George Takei is happily married to his husband Brad, I had no idea that young Lincoln probably wouldn’t have been interested in me romantically either. Clearly, the white, straight, cisgender men who authored the history books I read in school had only assumed the sexualities and gender identities of the historical figures they wrote about. In her introduction to Queer, There, and Everywhere, Prager acknowledges how the term “queer” continues to change. At one time a hurtful slur that still conjures up painful memories for some, it’s been reclaimed as an umbrella term for a broad community. For the purpose of her book, Sarah uses “queer” to mean “anyone not totally straight or not totally cisgender—anyone outside society’s gender and sexuality norms.”
Regardless of how differently societies construct their lines of acceptable gender expression, there are always people who cross those lines.
So yes, Abraham Lincoln, who shared a bed with another man for four years, was queer, as was former First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt, who had a relationship with another woman during her marriage to FDR. Then there’s Jeanne D’Arc, whose official decree for being burned at the stake was her refusal to wear women’s clothes. And there are countless other lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer world-history makers you’ve never heard of. The truth is, queer people stretch back across every generation of human existence. At her NYC book launch, Prager explained that even though terms like gay and transgender are relatively recent, queerness is not a new fad. Regardless of how differently societies construct their lines of acceptable gender expression, there are always people who cross those lines. I learned that in the 1990s from my own gender nonconforming child. But I had no idea that in the early 200s the mother of Rome’s teenage emperor Elagabalus might have shared some of my same parenting experiences. In a fun, breezy, can’t-put-it-down style, Sarah Prager presents a side of 23 trailblazing activists in science, literature, politics, sports, religion and human rights that you wouldn’t get in another history book. Not only are these fascinating, meticulously researched short stories true, they’re written with such insight that one gets the sense of what each of these historic individuals was actually feeling. [caption id="attachment_6473" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Author Sarah Prager, at the Bureau of General Services-Queer Division, NYC.[/caption] I’m excited for the teens that are just now figuring out they’re different to see how some of the most remarkable and influential people in human history preceded them. Sarah’s prose also includes empowering messages for queer youth throughout her short stories, like, "Live your life full out as yourself, no matter what others think." And I’m eager for the peers of LGBTQ teens to see the tremendous contributions queer people have made to world history.I could have been so much more of an uplifter for my child.
This is the book I wish I could have given to my kid Harry when they were discovering their gender self and sexuality. And it would have helped me, too. I remember being both awe-struck and proud when I first learned in a movie theater that the man who invented the computer and cracked the Nazi Enigma code, Brit Alan Turing, was gay. And if I’d had the powerful histories of these 23 queer people who changed the world, I could have been so much more of an uplifter for my child. I would have loved to quote for Harry the 1950s San Francisco drag queen, José Sarria, who took a bold stand against police harassment and would close her performances with the words, “Believe in yourself, and work to change the system.”We must all help today’s LGBTQ kids know their value and their place in world history.
While Sarah Prager wrote Queer, There, and Everywhere for a teen audience, it’s a valuable resource for adults too. In fact I think it’s a must-read for every straight, cisgender parent. It's our adult duty to help today’s LGBTQ kids know their value and their place in world history. And it’s important to give gender-conforming youth the educational tools they need to be upstanders and allies for queer kids. Let’s all work to leave behind a 21st century world history of equality, respect, and pride. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "LGBTQ history in the making." "Gender confusion? It's all in the minds of confused adults." "For every girl who...there's a boy who..."June 2, 2017
- May 2017
- Drag queens, non-stop fun & my gender revelation.
Mistie Bonet, Miss Toto, Tarah Cards, and Kimberly Clark were among the fabulous drag royalty I cheered at the inaugural Bushwig South festival of queer culture, experimental music and love in New Orleans over my long Mother’s Day weekend trip with Harry. I promised in my last post to share pictures of the outfit my kid Harry (aka drag artist Amber Alert) styled for me, and Amber’s awesome look, too. So have a look below and keep scrolling, because there are a few more fave photos from the fest, including one of the queen who triggered a remarkable little convo between Harry and me. [caption id="attachment_6423" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Yours truly, feeling like a stick of dynamite in my Tyler Wallach "American Beauty" print dress.[/caption] [caption id="attachment_6446" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Amber en route to Bushwig South. The girl has ALWAYS known how to turn a look.[/caption] [caption id="attachment_6438" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Me feeling like Queen for a Day on Mother's Day Eve in the Bushwig performers' staging area.[/caption] Amber, by the way, clued me in that the gold metallic thread in my vintage-thrift Palazzo pants is called Lurex. Of course, she would know that. [caption id="attachment_6432" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Just had to include this shirt of Katya & Trixie Mattel.[/caption] [caption id="attachment_6427" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Performers Charlene onstage and Ickarus on the ground.[/caption] The awesome leaf sculpture pictured above was just one of many at host venue Castillo Blanco Art Studios. My favorite was R2D2 in lipstick. [caption id="attachment_6435" align="aligncenter" width="450"] Smokin'.[/caption] [caption id="attachment_6430" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Queen Hannah Lou, her friend Alexis, Amber & another fab sculpture.[/caption] The queen I connected with the most was NOLA native Tarah Cards. I loved her zigzag-striped body suit, flaming red hair, bubble umbrella, and eclectic mash up of diva power tunes. But it was the interspersed taped quotes from eccentric, eye-patch-wearing Nadine Hurley of Twin Peaks that released my epiphany. [caption id="attachment_6434" align="aligncenter" width="600"] It was all in the Tarah Cards for me.[/caption] It was after Tarah's lip-sync of Nadine's “I’m going to have the world’s first one hundred percent quiet runner" that I turned to Harry's ear with the confession that somewhere deep inside my soul, there was a drag queen waiting to be unleashed. Harry laughed. "I've always thought of you as somewhat gender-nonconforming, Mom." "You have?" I asked, feeling wholly validated. "Sure. Don't you remember what I told you about your wardrobe when I was two?" I flashed back to an afternoon in the fall of 1992 where Harry was waiting for me at the back door when I arrived home from work. “You don’t have any dresses!” he accused. His nanny informed me that Harry had wanted to look in my closet that day. My pint-sized fashionista had nailed it. I wore skirt suits or dress pants to the office and jeans or leggings at home. “I have a purple dress. Did you see that?” He shook his head. “You need more dresses, Momma.” And there I stood in a billowy pair of silk pants, eager to jump on stage and let my freak flag fly. I couldn't remember the last time I'd felt so free to express my inner diva. I smiled up at Amber, so appreciating her wit and wisdom. It was a very special mother-child moment of the gender nonconforming kind I'll never forget. I’d planned to have someone at the festival take a photo of Amber and me together, but somehow I forgot. It’s so easy to get caught up in the fantasy, fun, and magic of Bushwig! On our last night, when I realized no photo of the two of us in NOLA existed, we took a selfie on the balcony of our Airbnb. I'll be sure to get a glamour head-to-toe shot of us together at Bushwig 2017 in September. Maybe we'll even see YOU there. In the meantime, wherever you are this weekend, have fun, be you, and, by all means, express yourself to the max! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "My Mother's Day date with Mz. Amber Alert." "My fall photo album: drag royalty, gender-bender acceptance & LGBTQ visibility." "An explosion of drag performance, music & love? Must be Bushwig 2015!"
May 26, 2017
- My Mother’s Day date with Mz. Amber Alert.
No Mother’s Day brunch for me this year. Nope. My day will start literally at the stroke of midnight, where the NYC drag explosion known as Bushwig will be in the throes of heating up New Orleans, LA. And I'm so excited! I’ll be at that party of queer performance, music and love with my kid Harry, aka drag artist Mz. Amber Alert. Even though Amber won't be taking the stage -- this is a vacation for her as well, I know my kid will be dressed in an utterly fabulous look. Or, knowing him, maybe even two looks. I’ll be wearing the killer dress I ordered from Tyler Wallach Studio. (Btw, my super creative and fun friend Tyler created the finale Red Carpet look for RuPaul's Drag Race Season 8 winner, Bob the Drag Queen.) [caption id="attachment_6384" align="aligncenter" width="375"] Brooklyn artist and designer Tyler Wallach & me. My dress is in the "American Beauty" print on his shirt.[/caption]Choices, choices, choices.
I was faced with a fashion dilemma this week, though. How I could wear that amazing dress AND the incredible silk palazzo pants I found while vintage-thrift shopping with Harry in Milwaukee recently. Our shopping adventures always yield the best finds! Harry can spot a Fendi skirt on a Salvation Army rack from across the room. I know that because there’s one such garment hanging in my closet. But this time, the palazzo pants with gold metallic tufts in a swirly aqua and purple print that I pulled off the rack for Harry actually ended up fitting me. So here’s how it’s going down."Be bold, Mom! You're going to be competing with drag queens, so no matter what you do it won't look like too much."
Bushwig South starts at 2pm Saturday with a line up of non-stop fun until 4am on Mother’s Day. There’s NO WAY I can make it through without a disco nap in there somewhere. So I’ll start out in my fab new dress and then later change into my mom’s day celebration palazzos before midnight. My former fashion insultant turned personal fashion consultant Harry has a couple of ideas on what I can wear with those fantastic pants. He’s even offered to pack something from his wardrobe as an option.Be bold.
When I asked Harry about wearing some bright eyeshadow, he replied, "Be bold, Mom! You're going to be competing with drag queens, so no matter what you do it won't look like too much." As for what the ever-fashionable Mz. Amber Alert will be wearing, I’m sure my looks will fall closer to the Amish end of the fashion scale in comparison. I may not look as good as the other queens, but I’m sure going to feel like one. If you’re also a mom, I hope you’re celebrated this weekend for your unconditional love, support and protection. If I’ve learned one thing from Harry, it’s that our kids are not here to live out our expectations for them. Pass it on, and allow yourself to be queen for a day. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The Mother's Day I became a gender creative kid's champion." "5 Mother's Day maxims from a 'gender creative parent.'" "A note from another mother."May 12, 2017
- #TheRealReason we need ‘The Real O’Neals’
Last week Monday I shared with parents at a PFLAG NYC meeting some of my experiences raising a gender nonconforming son in the early ‘90s, a couple of decades before the gender revolution and the terms I wish had existed back then. I learned after my talk that, in addition to parents whose young kids were also gender nonconforming or transgender, some had older children – teens and young adults – who’d come out to them recently as lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans or queer. One mom expressed her confusion understanding her child. Others worried about what being LGBTQ might mean for their child’s safety at school or acceptance by members of extended family, their neighbors or church. Those moms’ feelings stuck with me the next night when I remembered I’d already watched this season’s final episode of The Real O’Neals, a sitcom that focuses on gay teen Kenny’s life after coming out to his religious Irish Catholic family. And amid rumors the show might not be renewed for a third season, I was reminded how important the ABC-TV family comedy really is to both parents of LGBTQ kids and their children, especially given the current political climate of our country. The facts remain the facts:
- 26% of LGBTQ youth surveyed by the Human Rights Campaign say their biggest problems are not feeling accepted by family and bullying at school.
- Of the 1.6 million youth who experience homelessness in the U.S., 40% of them are LGBTQ, the majority forced out by rejecting families.
- More than 80% of 10,000 K-12 educators surveyed by the Southern Poverty Law Center, reported "heightened anxiety on the part of marginalized students,” including LGBTQ students. Four in 10 said they heard slurs directed at students in those groups in the first few weeks following the election.
I know I’m not the only one who wants to know what gay teen Kenny will face with the recent national rise in homophobia and bullying.
I know one TV show can’t be all things to all people, but when you have a vulnerable minority like the LGBTQ teen community starved for representation, I’d like to think ABC-TV will follow its much-needed When We Rise miniseries presented earlier this year with a third season of The Real O’Neals. I know I’m not the only one who wants to know what gay teen Kenny will face with the recent national rise in homophobia and bullying, or how his friend Allison will handle dealing with her parents abject rejection since discovering she’s a lesbian. ABC will be making their decisions about the 2017-18 season soon, so now is the time to show some love for The Real O’Neals. Because every little bit helps, there are ways you and your friends can let the network know you want a third season. You can tweet and post your support for the show. Use the hashtags #TheRealReason and #TheRealONeals. You can also tweet your support to @TheRealONeals and @ABCNetwork. Thanks for supporting LGBTQ kids everywhere! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "A primetime winner for parents of LGBTQ kids." "We must rise up for transgender children." "Fighting for kids in the gender revolution."May 5, 2017
- Apr 2017
- When your son wants to wear eyeliner to Catholic school.
Three of these things don't usually go together: Catholic school, nuns, eyeliner, and dress codes. Borrowing from the Sesame Street song, I'm sure you know which one doesn't belong here, especially for boys. But all four of those things came up in a question submitted to the good folks at My Kid Is Gay by the parents of an elementary school kid. My advice, which triggered some past worries of my own, follows the question below. "Hello, we are two moms with an 11-year-old son who is gay (even though he may not yet realize it). We are looking for parenting advice on how to support him. He recently started wearing eyeliner at home, but we are unclear as to how to navigate this since he attends a Catholic elementary school? Any advice?" Brava, Mamas! You’re allowing your child the freedom to express and present himself however he likes at home. Letting him exert some independence when it comes to personal style can go a long way to build self esteem and boost self confidence. As for how that loving parental support will pave a safe path inside the walls of a Catholic elementary school, I think you have both immediate and long-term options to consider before you proceed. Right out of the gate, private schools often have strictly enforced dress codes. And as a general rule, creative expression outside of traditional gender norms is not accepted. So my first suggestion is to check your son’s student handbook to see where his school stands on a dress code.
“NO makeup is allowed.”
Beyond uniform standards for boys and girls, I imagine there will be guidelines regarding jewelry, hair color, make-up, and nail polish. I did a random search online for dress codes at Catholic elementary and middle schools and found that most had a “NO makeup is allowed” rule—but there are always exceptions. For example, one school stated, “At the discretion of the parent, a young woman may wear makeup and fingernail polish that is in modest taste and appropriate for a Catholic middle school student.” The same school discouraged students in grades K-5 from wearing makeup or colored fingernail polish to school. However, if parents allowed it, the makeup and polish was expected to be “minimal and modest.” If your son decides he wants to wear eyeliner to school, you can suggest that the two of you take a look at the dress code policies. If it’s clear that makeup at school is not allowed, then case closed. If there’s no rule listed about boys wearing makeup, but it’s outlined as clearly forbidden in the dress code for girls, he may be able to draw his own conclusion. On the other hand, if he’s the gender rebel my son was at that age, he might want to push the boundaries. Even with your approval, chances are he’ll be asked to wash it off or be sent home. And I’m willing to bet that “no makeup” would quickly become the general rule.Your child is probably well aware that boys wearing makeup is a thing.
One of the Catholic school dress codes I found online allowed both girls and boys to wear a limit of two bracelets. If your son’s school is also open to wrist jewelry for boys, maybe he could express his creativity at school with a unique friendship bracelet or two. You’re nearing the end of the school year now, so you two have some time to observe how important your son’s gender expression is to his well being going forward. While the administrators at his school may not know that CoverGirl cosmetics hired a teenage cover boy last fall, I bet your son knows. And if he has an Instagram account, your child is probably well aware that boys wearing makeup is a thing.A new GLAAD and Harris Poll study found that 20% of millennials identified outside the traditional binaries of “gay/straight” and “man/woman."
So the question you might soon be considering is: Can our son stay happy and focused on learning if he feels like his personality and creative expression is being quashed? While a new GLAAD and Harris Poll study found that 20% of millennials identified outside the traditional binaries of “gay/straight” and “ man/woman,” I wonder how the teachers at his Catholic school will respond to a kid who doesn’t fit the binaries they believe are God’s rules. I raise these points because I worry about your son’s self-esteem beyond elementary school. I don’t know what they teach about sexuality in middle school religion classes these days, or if there’s even any mention of gender identity. But I do know the nuns at the school my son’s dad attended taught him that being attracted to someone of the same sex was more than wrong; it was an “abomination,” and something to be feared, ashamed of, and fixed.You have every right to ask the principal about the school’s policies regarding the rights of LGBTQ+ students.
I’m also concerned for your son’s wellbeing because of the wrath my own son had to face as a 15-year-old foreign exchange student in Spain. How he ended up at a Catholic high school is a story all on its own. But one of the girls in his class asked him if he was gay. When it got back to the Mother Superior that my son was attracted to boys, she called him into her office and told him he needed psychological help. As loving and supportive parents, I can’t imagine you two putting up with anyone in a position of authority bullying your child like that at any age. You have every right to ask the principal about the school’s policies regarding the rights of LGBTQ+ students. Based on how things go for your son for the remainder of this semester, you may want to think ahead to the prospect of Catholic middle school. My advice is to think like mama bears and consider what will be the best learning environment for his sense of self to thrive.There’s also the possibility that his desire to wear eyeliner is an exploration of his gender identity.
Lastly, I want to circle around to the belief that your son is gay. Until he tells you he has a crush on another boy, or comes out and says he’s gay, try to reserve judgment. Maybe he is gay. Maybe his gender expression led you to that conclusion. There’s also the possibility that his desire to wear eyeliner is an exploration of his gender identity, or may simply be about gender expression. But just maybe he’ll wind up telling you he’s bisexual, pansexual, asexual, or straight. You really won’t know until he tells you, so let observation and time be your guides. I remember thinking my kid was gay before I understood the terms gender nonconforming, transgender, genderqueer, and nonbinary. I encourage you to let your son go through his own process of figuring out what identity words feel right for him. Whatever your son’s sexual orientation or gender identity, I’d like to suggest you continue your navigation to ensure his schools are as encouraging and accepting of him as you are in the happy and safe place he calls home. [caption id="attachment_6309" align="aligncenter" width="407"] My son Harry's very own H.S. school uniform, complete with eyeliner and lipstick.[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "In defiance of gender roles: Clothes!"' “My toddler was a gender rebel.” "The day I fell in love with Jean Paul Gaultier."April 28, 2017
- Gender bending by an iconic American artist.
Lots of peeps in New York City this Sunday will be donning their most colorful and creative hats for a march down Fifth Avenue in the 2017 Easter Parade and Easter Bonnet Festival. It’s an annual tradition that fills the street with exuberant personal expression, thanks to people like my artist friend Carri Skoczek, pictured above in last year's extravaganza. Yet it was a plain black bowler hat I saw in a poster of artist Georgia O’Keeffe recently that prompted me to revisit society’s traditional ideas about the clothes we wear. [caption id="attachment_6321" align="aligncenter" width="375"] Georgia O'Keeffe, by Alfred Stieglitz, circa 1920-22[/caption] That photo by O’Keeffe’s husband Alfred Stieglitz and others of her dressed in signature black garments that shaped my image of Georgia O’Keeffe as a strong, beautiful and mysterious woman. It was how she presented herself to the world that I admired more than her classic paintings of New York skyscrapers, oversized flowers or bleached animal bones. The “Living Modern” exhibit at the Brooklyn Museum explores how O’Keeffe used clothing to assert her independence as a woman and an artist. And despite the fact that she dressed mainly for comfort, she also understood how what she wore shaped her image. As a teenager she rejected the Victorian world of corsets and decorous dress codes into which she was born. A high school class portrait at the beginning of the exhibit shows all of the girls but O’Keeffe wearing a poufy-sleeved blouse and a pompadour hairdo topped with a big, floppy bow. She stood out even then, third from the right, with her hair pulled back into a long braid and dress sleeves tight around her wrists. The yearbook described her a girl who shunned established feminine styling: “A girl who would be different in habit, style and dress. A girl who doesn’t give a cent for men and boys still less.” He class photo reminded me how my now-27-year-old kid had also expressed his independence as a high school student with clothing style, hair color, eyeliner and even his art. He’d stood out from other boys throughout the lower grades, too, wearing mostly tie-dye tees and bright-colored flight pants. He would have worn a dress in first grade if I’d let him. Years later he clued me in that if a t-shirt’s long enough, it's a dress. But it was high school where he seemed to consciously defy the traditional ideas of gendered clothing. The outfit he chose to wear for his senior ID photo was not what anyone, myself included, would have expected: frilled collar, military jacket, eye makeup, and lip gloss. [caption id="attachment_6309" align="aligncenter" width="407"] Harry's high school ID photo, Sept. 2007[/caption] Harry, who identifies as non-binary, was just expressing his inner self and his aesthetic. Thanks to the new language of gender, I now know his wardrobe was and is about gender expression. I watched his kindergarten dress-up box became the costume closet for his middle school movie-making, which in turn grew to become his extensive and fabulous wardrobe. I imagine at the turn of the century Georgia O’Keeffe hadn’t heard the term gender expression either. And those who gossiped about her all-black androgynous garments probably didn’t notice how similar those looks were to the shapes and lines in her paintings.
So if clothing can be artistic expression, then can’t gender expression be art?
Today's youth continue to push the boundaries of gender and gender expression, defying the ideas that people have to fit into one of two gender boxes. Teenagers like rapper and actor Jaden Smith, a 2016 model for Louis Vuitton women’s wear, and rapper Young Thug, whose new album "Jeffrey" features him in a long dress and umbrella-style hat, are stepping outside the limits of what’s traditionally thought to be masculine or feminine dress. They, along with so many other everyday teens, know there’s a whole lotta gray between the binary of black and white that insists humans must be either solely male/masculine or female/feminine. Please lead on, millennials! And if clothing can be artistic expression, then can't gender expression be art? And don’t we all have the right, if not the need, to experience and express ourselves creatively in whatever medium we choose? I like to think so, as I can hear Harry reminding me of RuPaul’s saying, “We’re all born naked, and the rest is drag.” So what do you feel like wearing today --- hat or not hat -- in this world that is a stage? [caption id="attachment_6326" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry dressed to host a show in Brooklyn, spring 2017[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “My toddler was a gender rebel.” “In defiance of gender roles: Clothes!” “Life lessons learned from a drag queen.”April 15, 2017
- Mar 2017
- Gender confusion? It's all in the minds of confused adults.
Thanks to the Quist app, I was reminded of this week's 20-year anniversary of the Teletubbies. I remember so clearly breathing a sigh of relief that my kid Harry was already seven when Teletubbies premiered on PBS in 1997. Clearly the gibberish spoken by the four bright-colored creatures with TV screens in their stomachs and different-shaped antennae on their heads was aimed at pre-schoolers. I thanked my lucky stars for Harry’s early years of Sesame Street, and that was that. But two years later I recall my jaw dropping when Rev. Jerry Falwell Sr. dared to warn parents that Tinky Winky, the purple Teletubby, was really a “gay role model” for toddlers. According to Falwell: "He is purple, the gay pride color, and his antenna is shaped like a triangle, the gay-pride symbol." Falwell Sr. also thought Tinky Winky's red bag looked too much like a woman's purse. I was furious then. So what did that make Barney, the purple dinosaur? Or Felix the Cat, with his yellow magic bag of tricks? Maybe he also thought inverted triangles in algebraic equations was gay math? We’ve come a long way in LGBTQ+ freedoms and equality since Teletubbies first aired. But now, in addition to using religion as an excuse to discriminate against the LGBTQ+ community, there are those on the right who use their religious beliefs to demonize transgender and gender nonconforming children. I’m incensed that some of our most vulnerable kids continue to be caught in their crosshairs of fear and hate. And it’s not hard to find evidence of that. A few months ago Harry was sitting with his laptop when he asked me if I’d ever heard of “Ask Me First.” I hadn’t, so he patted the seat next to him. "Here’s what you’re up against, Mom.” Harry clicked on a video of two mothers talking about how upset they'd been when the principal at their kids’ elementary school had wanted to read the children’s picture book My Princess Boy in class because a “gender-confused” student was attending. To these women, and the other mothers who then formed the Ask Me First organization with the help of so-called Christian legal groups, transgender and gender-nonconforming kids threatened the “innocence” and “right to privacy” of their gender conforming children. These very confused mothers viewed the school’s guest psychologist on the topic as a “proponent of gender confusion” and were certain that any staff training by the psychologist would encourage gender confusion within the classroom. “We have the truth the Lord shares with us,” they said, “and we have the courts on our side.” And their boldness in bullying trans and gender nonconforming kids is spreading to other close-minded mothers. Just this past week, a school system in North Carolina pulled the picture book Jacob’s New Dress from its first-grade lesson plans on anti-bullying after intense criticism from the conservative N.C. Values Coalition. “The purpose of our elementary schools is to teach writing, reading and arithmetic, not to encourage boys to wear dresses,” an official wrote in a statement to The Charlotte Observer. And executive director of the coalition, Tami Fitzgerald, told The New York Times that the book was “a tool of indoctrination to normalize transgender behavior.” She said a lot of parents would be opposed to that. I've got news for all these confused parents and uniformed state Republican legislators: Trans and gender nonconforming children exist and are as "normal" as a left-handed child is when compared to a right-handed child. All this furor and animosity is over picture books that teach children about acceptance, remind parents about the importance of unconditional love, and educate everyone that there is no such thing as gendered clothing, toys, colors or behaviors. So what do the Falwells, the Ask Me First parents and N.C. Values Coalition families do when one of their own kindergarten boys wants to wear a dress? Or one of their young daughters refuses to put one on? I can only hope they’ll see the true innocence of a child who knows nothing of society’s prescribed gender expectations. Transgender and gender-nonconforming kids aren’t confused. Those children know their inner selves and, without interference from clueless parents, love themselves. All we have to do is listen to them, believe them and love them unconditionally. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Books that celebrate kids of all genders." "My new role model is an 11-year-old transgender girl." "Giving a boy a dress will not make him gay."
March 31, 2017
- What if your child comes out on social media before telling ...
I remember asking my now-adult kid Harry in the summer of 2008 if he'd accept me as a "friend" on Facebook. He was headed to college out of state, and I thought Facebook would help me keep up with his life. He paused before replying, "All right, Mom, but I'm not going to censor anything just because you're on Facebook." Harry had already come out to me and his dad before Facebook began allowing young teens to join in 2006. I'd never thought about how I would have reacted if he'd come out first on social media and didn't know that I knew about it. But this week the editors at My Kid Is Gay asked me to respond to that question as submitted anonymously by the mom of a teenage girl. Due to the importance of social media in our kids' lives, my answer required more than one option. “My daughter is 15 and just came out on social media last week. I learned about it from the mother of one of her friends. I’ve had a pretty good idea for over 6 months now, but wanted her to have the opportunity to tell me when she was ready. Now that she has come out on social media should I continue to ‘pretend not to know,’ to let her tell me when she is ready or talk to her about it? We have a close relationship and she knows that I support LBGTQ rights/people. Thanks.” Your question is so full of love and respect for your daughter that I want to reach through my computer screen and hug you. I can imagine how proud and happy you must be that your daughter knows herself and what’s in her heart when it comes to love and attraction. At the same time, you’ve been thrown a conversational curve ball, and I understand your quandary of “to tell or not to tell,” as Shakespeare might have put it. But here’s the thing. The coming out process still belongs to your daughter. And even though another mother has inserted herself into your lives doesn’t mean you can’t still allow your daughter to take the lead on sharing her own news.
Based on what I’m about to say, how is the other person likely to feel?
You wanted her to have the chance to tell you when she was ready, and I applaud you for giving her that space. The fact that she feels safe and secure enough to come out on social media is huge. Of course it’s not exactly private to come out on social media, but teenagers are teenagers. If you continue to respect your daughter’s coming out process, my guess is the close relationship you referenced will grow even stronger. I tend to think it’s your daughter’s telling you—in her own way and on her own time—that really matters. As you’ve weighed this decision, though, I’m sure your mind has run through some possible conversation-starters. And you’ve probably thought, too, about how such a talk with your daughter might unfold. Putting myself in your shoes, I’ve done the same exercise. Here’s the filter question I often use when contemplating a potentially awkward conversation: Based on what I’m about to say, how is the other person likely to feel? And honestly, I can’t think of anything that wouldn’t in some way dim the bright light that is shining on your daughter’s current celebration of self.Your daughter could be expecting you to initiate the conversation.
That said, there is a chance she was hopeful you would find out as a result of her posting, because coming out on social media is a very public thing to do. If you feel comfortable, perhaps you could make an extra effort to bring up LGBTQ topics that might make it easier for her to segue into telling you. I remember that right before my son came out to me at the same age as your daughter, we’d been talking about his love of high heels from the age of three. The possibility also exists that the mother of her friend who told you about the social media posting also has a close relationship with her daughter and might mention to her that she told you. If that were the case, your daughter could be expecting you to initiate the conversation. Again, considering your comfort broaching the subject, you could be the one to begin the conversation with, “Honey, there’s something I want you to know. So-and-so’s mom told me you’d come out to your friends on social, and I’m just bursting with love and pride for you.”Respond in a way you know will make her feel loved, supported, and utterly fabulous.
Given the close relationship you two have and your openness to the rich diversity of human life experience, you sound like the kind of cool mom who can handle any unpredictability. So however you choose to have your eventual conversation play out, whenever she comes out to you, you’ll get to respond to her in the way that you know will make her feel loved, supported, and utterly fabulous. And if you don’t already own a copy of This Is a Book for Parents of Gay Kids: A Question & Answer Guide to Everyday Life, you might want to add it to your library. Written by the founders of My Kid Is Gay and Everyone Is Gay, the book covers every question parents might wrestle with after their child comes out to them, from telling other family members to gender to sleepovers. It’s the kind of book you can keep coming back to over and over as new questions arise. [caption id="attachment_6229" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry & Me the year he joined Facebook, 2006[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU'LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: When a child comes out to only one parent. When a mom is worried about her teenage son's 'femininity.' When a trans boys still likes 'girly' things.March 24, 2017
- A little convo etiquette for LGBTQ allies.
Hillary Clinton may have received a standing ovation before the curtain went up on Sunset Boulevard the night I was there, but it was my kid Harry’s friend, drag artist Severely Mame, whom audience members lauded with compliments on our way in and out of the show. Mame had arrived at the theater channeling the play’s faded silent film star Norma Desmond, right down to Ms. Desmond’s exact cigarette case. I felt like I was in the entourage of a celebrity the whole night. “Did you guys have time to eat before the show?” I asked Harry and Mame as the pre-show Hillary applause died down. I winced as soon as I said the words “you guys” and wondered if I had just offended the glam duo. I know I say “you guys” all the time when referring to a mixed-gender group or even several girlfriends, but “guys” is clearly a gendered word. It didn't seem right when staring them in the face, because I know Harry, aka drag artist Amber Alert, and Mame refer to each other as “girl” and use she/her/hers pronouns when together. I asked Harry later if "you guys” had bothered him. He hadn’t really noticed. “People say ‘you guys’ all the time, Mom.” “I know, but it seems sexist and wrong, especially when referring to genderqueer or nonbinary people.” “You guys” became a teachable moment for me. I decided right then to replace it with the more gender neutral, albeit southern, "y'all." And as a straight ally for the LGBTQ community, I’m hopeful other allies will also think twice about language used and questions asked. I say this because I have friends who are strong supporters of LGBTQ rights, but whom I’ve heard ask highly insensitive questions, especially as they relate to transgender people. I was at a party recently talking with a man who was telling a lady friend of his and me that his husband was transitioning. She had changed her name and was using female pronouns. “Is she going to have the surgery?” his girlfriend asked casually. He paused before replying, “She hasn’t decided.” I was cringing. I couldn’t believe his friend had asked such a personal question. My mom was big on manners and had hammered on me from an early age about what was polite and what wasn’t. I even had a book on the subject. So believe me when I say that questions about what’s between the legs of transgender, nonbinary or gender-nonconforming people are just plain inappropriate. Our life experience as humans is so much broader than our anatomy. Being transgender is about gender identity, and has little to do with what’s in someone's pants. I refer you back to the Genderbread Person, the easiest way to remember the differences among the terms gender identity, sexual orientation, gender expression, and the sex someone is assigned at birth. As the mom of a nonbinary kid, I get asked questions, too. Questions of clarification like, “What if I pass someone on the street and can’t determine their gender?” My advice to them is to smile and just keep on walking, for they will have simply experienced the diversity of human experience. And that happenstance is also a good reminder that someone’s gender identity is defined by them, not by society’s preconceived ideas about gender. And just in case you meet someone and are unsure of their gender, it is totally appropriate to ask them what pronouns they use. I assure you it’s not only an acceptable question, but one that will be welcomed and appreciated as well. In fact LGBTQ youth ask each other that all the time. I've even been to events where name badges include pronouns used. Any questions? I ask because in this ever-evolving worldwide gender revolution of ours, answering questions helps me continue learning, too. [caption id="attachment_6189" align="aligncenter" width="450"] l to r: Severely Mame, Me and Harry[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Have you come out as an LGBTQ ally?" "6 ways to be a better LGBTQ ally." "He, Zie or They: Gender-specific pronouns are personal."
March 17, 2017
- Feb 2017
- We must rise up for transgender children.
Wednesday night, as the Republican Administration announced its withdrawal of federal guidance that protected transgender and gender-nonconforming students in public schools from being discriminated against based on their gender identity, I sat in a movie theater on the Lower East Side. I was there for a preview screening of the first episode of “When We Rise,” a four-part television docudrama that follows the lives of three young people who in the early '70s became trailblazers in the LGBTQ rights movement. The When We Rise miniseries will debut Monday night, February 27 on ABC TV at 9p/8c. Due to an address to Congress by President Obama’s successor, the three subsequent two-hour episodes will air March 1 to March 3, also at 9p/8c. As I watched the stories of real-life activists Roma Guy, Cleve Jones and Ken Jones unfold on the screen, I felt myself becoming emotionally involved. I was reminded of the pain LGBT people suffered then – and still suffer – often at the hands of law enforcement. I choked up during the conversation young Cleve Jones has with his physician father, reminded that many in the medical profession back then considered being gay or trans a mental illness, “curable” with conversion therapy or electroshock treatments. And I jotted down lines from the show that have been running through my mind ever since. “When did you know you needed to rise up?” The arc of history is long, but it bends towards justice.” “I feel like fighting back today, don’t you?” “We have to create our own power to ensure our safety.” [caption id="attachment_6137" align="aligncenter" width="600"] "When We Rise" panel (l to r): Moderator EW Senior Editor Caitlyn Brody, actors Fiona Dourif & Emily Skeggs, writer/creator/director Dustin Lance Black[/caption] In the discussion after the screening, the show’s writer and creator Dustin Lance Black was asked what impact he thought the miniseries would have in our current post-election world. “I think it’s critical that people remember the ‘we’ in When We Rise,” he said, “so we can stop this backlash and we can push that momentum forward again.” The we in the audience applauded with a sense of urgency. I’d known on my way to the theater that the current Republican administration could at any moment rescind anti-discrimination protections for transgender students. But that didn't stop the combined body wave of nausea and anxiety I felt on my train ride home after the breaking news popped up on my phone: Those Obama-era guidelines had been reversed. The irony of this happening on the night I'd just viewed the important history lessons in When We Rise rang in my head like a fire alarm. How could it be that in 2017 schools no longer had a duty to treat transgender girls and boys with the same fairness and respect they treat other girls and boys? [caption id="attachment_6140" align="aligncenter" width="500"] My son Harry, at age 10[/caption] I didn’t want to believe that the progress of the LGBTQ rights movement, like the civil rights movement that preceded it, could ever be rolled back. And yet here we are, American citizens governed by a Republican administration that has begun attacking the basic rights of our most vulnerable people: transgender and gender-nonconforming children. [caption id="attachment_4902" align="aligncenter" width="450"] My friend Mateo, at age 5[/caption] I know this isn’t just about children, but that’s where the Republican administration has chosen to start. The so-called “bathroom bills” and “bathroom debate” continue to be called that and messaged as such under the Republican party's efforts to defeat civil rights protections for a broad range of people. Their language is about creating fear -- fear of the unknown, fear of “the other” -- in order to enact rules and legislation that will eventually strip LGBTQ people of basic freedoms, rights and protections. But no matter how challenging or difficult these weeks since January 20 may be, I know that LGBTQ progress is progress. As a nation we must not turn back. And as parents, families, educators, advocates, allies, or anyone with a moral compass, we cannot be complacent. We must stay informed, stand up, speak out, attend school board meetings, reassure vulnerable kids we have their backs, and send messages to the federal government insisting on its duty to ensure that all transgender and gender-nonconforming students are protected from discrimination, bullying and harassment. Those children, adult members of the LGBTQ community and its allies, along with all other marginalized groups, will never be alone. We are in this together. And like those freedom fighters before us, we must never give up. I feel like fighting back today, don't you? [caption id="attachment_6134" align="aligncenter" width="500"] LGBTQ rights activist Edie Windsor with screenwriter Dustin Lance Black[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: Fighting for kids in the gender revolution." "Diary of a queer kid's mom." "My new role model is an 11-year-old transgender girl."
February 24, 2017
- Transgender kids are changing the world.
Transgender kids are changing the world. And there is so much evidence of how and why. For starters, widespread rumors that the LGBTQ+ community will soon be the next group threatened by the current administration’s discriminatory executive actions. While I will never give up championing equality for all the marginalized among us, I know how easy it is to become overwhelmed by worry and fear. So instead of disturbing headlines and weariness and a knot in my stomach, I turned to the voices of kids. They’re my go-to for tapping internal strength and the positive mental attitude that tells fear to take a back seat and just shut up. Children feel our connectedness as one big human family. That is, until somebody teaches them to fear our differences. And until someone tries to destroy it, the youngest among us know their individual worthiness and the joy that comes with just being themselves.
Willa's story.
I re-watched the YouTube video about then-eight-year-old Willa Naylor, the trans girl to whom Malta dedicated its Gender Identity, Gender Expression and Sex Characteristics Act. Her story is one of the most uplifting ever.Jazzing up my coffee table.
Next I read my coffee table copy of I Am Jazz, about transgender teen Jazz Jennings, who knew as a toddler that she had "a girl’s brain in a boy’s body." Jazz, now a national figure, is a role model for my 11-year-old transgender hero and friend, Conner McClaren. Conner had a beautiful personal essay published in the Jan-Feb issue of New Moon Girls magazine. She shares with young readers the story of her life as a girl who just happens to be trans, as well as her goal to be an advocate for LGBTQ+ equality. Like Willa, Jazz, Conner, and my own gender-nonconforming child who at two told me that inside his head he was a girl, trans kids need to be heard and loved unconditionally. They know who they are. And knowing one of those children is going to be what changes the hearts and minds of those who fear them.A gender revolution.
I’m eager to see the upcoming National Geographic special, “Gender Revolution: A Journey with Katie Couric.” I hope you get a chance to see it too. The two-hour program about the ever-evolving notion of gender identity airs Monday night, Feb. 6. (The show will repeat at 9 p.m. ET on Friday, Feb. 10 and Monday, Feb. 13. ) Couric talked recently with Matt Lauer about the “Gender Revolution” special.The opposite of fear.
Let’s remember that it's today’s youth from every group who shape popular culture and broaden national conversations. We must listen to their truths and share their stories. Because everyone, including government officials, can listen, learn and fear not the most vulnerable among us. That's when we can take actions to end discrimination at all levels. My own fears, for now, remain quiet. And I’m back on track knowing that everything will get better. So many parents, friends, allies and advocates for human dignity are also fighting against fear of "the other." And the opposite of fear will always be love. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "LGBTQ kids need us more than ever." "My new role model is an 11-year-old transgender girl." "A look to the future for gender-nonconforming kids."February 3, 2017
- Jan 2017
- President Obama’s letter to moms of LGBTQ kids.
In my desire to hold onto the Obama presidency for as long as possible, I watched all of the TV specials that aired last week highlighting our 44th President’s greatest accomplishments. And I didn’t miss CNN’s special report on the role model also known as “mom-in-chief” either. I have appreciated the President these past eight years for his vision, his leadership, his temperament, and his hope. And as the mom of a queer kid, I am grateful for all he’s done to further the freedom, equality, and safety of LGBTQ people. So in these last hours of his presidency, I want to honor Barack Obama’s legacy in support of the LGBTQ community by sharing a personal letter he wrote to some Facebook friends of mine. First, a little background. Serendipitydodah for Moms is a private Facebook group created by Liz Dyer as an extension of her Serendipitydodah blog. The Facebook group is stealth so that only members can find it or see what’s posted. The group was launched in June 2014 specifically for open-minded Christian moms who have LGBTQ children and want to have healthy, loving relationships with them. It’s a safe space where members can share information and encourage one another. In full disclosure, while I’m neither Christian nor religious, I like to think of myself among the majority of people who believe in the inherent goodness of all, treating each other with kindness and respect, and loving each other as fellow humans. The Serendipitydodah for Moms Facebook group, which presently has more than 1,500 members, often sends letters of thanks and support to individuals, churches, and organizations that support LGBTQ+ equality and protection. Last May, when the Obama administration instructed public schools to allow transgender students to use the bathroom that matches their gender identity, they sent the following letter to President Obama. Dear Mr. President, We are a part of a large private Facebook group of more than 1,000 Christian moms of LGBTQ+ kids. Our group was created for Christian moms who have LGBTQ+ kids and want to develop and maintain healthy, loving, authentic relationships with their LGBTQ+ kids. More than 250 of us are signing this letter because we want to say thank you for all you have done for LGBTQ+ people. Your commitment to include and protect LGBTQ+ people throughout your presidency has given us so much hope for our children’s future. We are very encouraged by your actions and want you to know that we are praying that God will protect, strengthen, guide and bless you. We believe that your action not only reflects the true spirit of America, but also demonstrates the idea that Paul put forth in Galatians 5:6 when he wrote “the only thing that counts is faith expressing itself through love.” We are forever hopeful that others will follow your just and compassionate example. Most respectfully, Liz Dyer, Founder & Owner Liz and the 250+ mom signers who are public about their participation in the group were hopeful their letter would reach the President. Of the 40,000 letters that arrived at the White House each day during his presidency, they knew his staff selected the ten he'd read each night. They were also aware that a response was never guaranteed. But read and reply President Obama did! Dear Elizabeth: Thank you for writing. Throughout our history, generations of Americans have brought us closer to fulfilling the ideals at the heart of our Nation’s founding—that all of us are equal, and that all of us should be free to make of our lives what we will. Our country has come far in its acceptance of transgender Americans, but transgender individuals still face terrible violence, abuse, and poverty here at home and around the world. I know that some people have a hard time understanding what it means to be transgender, especially if they haven’t had the opportunity to know someone who openly identifies that way. As brave individuals come out at all levels of business, government, sports, and entertainment, the power of their example is slowly but surely changing hearts and minds. We need to ask ourselves what kind of society we want to build for the many young people struggling with their identities who deserve a childhood free from harassment or ridicule. Too many transgender people, especially youth, take their own lives because of discrimination and violence, and no one should ever feel so alone or desperate that they feel they have nowhere to turn. That’s why my Administration took a stance against the use of conversion therapy on minors, and why we have been working to address bullying. And when schools sought advice about how to ensure learning environments are respectful and inclusive for all students, the Department of Education provided guidance to educators—because all of our children deserve to know that their safety is protected and that their dignity is affirmed. We have also taken actions to help ensure that transgender Americans have the same rights as any other Americans. I issued an Executive Order that prohibits discrimination in employment by Federal contractors based on sexual orientation or gender identity, and I signed legislation that includes protections against hate crimes. Thanks to the Affordable Care Act, there are now important protections in place against discrimination in healthcare, including discrimination based on gender identity. And this year, my Administration lifted the ban on transgender individuals serving in our Armed Forces—because no American who wishes to serve our country should face unnecessary barriers, and our military is strongest when it draws on the skills and talents of all our people. Again, thank you for writing. Please know I will keep pushing to advance the safety and dignity of every American as long as I hold this Office and beyond. Sincerely, Barack Obama While I remain so moved by his response, it’s that “and beyond” in his letter that I’m counting on. I know President Obama will never let up on the future we hope for. And I know there are millions of moms who are right there with him, every step of the way, fighting for a future that delivers freedom, equality, and safety for all children. Top image: White House Photographer Pete Souza IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Fighting for kids in the gender revolution." "Diary of a queer kid's mom." "LBGTQ kids need us more than ever."
January 20, 2017
- Fighting for kids in the gender revolution.
Despite the fact that a team of anti-LGBTQ extremists and equal rights obstructionists will soon fill key White House and cabinet positions, I am resolved this year to remain fearless. I will not back down or stand by and watch our country’s progress be rolled back. The countless non-profit organizations, activist groups, journalists and many others who are speaking out and standing up for the betterment of all fortify me. I am focused on the change I want to see and experience. And I am driven by optimism -- hopeful we can instill it in all of today’s youth, regardless of their color, ethnicity, abilities, gender or sexual orientation. Thanks to the generous chiropractor who lent me her waiting room copy of National Geographic’s special issue, “Gender Revolution,” I’m reminded of the power education and knowledge have to change hearts and minds. We must all find teachable moments to influence attitudes, beliefs and behaviors about what it means to be human, and to rethink the gender binary of boy and girl. (Based on the special issue, National Geographic has put together a wonderful discussion guide for parents and teachers on the topic of gender.)
"The best thing about being a girl is, now I don't have to pretend to be a boy." --Avery Jackson, 9 years old, "Gender Revolution" special issue
I will continue to fight for the injustices served those kids by anyone who would negate their sense of self or deny their very existence. Whether we are parents, family, teachers, neighbors, or religious leaders, it is imperative that we assure gender-nonconforming and LGBTQ children they are perfect just the way they are. And we must instill in them the four most important traits of personal leadership: confidence, hope, optimism and resilience. As is my January drill, here are four* suggested adds to your list of New Year’s resolutions. They encompass ideas that affirm our collective desires for freedom, joy and personal growth. Please feel free to share them with every adult and child you know.- I will approve of myself, my characteristics, my abilities, my likes and dislikes, my inclinations and disinclinations, realizing that these form my unique individuality. I have them for a reason.
- I will approve of and rejoice in my accomplishments, and I will be as vigorous in listing these – as rigorous in remembering them – as I have ever been in remembering and enumerating my failures or lacks of accomplishment.
- I will remember the tremendous energy, joyful spontaneity, possibilities and potential that lie within me to create that which I can imagine for myself.
- I will realize that the future is a probability. In terms of everyday experiences, nothing exists there yet. It is virgin territory, planted by my feelings and thoughts in the present. Therefore I will plant accomplishments and successes, and I will do this by focusing on how I want and expect the future to be for me.
January 6, 2017
- Dec 2016
- From the wisdom of a trans girl to potential parent bullies: ...
[caption id="attachment_5985" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Harry in the Lanvin dress & earrings my sister sent for Christmas[/caption] Here we are at the end of December and my annual recap of the year's most popular posts. Sometimes I'm disappointed when a few of my personal favorites don't make the cut. Thinking about it, I remember how surprised I was three years ago when my debut blog on The Huffington Post drew very few readers. I changed the headline on that piece to "The first Halloween my boy wanted to be a girl," and it continues to be the most widely read post here. I know that post title really spoke to parents and families of gender-nonconforming children, because, personally, Halloween was a time I learned to better understand my kid Harry...and myself. So here are headlines you clicked on the most. And if you missed any, now's your chance to catch up on the 2016 blog roll.
I wish you a 2017 filled with love, acceptance, inclusivity and peace. And for all of our LGBTQ family members, friends and their allies, let's hope for a Happy News Year. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “From homophobes to genderqueer: the top fave blog posts of 2015.” “A 2014 roundup of most popular posts on My Son Wears Heels.”December 30, 2016
- When a child comes out to only one parent.
As a teenager, my now-adult kid Harry came out to me as bisexual and then again as gay. It didn’t feel right either time to talk to Harry's dad until he had. Harry did tell his dad right away. But what would I have done if he hadn't? A reader at My Kid Is Gay posed a similar question. Was it unusual for a child to come out to only one parent? Here’s the mom’s question, followed by my thoughts on how to handle her dilemma. “My adult son told me he was gay almost one year ago. He has not told his father or brother and has not mentioned it again. I love him so much and I am so proud of who he is and want to be supportive. But I don’t think he wants to talk about it. Is this normal?” I was divorced when my son, then a high school freshman, came out to me. I don’t think he planned it, as the subject arose while we were dining out. Before leaving the restaurant I asked him to please tell his dad, too. I didn’t want his dad to feel excluded from knowing such an important part of our child’s identity. I have a feeling you want the same thing for your family.
Coming out can be a gradual process.
I wouldn't say it's the “norm” for an adult child to come out to only one parent. A Pew Research Center survey indicates that sharing one’s sexual orientation with family can be a gradual process. Coming out can often taking several years to unfold. That surprised me. But the article includes many personal explanations from LGBTQ+ on why. The piece also backs up what I’ve learned from my LGBTQ+ friends and family. Coming out to one’s parents as an adult can be terrifying. I don’t think there’s really any one “right” way or time to come out to family. Everyone has to do it in their own time, and that’s when they feel comfortable and safe. The fact that your son told you but not his dad or brother may mean that he feels closer to you and anticipated that your response would be filled with the love, pride, and support you mention above.Coming out requires a tremendous amount of energy.
He may be worried about his dad or brother’s reactions, wondering if they’ll be as immediately accepting as you were. Based on beliefs or assumptions of your husband’s views, your son might anticipate his dad will have a hard time dealing with the fact he’s gay. Or maybe your sons have a close relationship and he’s afraid his brother will be angry he wasn’t the first to know. He might just fear being devastated by a negative reaction of any kind. In addition to courage, coming out requires a tremendous amount of energy. Perhaps your son has decided to take things slowly with coming out to his dad and brother, or is still wrestling with how to tell them. Maybe the relief he felt telling you was enough for now, and he’s just not ready to move forward with telling other people. Only that “now” has become a year later, and it’s creating some stress for you. I’m sure that in a marriage built on trust you want to be able to talk openly and honestly about your children with your husband.A lot of maybes.
You didn’t say that your son expressly asked you not to tell your husband. Maybe he assumed you would; maybe he really wanted you to. Maybe you believe that’s his truth to tell, and you wouldn’t dream of sharing that without his request that you do so. On the other hand, maybe he has no intention of ever telling his dad or brother. I realize I’ve presented you with a whole lot of maybes. But the bottom line is that all of these unknowns are creating stress for you. Until you have a conversation with your son, you can only keep guessing. And I think that after almost a year, there’s nothing wrong with asking your son to help you understand why he hasn’t come out yet to his dad and brother.Coming out can take time.
Ask him if you can come over for a heart-to-heart talk, or invite him out for lunch. Explain that you assumed he wanted to tell each of his parents individually, and the fact that he hasn’t done that after almost a year is confusing to you. Assure him you know the how and when of coming out is up to him, and that you understand it can take time. You can also communicate how you feel being the only parent who knows about his sexuality. If he says he’s just not ready, maybe he’s wanted all along for you to tell your husband. That could pave the way for him to have a future father-son dialogue down the road. If he says he isn’t comfortable with that, again, ask him to explain. If it’s because he wants to be the one to tell his dad, then honor his wishes. But ask him for some sort of timeline, because not being able to share in your pride for him with his dad is placing you in an awkward position within your marriage.Coming out to family is about acceptance.
If he fears his dad will reject him, ask him to explain those thoughts and feelings. If you know your husband loves and supports your son unconditionally, assure him of that. Provided his dad is by no means anti-gay, ensure him of that, too. If you don’t think your husband has ever considered the possibility your son is gay, express that. You can probably agree it might take some time for his dad to process the information, but that he does love him unconditionally. You could even offer to be present when he tells his dad and/or brother. It might make it easier for him to say something like, “I’ve shared something about myself with Mom and now I want you to know, too.” Coming out to family is about acceptance and wanting a closer relationship with loved ones. And if that’s what your son wants—and I have a feeling he does—then I’m sure the two of you can come up with a coming out plan. There may never be that perfect time, but with your love, support, and assurances, I’m sure you can find a way that makes your family closer and stronger and your lives fuller. [caption id="attachment_4183" align="aligncenter" width="472"] Harry & me, Christmas 2008[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: Holiday gift ideas for gender-nonconforming kids. Getting through the holidays with homophobic relatives. When a mom is worried about her teenage son's 'femininity.'December 23, 2016
- When boys don’t like being boys.
My non-binary* kid Harry, now 26, grew up believing in Santa Claus. In “The Toilet Paper Bride” chapter of my memoir about raising a gender fabulous child, I agonize over whether or not Santa will bring little two-year-old Harry the Barbie Dream House he wants. That was the same year his cousin David, who just happens to be gay, visited us on his way home from England, and I learned he'd wanted the Barbie Dream House when he was a kid, too. So I wondered if because Harry loved Barbie and her Dream House that meant he would be gay someday, too. I was clearly clueless, because that’s like saying if boys and girls don’t play with different sets of toys they’ll grow up to be gay or lesbian (which we know is not true.) I just didn’t understand the concept of gender identity back then. In fact I didn’t even know what gender identity meant until Harry explained it to me his freshman year in college. I didn’t understand there was a gender spectrum or that my kid was simply gender nonconforming, two other terms I didn’t know before discovering Diane Ehrensaft’s book, Gender Born, Gender Made five years ago. But it’s not all about gender-nonconforming kids and toys. Clothes, colors, careers, behaviors and characteristics all get gendered, too. Before my appearance on “The Morning Blend” in Milwaukee the week after Thanksgiving, the hosts shared a recent survey of 9-year-old boys who were asked to name what they "don't like about being male." Here’s the list of replies:
- “Not being able to be a mother.”
- “Not supposed to cry.”
- ”Not allowed to be a cheerleader.”
- “Supposed to like science.”
- “Supposed to play football.”
- “Boys smell bad.”
- “Having an automatic bad reputation.”
- “Hair growing everywhere.”
December 16, 2016
- Diary of a queer kid’s mom.
Dear Diary, I haven’t been avoiding you intentionally. In all honesty, I realize I've just been mentally paralyzed since the election. I've rested my fingers on the keyboard many times, only to stare at the screen. Even away from my computer I’ve had trouble concentrating. My gut has ached with knots of dread and despair. I’ve had to hold back tears on the train and in the checkout line at the grocery store. Even now, as I type these words, my eyes are beginning to brim. I’ve needed to grieve in my own way and on my own time. Today I’m ready to pivot my thinking in a way that will move me up from the feelings that hover at the bottom end the emotional scale. I want to bounce back. I want to look for and find the good, renew my purpose, and move forward. I want to reinvigorate my typically positive approach to life. Recently I began a mental list of the interactions, situations, and articles that have lifted me up, restored my hope for the future, and strengthened my faith in humanity since that shocking day in November. So here, dear diary, are the numbered steps on my ladder of resilience. I never want to forget them.
- When I met my friend Ruth for dinner after the election, she gave me an oversized book she’d picked up, called The Shared Heart: Portraits and Stories Celebrating Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Young People, by Adam Mastoon. I wondered why the title didn’t include the T at the end of LGB, but noticed on the subway ride home that the book had been published in 1997, when use of the term transgender was still a rarity. Then I began reading the stories of teen after resilient teen that had grown up feeling alienated, alone, and fearful of rejection. They were just the reminder I needed that kids challenged simply for being who they are, or loving who they love, can lead empowered lives regardless of the decade. The next morning I emailed Ruth an apology for being such a dinner downer and thanked her for the book that helped me see progress ahead no matter what.
- In mid-November I flew to L.A. for a long-planned It Gets Better Project strategic planning retreat with the other board members and dedicated staff. In a daylong session to perfect the programs, advocacy, and organizational framework that serve LGBTQ youth around the globe, several anecdotes emerged that spoke to the relevance and importance of improving the lives of young people who face adversity on a daily basis, just for being who they are. One that will always stick with me is an email that came from a teenage girl saying the It Gets Better video collection often “gets me through the night.” The power of digital storytelling to connect a marginalized community uplifts me everyday.
- Late on Thanksgiving night, I pulled into a driveway full of cars at my longtime friend Katie’s, where I was staying while in the Midwest. I’d planned to put on my pajamas and crawl into bed, but joining her family party was like a salve for the soul. I met an aunt of Katie’s step-daughter for the first time. After asking about my book, Aunt Laurie told me she’s a therapist in Pennsylvania’s Amish country. She talked of the family rejection, community intolerance, and bullying at school her LGBTQ youth clients have to suffer. She started to tell me about two transgender teens recently hospitalized after suicide attempts, but we were interrupted. Right then, in a moment of clarity and with a desire to hug that woman, I realized I don’t have time to be depressed; there’s too much work to be done helping LGBTQ kids develop hope, confidence, and resilience of their own.
- One of the greatest sources of inspirations for my bounce-back resolve comes from President Obama’s words to his daughters about the outcome of the election. They were shared with David Remnik in a lengthy interview in The New Yorker. The following lines are from an excerpt in what Gabriella Paiella reported as a “pep talk” in New York Magazine:
“…your job as a citizen and as a decent human being is to constantly affirm and lift up and fight for treating people with kindness and respect and understanding. And you should anticipate that at any given moment there’s going to be flare-ups of bigotry that you may have to confront, or may be inside you and you have to vanquish. And it doesn’t stop … You don’t get into a fetal position about it. You don’t start worrying about apocalypse. You say, O.K., where are the places where I can push to keep it moving forward.” ~President Barack Obama
I will remember, dear diary, as I believe we all must, that this is a country where everyone has the right to be treated equally, with respect and dignity, and where everyone belongs. I will draw on not only my resilience, but also my courage and my heart to be a hopeful up-lifter for others in defense of rights both given and gained. I will fight for love over hate. I will refuse to back down. And I will do my best to reserve tears for joyful victories. Love, Julie xo IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “LGBTQ kids need us more than ever.” “Have you come out as an LGBTQ ally?” “A look to the future for gender-nonconforming kids.”December 2, 2016
- Nov 2016
- LGBTQ kids need us more than ever.
Still dumbfounded the morning after the presidential election, I arrived at a Brooklyn middle school a little before the beginning of first period. I was met by the dynamic duo of Drew Tagliabue and Kalima McKenzie-Simms from PFLAG NYC who led me and two other volunteers from PGLAG NYC’s Safe Schools Program to the guidance office. The head counselor gave us the schedule that had our two teams presenting to a total of six classrooms of either sixth or seventh-graders over three periods. Then she let us know we did not need to mention the election in our talks and storytelling. “The kids are scared this morning,” she said. “They don’t know what it all means. But we’re going to let the information process a little bit before we discuss it in the classroom.” She told us she was glad we’d been scheduled to come in. “Your being here will help normalize the day as much as possible and demonstrate that life goes on after an election.” I understood the need to process; I was still doing that myself. And I was struck by the irony that we'd come to talk about creating a safe school environment, free from bullying, when we’d just elected the country’s most outspoken bully as president. Seeing those anxious young faces in the classrooms reminded me how now more than ever it’s important to:
- Raise awareness and understanding of LGBTQ people.
- Bust the myths that exist about gender identity and sexual orientation.
- Protect and keep safe those students who are “different” by nurturing the next generation of allies.
Adversity is the mother of progress. ~Mahatma Gandhi
We really are all in this together. We must stand strong on the gains made and continue to fight for what we believe is decent and right. As my child Harry told me at five years old, “You can never give up, Mom.” And as Mahatma Gandhi once told the world: Adversity is the mother of progress. [caption id="attachment_5875" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Display in the main hallway at a Brooklyn middle school[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “Orlando: My tears, fears, and hopes.” “Have you come out as an LGBTQ ally?” “6 Ways to be a better LGBTQ ally.”November 11, 2016
- Oct 2016
- My new role model is an 11-year-old transgender girl.
I scanned the busy lobby of the JCC of Greater Columbus last Thursday night in Ohio, but I didn’t see her. The receptionist at sign-in told me that mom blogger Melissa McClaren had arrived already and was with her kids in the open seating area behind the front desk. Yes! Melissa brought the twins! I scribbled my name, hardly able to contain myself. When I spotted her and 11-year-olds Conner and Murphy, I felt my face become the wide-toothed-grin emoji icon. Two months earlier I’d received an email from the savvy JCC Bookfair Coordinator suggesting that a local mom join the program at my upcoming book event. I loved that idea. I’d just been corresponding with the mom that same day on Facebook. I’d been a fan since finding her personal essays on The Huffington Post. Last spring she wrote a smack-down response to the so-called “bathroom bills” springing up around the country. And the week before arriving to meet her in Columbus, she shared an emotionally charged piece on the parenting journey that has lead her and Conner to puberty blockers. [caption id="attachment_5822" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Melissa and me, JCC of Greater Columbus[/caption] I waved to the threesome on my way over to greet them and then embraced Melissa. After introductions, Conner wanted to give me a hug. I was "the second celebrity” she had ever hugged, the first being her hero Jazz Jennings. She told me she wanted to be a public speaker and had just submitted her first article to a girls’ magazine. I learned she loved science, especially astronomy, and had a theory on how to come out the backside of a black hole. Murphy, on the other hand, was happy with a handshake. After my reading, and our conversation that included a pointed discussion on the importance of visibility for transgender and gender-nonconforming kids, Melissa asked if anyone in the audience had a question. Murphy’s hand shot up like a rocket from the back row. Melissa told him she wanted to take questions from the adults first, but returned to him for the last question of the evening. “Can I have another cookie?” he wanted to know. Murphy received a big laugh from the room, and, with a “yes” from mom, he got his cookie.
“So, Conner, what would you want the parents of a transgender child to know?” I asked.
Then, eyeing the future public speaker sitting in the last seat of the last row, I asked Conner if she might like to come up on stage and take a question. She agreed and, with a little swerve past the cookie plate, walked to the front of the room and up the steps to the stage. Melissa handed her microphone to Conner. I watched as that confident young girl in a turquoise butterfly tee and multi-colored heart print skirt took a deep breath, clutched the mic to her chest, and stood tall. I couldn’t help but smile at this astronomy-loving star of a bright and hopeful future. “So, Conner, what would you want the parents of a transgender child to know?” I asked. “I’d say that if you have a boy who tells you he’s really a girl, or a daughter who tells you she’s a boy on the inside, or a child who doesn’t feel like either, believe them,” she began. “It might be difficult at first…but think of it like a rock…the first rock you’ll climb as a parent of that child. And there will be other rocks. But when you get to the top of the mountain, it will be beautiful.” Melissa and I shared an astounding glance. Then I started the roomful of applause that Conner’s remarkable response deserved. She had spoken with such poise and confidence. I could feel Melissa beaming with pride, and I was so moved by the two of them, mother and daughter. [caption id="attachment_5821" align="aligncenter" width="500"] l. to r.: Melissa, Conner, yours truly and Murphy[/caption] After signing books, we posed for some photos. Aside from the group shot where Murphy is showing his hint of a smile, my favorite is the selfie Melissa took with Conner popping into the background. Before we left there were more "cuggles" – the twins’ term for a hug + cuddle. And I felt so honored that steady and seemingly all-knowing Murphy wanted one now, too. [caption id="attachment_5824" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Melissa, me and the photo bomber[/caption] A week later, I still get a little misty when I think of Conner’s advice to parents: “Believe them.” After meeting Melissa and her children I am resolute that being an advocate for LGBTQ kids, and helping their parents understand them, is absolutely the right work for me. I can only hope to channel Conner’s presence, commitment, and ease wherever I go. Now, cuggles for all! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "4 lessons for parents of gender-nonconforming kids." "What my son taught me about gender identity." "An island rainbow of gender diversity."October 28, 2016
- My fall photo album: drag royalty, gender-bender acceptance ...
NOT BATTING AN EYELASH
My friend Sharon and I arrived at Bushwig 2016 last month soon after the doors opened. The “biggest, queerest & most fabulous festival of drag, music & love in the world” had moved to the 5000-person capacity Knockdown Center, and we wanted to take in the food, live music, retail vendors, and outdoor music before our favorite performers sashayed out onto the stage. Electrifying the crowd that night was the one and only, “large & in charge” Queen Latrice Royale of RuPaul’s Drag Race fame. One of my most fun, love-filled moments of the evening didn’t take place in the spotlight at all. It was under the bright flourescents of the bathroom. A bathroom for all. My jaw dropped as I walked into a space bigger and cleaner than my entire apartment. I headed beyond the mirrored walls, past the backs of people dressed in skirts and pants standing in front of the the row of urinals, to one of more than a dozen stalls. Then at the sink, I marveled at the freedom I felt in that room. “This is so civilized!” I said to the person next to me. “ No kidding!” they replied. “Compared to last year’s port-a-potties or the closet with the broken door the year before.” “No, I mean here we are – people of every gender – all using the same bathroom. And no one cares.” “Oh, yeah, that,” my bathroom acquaintance said rolling their eyes. “So dumb. But today we’ve got peace!” I loved their outlook, and the fact that I live in NYC where using the restroom consistent with who you are is simply the law. Just then I saw someone with the most ginormous eyelashes ever ask a friend for help adjusting them. And I asked if I could take their picture. I honestly didn't want to leave that bathroom. But royalty awaited. And if you're wondering why there no photos of Harry on stage as the fabulous Amber Alert, the poor darling woke up too sick that morning to even drag himself of bed. But she's promised to make up for it in 2017. And Amber does keep her promises.A MOST PROVOCATIVE QUESTION
The hometown advantage was definitely at play in Milwaukee a couple of weeks ago when Boswell Books, a store from Harry’s childhood, hosted my first book-launch event. Among the crowd of 160, that included some people I didn't know, were my favorite aunt, cousins, friends from high school, college and past careers, former neighbors, couldn’t-live-without-them gal pals, friends of friends, and even an old crush. I told them I felt like I was on an episode of This Is Your Life. Harry and his dad Ken were there, too. They'd even agreed in advance to field any questions the audience might have for them after my reading. As Harry walked up to the podium, he stopped to give me a hug and whispered, “I’m so proud of you, Mom.” It was a moment I’ll never forget, from one of my most memorable nights ever. Two days later, at my reading at the Women and Children First bookstore in Chicago, the mom of a gender-nonconforming child asked me a question that has really stuck with me. “When did you come to really accept Harry?” she asked. My eyes blink in rapid succession as I thought hard. She wanted to know when I’d first accepted Harry’s gender nonconformity. My brain flipped through images of him twirling in a skirt from his dress-up box, masquerading as a vampire geisha on Halloween, and crossing the auditorium stage at his high school graduation in red patent leather stilettos. But I couldn’t pinpoint an a-ha moment of “acceptance.” “I don’t know that I ever didn’t accept, Harry,” I told her. “I’ve always just loved him. And for me, love means acceptance. Even if I didn’t understand him, my love for him, and my desire for him to know that love, and feel safe, happy, and secure, always overrode any confusion I had.” She nodded. And I could relate so well to what I imagined was an internal struggle to balance fears of the unknown and worry about the future safety of her child with what it means to love unconditionally. But later, I wondered if I'd been honest in my reply to her. Was it possible that I just couldn't get my head around the idea that before a certain day, I had ever disapproved of my child. I thought about Harry at four years old, the second time he wanted to be a girl for Halloween. He was the center of my universe, but I hadn't let him be the Pink Power Ranger he wanted to be. So if I didn't encourage him because I wanted to protect him, did that mean I hadn't approved of him? And maybe that meant I hadn't truly accepted him and his expression until I came face-to-face with my own double standard once again, this time about the color pink. Those memories were powerful reminders of what I hoped I'd conveyed to that mom in Chicago: If you let your kid be, love wins.BE REAL. BE YOU. BE OUT.
At the very last minute three days ago, I flew back to my hometown to accept one of Milwaukee Pride’s first-ever BeOUT Awards for LGBTQ Visibility. The organization that has hosted 30 record-breaking PrideFest extravaganzas, held the award ceremony at the close of their new fall BeOUT Milwaukee event, to celebrate the impact of LGBTQ visibility on National Coming Out Day. [caption id="attachment_5773" align="aligncenter" width="500"] From r. to l.: Miltown LGBT Families founders Joseph Brooks and Laurie Marks, yours truly, and Joseph's husband, Bradley Ewardt.[/caption] The Milwaukee Pride Board of Directors presented an award to Miltown Milwaukee Families and one to me for elevating the “image, reputation and awareness of LGBTQ people, culture, history and critical community needs within the past calendar year.” I was truly honored and so thrilled to receive such a meaningful award on the day that celebrates coming out as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer/questioning, or as an ally. The Visibility Award meant a lot to me for another reason, too. It was because of something a mom in a private Facebook group posted recently. She wrote that her teenage son, who’s gay, said if he ever got a tattoo it would be of a jellyfish. He reasoned it was because when you’re a jellyfish, you’re pretty much invisible. But then when people come up to you and see who you are, they turn and swim away fast. It pains me to think of any child sad or lonely because they feel hidden, rejected, or socially isolated. And I believe strongly that it takes the voices of advocates and allies speaking up and speaking out to give every LGBTQ+ person the freedom they deserve to be their true, worthy, and loveable selves. The day after the award ceremony, before heading back to the airport, I saw that Harry had written Facebook post on National Coming Out Day. His message spoke about the “privilege” of being “out” and the importance of creating a society where no one has to feel like “the other” or defend their very existence. With the pride and joy I feel at being Harry’s mom, I must tell you all, We’ve got work to do! [caption id="attachment_5774" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Adam Bouska, l., and Jeff Parshley, are founders of the NOH8 Campaign, a sponsor of BeOUT Milwaukee 2016[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: An explosion of drag performance, music & love? Must be Bushwig 2015! Picking the gender-stereotyped 'girl toy.' What my son taught me about gender identity.October 14, 2016
- Sep 2016
- When a trans boy still likes 'girly' things.
I remember clearly the confusion and questions I had as my toddler son who loved pink, glitter, and Barbie dolls grew to adulthood. Vocabulary has expanded over the decades to include terms like transgender, nonbinary, and gender fluid. But parents of kids who don’t fit society’s norms or even their own perceived ideas of what it means to be a boy or a girl can still be puzzled. For example, what does it mean when a trans boy still likes "girly" things? I appreciate so much the My Kid Is Gay website for helping perplexed parents. And I’m honored whenever the editors there call on me for the advice that follows: “My 16-year-old claims to be trans, but I don’t believe it. I cannot see my daughter as a boy. His bedroom is pink and he has a doll and stuffed animal collection. We are in a trans group for teens, and I think all of the kids are amazing. I can see him being a butch female, but a trans guy? Not so much. We are very close, and I don’t want to be an unsupportive parent, but I honestly don’t understand this.” Your son obviously trusts you. By coming out to you as transgender, he shared his innermost, deepest truth about himself. Diving inside oneself can be scary enough to begin with. But then to share what one discovers—even with their mom—can be terrifying. I’m sure he hoped that after he told you, your unconditional love and support would not waver.
Children need a parent's trust.
To say that you don’t believe him—that you can’t see him for who he knows himself to be, because of his presentation or possessions—is the same as saying that you don’t trust him to know himself. His gender identity isn’t about how you see him; it’s about how he sees himself. Nobody can know someone else’s gender better than the person themselves. I assure you the person inside your son is the same person you have loved since birthing him. And that person needs you to trust him. From the close relationship you’ve described, I don’t really believe you’d be willing to risk losing that trust based only on your beliefs that boys can’t like the color pink or that only girls can have a doll collection. Most of us, from an early age, were taught society’s rules that boys and girls need to fit neatly inside a gender box that’s either pink or blue. Thankfully, due to continuing education and a wide range of present-day challenges to those rigid social norms, we now know that clothes, toys, and colors don’t have a gender. Boys can wear dresses and play with dolls; girls can have buzz cuts and wield light sabers.Beliefs can be limiting.
We’re talking about gender norms and stereotypes here. And stereotypes are nothing more than beliefs we accept as truth. If your beliefs about what’s appropriate for boys and girls are limiting your ability to fully support your son’s gender journey, then I think you may have a little personal work to do. Read through some of the belief exercises I suggested to another mom for her husband to think about. Challenge yourself. Bust a few myths! There’s a wealth of other information in the gender section of My Kid Is Gay, including shared stories and practical advice to help you better understand your son. I also strongly urge you to pick up a copy of This Is a Book for Parents of Gay Kids. It covers every question parents might struggle with after their child comes out to them. It’s the kind of book you can come back to over and over as new questions arise. I think you’ll find the chapter titled “Questioning Gender” invaluable right now.Support groups for parents.
And while I know you and your son are in a group for trans teens together, I’d like to recommend a support group just for parents of transgender kids, where you can hear how parents in similar situations are managing their concerns. PFLAG NYC has more than a dozen online support groups. And the national organization has hundreds of chapters across the country. Ideally, there will be one near you. Lastly, I bet you’d agree with this statement: no one knows you better than you. Please extend that same understanding to your son. Trust that he knows himself better than anyone. Even if his gender identity continues to develop or change over time, which it may, it’s my hope that you’ll believe him every step of the way. And whether or not you fully understand what’s going on inside his head, what will be most meaningful to him are your smile, your hugs, and your continued love and support in every present moment. I believe he needs all of that more than you know. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “When a mom is worried about her teenage son’s ‘femininity.’” “Gay, straight or transgender, all teens want freedom.” “What my son taught me about gender identity.”September 30, 2016
- 4 lessons for parents of gender-nonconforming kids.
This piece was first published on Advocate.com My queer kid is 26 years old, so “back-to-school” is no longer part my active vocabulary. But I still enjoy watching the parents on my block escort little ones to their first day of kindergarten or elementary school. I flashed this year on the small percentage of those children who, like my child, will come out one day knowing themselves to be lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, or agender. I imagined those kids headed to new classrooms, all feeling loved, valued, and supported for who they were in that moment. I wanted to believe they were dressed in the outfits they chose for the special first day. I hoped they were carrying the backpack they had picked out, and that their hair was styled how they wanted it, regardless of the gender expectations they’d been assigned at birth. Seeing those kids, I thought about how far I’d come from the years I took my son to first days of school wearing shorts when I knew he would have preferred a skirt. I also meet parents who think my experience raising a child who now identifies as queer might somehow make me an expert on their child. The friend of a friend ask me recently how to know if her four-year-old boy who liked dresses and lipstick was struggling with gender issues or just engaging in imaginative gender play. I was struck by the phrase “struggling with gender issues” in connection with a kindergartner. I couldn’t imagine the child being anxious over LGBTQ youth homelessness or transgender inequality. I figured the mom was referring to gender identity, a term I didn’t learn until my son was in college. And I knew from my son’s early years there was also a good chance the person struggling was the mom, not the child. My son came out by telling me, “Inside my head I’m a girl.” He was two years old. At the time, I had no idea what that meant. There were few resources in 1992, no internet, little knowledge, and a lot of misinformation and stereotyping. Terms like transgender, gender nonconforming, gender creative, and gender expansive didn’t exist. I struggled to understand my toddler, and I knew the mom questioning me was probably experiencing the same confusion and worry I felt when my then-six-year-old son took one of my lipsticks and hid it under his pillow.
I learned it’s never too late to learn from your child as much as you learn for your child.
Whenever I’m asked to weigh in on whether or not someone’s child is transgender, gender nonconforming, gay, or just going through a phase, I say I honestly don’t know. And then I ask my own question: Is your child is happy? If the answer is yes, what that child wears, likes to play with, or wants to be called shouldn’t really matter, I say. As long as they love their child unconditionally and listen carefully to what their little boy or girl tells them about him or herself, their own child will eventually help them answer the pressing question. And gender experts exist to help the parents understand what might lie ahead for their child and their family. On the other hand, if I learn their little boy becomes sullen when told he’s too old to play with his sister’s dolls or a little girl stomps her feet when told she must wear a dress to a party, or a child withdraws after being told they can only be a boy based on their anatomy, I feel a rush sadness. Usually those parents are just worried, as I once was, that their child will be teased or bullied by other children when they get to school. While I understand the desire to protect gender-nonconforming and trans kids, I don’t think any parent wants to be become their child’s first bully.Kids are as unique as their fingerprints, so it follows that not every child will fit inside the boundaries of pink or blue that our historically rigid society has constructed as the norm.
In the time my gender-nonconforming child grew from toddler to adult, I learned it’s never too late to learn from your child as much as you learn for your child. So here, for parents who want to better understand a child who may be different than they’d ever expected, are four things I’ve learned or unlearned:- Gender may not be what you think it is. Gender for me used to mean one of two boxes you checked on a driver’s license application. But I now know that I was confusing sex and gender to mean the same thing, which I think a lot of people still do. Gender identity is about how you feel inside, who you know yourself to be. And it develops over time. We all discover ourselves as we grow, and finding our true gender selves is part of that discovery. The gender experts will tell you that if a child’s sense of self is being denied, they will likely become distressed, low-spirited, or depressed. And, for me, any one of those words connotes a child struggling not with their identity, but with a search for freedom within their family.
- There’s no right way to be a boy or a girl. Transgender kids will tell you that a girl can have a penis and a boy can have a vagina. A gender-nonconforming, gender-creative or gender-diverse child knows that boys can be happy wearing dresses, playing with Barbie dolls, or liking the color pink. Kids are as unique as their fingerprints, so it follows that not every child will fit inside the boundaries of pink or blue that our historically rigid society has constructed as the norm.
- Every child is a whole person. Each child – and adult – has traits that our society has deemed as either “masculine” or “feminine,” but are in fact just the characteristics that make up a complete person. Some boys like to express the so-called “feminine” side of their whole being, while the same can be said for girls and those traits labeled “masculine.” I like to project how much kinder and more accepting our society would be if sensitivity and nurturing qualities in all kids were as valued as strength and assertiveness.
- A gender-nonconforming or trans child is a thought leader. If your child is defying gender norms and stereotypes, they are re-shaping the way we think about gender. They are at the center of a sea change not only among families, but also in schools where diversity and fairness are key, and among those legislators who want to insure all children are treated equally under the law. I compare gender-nonconformity to handedness. Being right- or left-handed is just who you are. Right-handedness is more common, but that doesn’t make it correct, more “normal,” or the only way to be. Increased visibility of our less common trans and gender-nonconforming children is broadening awareness and expanding the national conversation about gender. I like to think they are among the leaders on progress to rework society’s rules about gender identity, gender expression, and the expectations that follow an “M” or “F” stamped on a birth certificate.
September 19, 2016
- It's official. I'm a published author!
[caption id="attachment_5664" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Harry and me on the official pub date. Image: Wendy Ploger[/caption] I appreciate you so much for reading my book, talking about it, and sharing the news of its release on social media. Thank you, thank you, thank you! I started this journey in 1992, when little two-year-old Harry told me, “Inside my head I’m a girl.” I know there are thousands of parents who are just now beginning a similar journey, learning about and struggling with their child’s gender identity. I'm sure many aren't even sure what "gender identity" means, like I didn't at the time. I’m hopeful my story will add to those that help them understand that discovering our gender selves is just one aspect of discovering who we are as individuals. [caption id="attachment_5248" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry painting the town pink, 1993[/caption] I wanted to celebrate the official release date with Harry, of course! We agreed to meet after work Tuesday at our local Barnes & Noble. It was quite a thrill to walk into the store and see Harry standing at the “Thought Provoking” table holding a copy of a book with his photograph of him at five years old on the cover. And to watch him take a picture of My Son Wears Heels with his cell phone was one of the sweetest moments of the night. [caption id="attachment_5665" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Image: Wendy Ploger[/caption] It’s been wonderful, too, to get photos of the book from people in other states who’ve spotted My Son Wears Heels in the gender studies, parenting, and memoir/biography sections of local bookstores. [caption id="attachment_5666" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Image: Corliss Williams[/caption] I’m very excited my 14-city national book tour will kick off with a talk and reading in hometown Milwaukee on Wed., Sept 21 at Boswell Book Company. It’s just a few blocks from Harry’s childhood home. And I’m so happy he’ll be at the event, too! [caption id="attachment_5656" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Boswell Book Company, Downer Avenue, Milwaukee. Image: Tami Quinlan[/caption] In other news, Bust magazine ran an edited excerpt from My Son Wears Heels online this week. It’s one of my favorite stories from the book, when teenage Harry and I are in Las Vegas and experience a drag show for the first time, together. I must say I love the header image they chose, as Harry does like to quote RuPaul's mantra: We're born naked, and the rest is drag. And speaking of drag shows, Mz. Amber Alert (aka Harry) will be performing at Bushwig this weekend. I’ll be at my usual spot close to the stage, so stay tuned for LOTS of photos from Brooklyn’s fiercely fun and fabulous festival of drag, music & love. [caption id="attachment_5673" align="aligncenter" width="500"] l. to r., Harry and his friend James at the Brooklyn Museum[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Please judge my book by it's cover." "An explosion of drag performance, music & love? Must be Bushwig 2015!" "Life lessons learned from a drag queen."
September 9, 2016
- Shared coming-out stories make schools safer for LGBTQ kids.
It’s not everyday you get an invitation to a storytelling workshop with the cast of the Tony award winning Best Musical, Fun Home. But volunteers in PFLAG NYC’s Safe Schools Program were lucky enough to have that chance last week and then stick around to see the show afterwards. Last week thirty of us, from millennials to baby boomers, crowded into a basement rehearsal room at the Circle Theatre with six brilliant Fun Home cast members: Michael Cerveris, who plays Bruce, the father; Judy Kuhn (Helen, the mother); Beth Malone (Alison, the main character); Emily Skeggs (Medium Alison, the character in college); Roberta Colindrez (Joan, Alison’s college girlfriend); and Kally Duling (the understudy for Medium Alison and Joan). A reporter and photographer from the New York Times were there too, and a lovely article about the workshop appeared online the following day. Our PFLAG group of volunteers was eager to hear the actors’ thoughts on how to build our storytelling, performance, and speaking skills so we could make even stronger connections with the middle and high school students we’ll be talking to when the Safe Schools Program starts up again this fall. [caption id="attachment_5640" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Many from FUN HOME's cast marched with PFLAG in NYC's Pride Parade 2016[/caption] We visit New York schools in pairs: one of us is LGBTQ, and the other is a parent or family member of an LGBTQ person who has come out to them. Last year, our band of storytellers spoke to nearly 6,000 students at more than 37 schools, for a total of 205 school visits, more than double the numbers reached in 2011. According to Drew Tagliabue, executive director of PFLAG NYC, requests are coming in this year for us to speak to kids in elementary schools. “Five years ago, we barely talked about people coming out as transgender, but now schools are clamoring for that help," Mr Tagliabue said.
“The dynamics of what kids are asking is changing, too,” he continued. “They now understand LGBTQ and are often thrust into trying to change the minds of older family members. Schools see us as the conversation starter, so we can normalize talking about it.”
We volunteers share our personal stories in classrooms for the purpose of…wait, I’ll let a sampling of students and teachers explain our “why” through some of the feedback surveys they sent in. “I liked the fact that these were real people telling their real, personal stories, and I could connect better with their struggles and was really compelled to listen.” – Student “I learned that you can't always know things or assume things about people. You can’t judge people without knowing them specifically. Everybody has their own life story. I learned to treat other people more respectfully because you never know when someone is trying to deal with more than you can see.” – Student “What I liked best about the PFLAG presentations was that I got to hear life stories from other people. What I didn’t like was that it took so long for David to come out. There should’ve been people around him who supported him. Maybe I could do that for someone.” – Student “I LOVED the program. It was effective because many of our students don't know that they've met someone who is LGBTQ and therefore cannot connect the idea to a real person. That can help keep homophobia alive and well. The biggest influence of this program was that they got to talk to an LGBT person or parent of an LGBT person face-to-face and connect with his or her story. The people who were chosen were so very professional in the work that they did with our students.” – Teacher “My students have such deeply rooted ideas about the LGBTQ community due to their culture and upbringing. Many of their families continue to harbor prejudices. It is so important to have real people stand in front of them and talk about their lives. When they hear the emotion with which the speakers talk about things that they have gone through, it really gets them to pay attention and question their own thinking and actions.” – Teacher Everyone in the basement at the Circle Theatre that late afternoon was touched by how much good the Safe Schools Program is doing to make schools safer and welcoming for all. Standing at the front of a classroom of young students to share my story about being Harry’s mom is one of the most rewarding things I do.It’s so important for children to be their authentic selves at school and for the next generation of allies to step up.
If you’re in the New York City area and are part of the LGBTQ community or a family member who’s had a loved one come out to them, I hope you’ll consider volunteering some time to the PFLAG NYC Safe Schools Program. A beginner’s training session is in the works, and we’d love to have you help put an end to homophobia and transphobia in schools. Those kids really need to hear from more “real people.” To get started, just shoot an email to: safeschools@pflagnyc.org [caption id="attachment_5651" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Classroom poster from a PFLAG NYC Safe Schools Program visit, 2014[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Now who can tell me what transgender means? This one's a little tricky." "Have you come out as an OGBTQ ally?" "In defiance of gender roles: Clothes!"September 3, 2016
- Aug 2016
- A dream come true: The New York Times Book Review!
Okay. So this photo of me jumping in the air was actually taken last summer. But it’s the closest I could come in recent snapshots to how excited and proud I am to see a positive review of My Son Wears Heels in this week’s issue of The New York Times Book Review (NYTBR).
“Tarney does an exceptional job of tracing the zigzagging line of Harry’s self-identity and recalling the inevitable questions asked along the way.” –NYTBR
The review, by Meghan Daum, is titled, ‘Inside My Head I’m a Girl’: Three Ways of Growing Up Gay. My book is featured along with those of two writers I hold in high esteem: Garrard Conley and Steven Gaines. [caption id="attachment_5591" align="aligncenter" width="300"] Image from the New York Times Book Review[/caption] It hardly seems a coincidence that I’m in the middle of reading Conley’s heart-wrenching memoir, Boy Erased. (When finished, you can expect a blog post on the damaging and horrifying dark arts of “conversion therapy.”) Steven Gaines’ One of These Things First, is next in queue on my nightstand. I’ve been eager to read about his experiences as a gay teen since hearing about the book last spring. And I’m thrilled to be on the program bill with him at a book festival in Naples, Florida in February. Sandwiched between the two of them in the review, I feel a little bit like the peanut butter and jelly between two slices of designer gourmet breads. I only wish Garrard and Steven's parents had been able to read My Son Wears Heels when their sons were young. But now I’m hopeful my story will help the thousands of parents and families out there that I know are just beginning this journey.“Tarney…turns supportive parenting into an extreme sport.” –NYTBR
You can read the full review here: ‘Inside My Head I’m a Girl’: Three Ways of Growing Up Gay. I also want to thank you for reading and sharing my book. Being able to contribute to the community of support for gender creative children and LGBTQ youth means the world to me. I'm so appreciative of all the loving parents who are on this journey too! [caption id="attachment_5616" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry and me, 1999[/caption]IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE:
"The gender angel for gender-nonconforming kids." "When gender nonconforming means not fitting in." "A look to the future for gender-nonconforming kids."August 21, 2016
- Please judge my book by its cover.
Ta-da! I’ve hit the refresh button on my website today to feature the upcoming release of My Son Wears Heels. You’ll find it on the shelf of your favorite bookstore on Tuesday, Sept. 6th. It really feels right to me that this labor of love will officially debut the day after Labor Day. (I did, after all, title one of my first blog posts, “There’s no epidural for birthing a book.”) As for the look of the book, I want you to know that I chose this particular photo of Harry for a reason. His dad, Ken, took the portrait at his design studio when Harry was five years old. Ken is also a fine art photographer, so there was no shortage of photos for me to choose from. But, for me, this one captured the essence of Harry as an incredibly self-aware kid. I hadn't realized at the time how well Harry knew his inner self, his truth, and his power. When I look at this photo of Harry now, I see every child – those who meet society's gender expectations, the gender creative ones, and transgender kids. I see every child eager to make friends, discover their favorite toys and activities, and find their place in the world. I see every child seeking love and approval. I see your child, your niece or nephew, your grandchild, your neighbor, your student. As for the title of the book set down the left side, that was Ken’s idea. I smiled hard the first time I saw his design of the cover. I thought it spoke perfectly to my expect-the-unexpected, 22-year journey with Harry that unfolds on the pages within. I’m so excited for you to read My Son Wears Heels! Copies can be ordered on IndieBound, Amazon, or Barnes & Noble. (My publisher will love you for that!) My Son Wears Heels will be in stores in the U.S. and Canada on the official release date of Sept 6th. There will also be an Amazon Kindle and Barnes & Noble NOOK offered in September. The book will be available in Europe and elsewhere starting in October. If you’re in Europe you can pre-order from your favorite local bookseller or from Eurospan Bookstore. Thank you so much for joining the kickass journey! [caption id="attachment_330" align="aligncenter" width="480"] Harry as Hedwig & me outside the Oriental Theatre, Milwaukee, Wis., 2008[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "There's no epidural for birthing a book." "Life lessons learned from a drag queen." "My toddler was a gender rebel."
August 12, 2016
- Picking the gender-stereotyped 'girl toy.'
“Buying toys for yourself now, Mom?” Harry asked Wednesday night when he stopped by to pick up the pink Timberland boots he’d ordered on eBay. “Oh, that,” I replied, glancing up from the couch at the mini My Little Pony sitting on the counter. “That’s a Happy Meal toy.” “It is?” “Yeah, and it was my ticket into the bathroom at McDonald’s today.” Harry laughed. “What?” I explained how I’d really had to pee on my walk from 37th Street to 28th that morning. When the closest Starbucks didn’t have a bathroom, I popped into the McDonald’s next door, only to find a keypad lock on the bathroom. A dining-area employee said I needed to show a receipt to get the combination. Restrooms were for paying customers only. I didn’t want to carry another bottle of water, so I decided to just ask someone for their receipt. On my way to the counter, I passed a mom with her two kids. On their table sat a Peppa Pig figure and a small red truck. “Then it hit me,” I told Harry. “I remembered from my days doing PR for McDonald’s that you could get just the toy. So that’s what I did. And it was like going back in time, buying a Happy Meal toy for you without you being there.” Harry laughed. “When I told the order taker I wanted only a toy, she didn’t ask ‘girl toy' or 'boy toy,’ which was great! She just wanted to know which toy I wanted. And even though they still offered what could be called a stereotype ‘girl toy’ and stereotype ‘boy toy,’ they weren’t asking if it was for a girl or a boy.” “It’s so cute!" Harry said, picking up the pink toy. “I asked her what they had, and she said, ‘Powerpuff Girls and NFL.’ I knew you would’ve wanted a Powerpuff Girl, so I told her I’d take that. She returned with a handful of toys. No Powerpuff Girls, but they did have the stuffed toy gray cat from their tie-in with Secret Life of Pets, a black Spy Gear something-or-other, and the pink My Little Pony. I knew you would have wanted My Little Pony, so I bought that.” “That’s hilarious, Mom.” “It was fun! I hadn’t bought a Happy Meal toy in probably 20 years. Look at all the stuff it comes with. And the tail changes color in the sunlight! How cool is that?!” After Harry left with his new pink boots, a magenta hair scrunchy around his wrist, I thought about how much easier it was for kids now to get the Happy Meal toy they wanted, without a corporation’s determination that something was a “girl toy” or a “boy toy.” I knew that didn’t mean their parents might not discourage certain choices based on the boy-girl stereotypes they’ve learned. Ideally, parents are realizing that toys don't have a gender and that expressing likes and dislikes when it comes to toys or clothes or colors or hairstyles is simply human nature. It's so important to remember that we're all humans first, and that gender comes second.
"I realized this is all just about expression. I don’t have to figure out what it means or what this says about him."
I flashed on a recent phone conversation with a friend who has two boys. One is three, the other nine months old. She told me they'd been walking through the aisles at Target when her oldest, who loves Disney’s Frozen, spotted an Elsa dress that lights up and sings a song. He asked if he could please have the dress. And without even thinking about it, she said yes. Then a few minutes later he wanted a Star Wars Stormtrooper toothbrush, and she bought that, too."I know that ultimately kids are who they are and to just let them blossom.”
“Before knowing you, I don’t know if I would have been so quick to get the dress for him,” she said, “but I realized this is all just about expression. I don’t have to figure out what it means or what this says about him. I don’t want to put anything on him. I’m just going to follow his interests. I know that ultimately kids are who they are and to just let them blossom.” I didn't tell my friend, but I had to dab my eyes during that call. Her words reminded me of why I wanted to start this blog and write my book. After talking to her I wanted to do more, to talk to more people, to share all of my fears and my successes as Harry’s mom. I know that anyone’s child can grow up to be gay or identify in a non-binary way, and that it’s our job as parents to love and support them unconditionally and let them become their true selves. As for the miniature My Little Pony sitting on my kitchen counter, I know a certain little boy who would happily adopt it. And there’s a three-year-old girl I know who would also love to have it. I have a feeling this My Little Pony will go simply to the child I see first, boy or girl. And I can't wait for them to see that tail change in the sunlight. Well, sort of change... IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Giving a boy a dress will not make him gay." "Don't be your gender creative kid's first bully." "For every boy who...there's a girl who..."August 5, 2016
- Jul 2016
- My toddler was a gender rebel.
This piece also appears on The Huffington Post. “That’s it!” I said aloud from my seat on the subway. “Performativity!” I glanced up from the page thinking people might be staring, but no one had noticed I was talking to myself. I turned back to the New York Magazine on my lap and Molly Fischer’s article, “Think Gender is Performance? You Have Judith Butler to Thank for That.” I was learning that Butler’s landmark book, Gender Trouble, published in 1990 (the year my son Harry was born), had challenged traditional ideas about gender and introduced her theory of gender “performativity” – the belief that gender is something that continually unfolds. Other terms jumped off the page at me, too, like “binarism,” “heteronormative,” and “social construct.” I’d first heard those terms from Harry. He used all three of them in a single sentence the summer after his freshman year at Wesleyan. My son who was gay had come home from college identifying as queer. Harry explained that he rejected the gender binary and “heteronormativity,” and that gender was "all just a social construct anyway." I remember saying, “Wait…what?” It was my first real understanding of the difference between sexual orientation and gender identity.
Harry’s gender had been performative since he was two, when he thought the difference between men and women was "earrings."
My niece, Lana, introduced me to Judith Butler during a phone conversation in the fall of 2013. She was a sophomore at Grinnell, reading Gender Trouble in a Critical Theory class. I'd expressed an interest in continuing to learn as much as I could about gender identity and gender expression. I jotted down Butler's name on my future reading list, where it remains. To be honest, the text was difficult, and I didn’t get past the preface. Since then, American philosopher, gender theorist, and University of California, Berkeley professor Butler's ideas about gender and its dynamic as “performative” have become mainstream. I'm heartened that it's now being talked about as an important part of popular culture. While reading the magazine article about Butler on the subway, it struck me that Harry’s gender had been performative since he was two, when he thought the difference between men and women was "earrings." [caption id="attachment_5072" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry James, March 1992[/caption] Harry was still two when he asked one night before bed, “Momma...how do you know I’m a boy?” I was so caught off guard by the question I didn’t know what to say. Why wasn’t he asking me what book we were going to read or something easy like, “Why is the sky blue?” I gave Harry a basic anatomy lesson, but I could tell from his expression that something about my answer didn’t sit quite right. When I asked what prompted him to ask the question, he replied self-assuredly, “Inside my head I’m a girl.” And so began the journey that, twenty-four years later, has led me to Judith Butler videos on YouTube. Knowing that gender is something we create internally based on our feelings and sense of self has helped me better understand Harry’s evolution as a whole person who just doesn’t think of gender as “either/or.” My kid was a toddler of the ‘90s, who liked his Power Rangers almost as much as his Cinderella Barbie. He loved the color pink and his neighbor friend’s lacy socks. He didn’t have "gender issues.” It was I who was confused, not him. I realize now that, without my knowing it, Harry was a gender rebel. [caption id="attachment_5067" align="aligncenter" width="390"] Drawing by Harry, 1996[/caption] Two-year-old Harry had no full understanding of society’s established gender norms. And he certainly wasn’t aware yet of the gender policing that occurs through teasing and bullying for kids who express their gender differently than the expected stereotypes. I imagine most adults haven't given much thought to the concept of children who "do" gender differently than the expected norms. Harry's room and toys were mostly gender neutral, but when he wanted only “girl stuff,” the terms gender-nonconforming, gender creative, gender fluid, and transgender didn't exist in my world. And for as many times as I was confused, or scared, or worried, I tried to listen carefully and keep an open mind. I learned to trust my instincts and, eventually, not to care what other people thought. I decided that as long as Harry was happy, I'd let him lead the way. Today I’m still following, only with more confidence. [caption id="attachment_5069" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry and me, December 2015[/caption] So I do thank Judith Butler. She's added to my continuing education on the wholeness and playfulness of gender. Every child and adult who does gender differently deserves to live a fabulous life, expressing who they know themselves to be with spontaneity and joy. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Why I Cheered for 'Queer'" "Don't be your gender creative child's first bully." "What my son taught me about gender identity."July 15, 2016
- My NYC Pride weekend: Amber performs, rainbows wave & love w ...
When I saw my kid Harry on Saturday, it was outside the #cloyingPARLOR art space in Brooklyn. They were dressed as Amber Alert for a dusk performance piece and video screening in the garden with fellow alternative drag artist, Lucy Balls. Amber’s bobbed blue hair, gemmed eye make-up, nude undergarment and short aqua silk robe comprised an outfit her dad described on Facebook as “understated.” And for Amber, that was true. Knowing the performance was going to feature a "spa day" with food items from the fridge, I couldn’t help but flash to the Marge-Simpson-style blue hair Harry wore as cooking show co-host “Thelma” during the launch of his movie-making days in fifth grade. As the proud mom of an artistic and unconventional kid, I have loved watching the trajectory of how Harry has “done” or performed gender since they were in kindergarten. [caption id="attachment_4992" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry as Thelma, from the show "Cooking with Thelma & Ed," 2001[/caption] Harry complimented my rainbow manicure. I’d had it done that afternoon to match the rainbow wig I’d be wearing the following day in the New York City Pride Parade. “I’m not sure how festive tomorrow will be,” I told them. “It’s so soon after Orlando that I wonder if the mood might be more solemn this year.” “I don’t know about that, Mom,” Amber replied. “It’s Pride.” On my train ride to Grand Central Sunday morning I immediately felt an aura of electricity and excitement. Amber was right; this was Pride. People with rainbow flags and Pride signs seemed to outnumber the other passengers. A woman seated in front of me smiled as she wiggled her nails of different colors to show me we’d been thinking alike. Ironically I saw her later on 40th Street, the meet-up block for the tri-state areas PFLAG chapters. She introduced me to her wife and daughter, the latter who walked with the PFLAG banner along the entire parade route. Orlando was definitely “presente” at the parade, and I felt from the many hugs given that afternoon that everyone carried the tragic loss of 49 LGBTQ young people in their hearts. Those kids celebrating Pride Month at the Pulse nightclub would never be forgotten. Their lives were being memorialized, celebrated, and fortifying the LGBTQ community and its allies. As always, I met many wonderful parents and young people who marched with PFLAG NYC. [caption id="attachment_4983" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Erica and her glitter canister and me[/caption] I walked much of the way next to a mom who was there with her eight-year-old transgender son and one of his friends, who was collecting necklace beads. For much of way those two boys high-fived cheering spectators along the route and collected more beads. And I have to admit that I loved hearing several people ask the mom which was her transgender son. It just supported one of my favorite maxims: We’re humans first; gender comes second. As we walked past the Stonewall Inn, the area that President Obama had just named the United States’ first national monument to LGBTQ rights, a mom named Valerie, who was marching in the parade for the first time and having what she described as “the time of her life,” turned to me. “The Pride celebration doesn’t end in a few days, does it?” she asked. “What do you mean,” I replied over the cheering crowd. “I mean, look at all of these people,” Valerie said. “The official Pride Month might be over on the 30th, but the love in the LGBTQ community never ends.” “I know exactly what you mean,” I said, pointing to a colorful sign a young woman on the other side of us was holding that read, "Love Always Wins." And now, this July 4th holiday weekend, as we celebrate our freedom and independence as a country, I’ll be hoping for soon passage of the Equality Act, introduced in July 2015 to assure that all LGBTQ people in the U.S. have full civil rights and protection under the law. It’s the right thing to do, not only for adults but to show our kids that treating everyone equally matters. And equality, freedom, and safety is something we can all love. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "My Gay Pride glow segues to fireworks of freedom." "Gay Pride is an outlook." "My son was born a non-conformist."
July 1, 2016
- Jun 2016
- Orlando: My tears, fears, and hopes.
The lady at the Delta airlines check-in counter yesterday smiled as I handed her my boarding pass. And as the corners of my mouth turned up to greet her in return, the muscle movement felt foreign. I realized how little I’d smiled since reading Sunday morning’s “breaking news” email from the New York Times. “Gay nightclub…worst mass shooting…unimaginable slaughter…” The words had jumped off the page like slaps to my face. Tears streamed as I imagined the horror. I thought of my 26-year-old son Harry, and as much as I needed to hear his voice at that moment, I didn’t want to be blubbering into the phone. He was in Berlin, where I knew he had been out dancing and having fun in the city’s all-night clubs. Then I thought of the raw pain of the moms of Orlando's latinx club kids, and my tears flowed harder.
I realize it will take more than tears and outrage to stop hate crimes against the queer community.
I spent the day alone, weepy and numb. I refused to turn on the television. The images in my head were real enough. I decided to go to Michael’s as planned to buy for materials for my Pride March sign. It was going to help me deal with the shock and grief. I was surprised when the young lady who rang up my purchase was so cheerful. I wondered if she even knew about the victims in Orlando. And, again, as I reached into my bag for my wallet, I felt my eyes well up. The more reports I read about a lone gunman’s massacre using military-style assault weapons, the more I was able to move from sorrow to outrage over the enormity of this violent hate crime against gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, queer, and gender-noncomforming people. And I seethed, too, at the easy accessibility of semi-automatic weapons. Monday night I met up with friends from PFLAG at the vigil at the Stonewall Inn for the victims of the massacre. I realized how much I needed to grieve with other people, to hold the hands of those next to me, to shout “Say their names,” and to read signs of strength and promise and hope. One sign in particular fortified me. It read, “I will not be afraid. You cannot scare me.” I thought of my son who wears heels and his unabashed confidence and resilience. And then I imagined the unimaginable: To be feared and hated just for who I loved or how I loved. To be the victim of continual verbal or physical assaults. To know I could be fired from my job, denied a lawful marriage license, turned away from a retail store or not served in a restaurant just for being myself. I realize it will take more than tears and outrage to stop hate crimes against the queer community. So, as the healing of our grief advances, so must our action. And while filibusters (finally!) for common sense gun laws are progress, they are not enough. We must continue to speak out for the freedom, equality, and safety of LGBTQ+ family members, friends, youth, and co-workers. And, perhaps most importantly, we much teach our children – those who will truly change the world -- to accept others, to celebrate our diversity, and to expect no less of us. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Transphobia? Homophobia? May love conquer all." "He, Zie or They: Gender-specific pronouns are personal." "My Gay Pride glow segues into fireworks of freedom."June 17, 2016
- Giving a boy a dress will not make him gay.
My yoga teacher Linda’s 3-year-old son Mateo wanted a dress. That’s what she told me last December when she was pregnant with her second child. She wasn’t sure at the time that she’d get Mateo a dress, because her husband felt conflicted about it. As an artist of Mexican descent, I wondered if Mateo’s dad had experienced any disapproval as a child for not fitting his culture’s tradition of machismo. But either way, I was sure the pink tutu I knew Mateo wore occasionally was helping his dad work through some antiquated beliefs about masculinity. When Linda’s daughter, Marianna, was born this spring, I bought some books as a baby gift. I wanted to get big-brother Mateo a little something, too. I picked out Jacob’s New Dress for him, a picture book that demonstrates there are many ways to be a boy. The gifts were wrapped when I handed them to Linda, so I gave her a heads-up on the title for Mateo. “He’ll love it!" she said. "I’m actually getting him a dress for his birthday.” “You are?” I asked, feeling the urge to hug her. “He still wants one, so I ordered a couple online.” I imagined Mateo being as excited about his first dress as my son Harry had been over two decades ago when he got his first Barbie doll. Linda just wanted to do right by her little boy, and I admired her for following her instincts. “You’re such a cool mom.” She laughed. “Well, I don’t know about that. His dad feels a bit unsettled by it.” I thought Jacob’s New Dress might be a good read for him, too. The following week Linda told me that Mateo had wanted to read that book more than 100 times over the past seven days. I felt like a fairy godmother that had validated a little boy’s desire for a comfortable piece of clothing. But it was his mom who granted the wish. My writing mentor let me know on Facebook recently that she’d bought an Elsa dress for her three-year-old son. “And who knows if I would have if it weren’t for you and the Wendy fiasco," she wrote. While she was referring to one of my early Halloween disasters, her words reinforced the sea change that I felt was moving society away from the rigid stereotypes that can limit a child’s creativity and self-expression. Then earlier this week, the waves quieted when a new friend told me about her two-year-old nephew. “His sister, who’s four, is very girly,” she said. “She’s into princess clothes, dress up, and lipstick, so my nephew sees her and wants to dress-up, too. Don’t you think he’s just following what his big sister is doing?” “I do think a younger brother or sister typically wants to do whatever an older sibling does," I replied. “But then again, what toddler wouldn’t be attracted to shiny, sparkly, pretty things? I mean it’s not like boys are born liking only navy blue, dark green, and khaki.” We both laughed. “Well, my boyfriend isn’t so sure about encouraging a little boy to dress up as a princess.” And there it was: a hint of the false belief that a boy untouched by gender roles or stereotypes, who wants to put on a dress or play with a doll, will grow up to be gay. I wanted to say that I wished her boyfriend would think before he speaks, because I know how disapproving looks can convey the message, “You are not okay.” But obviously he’d been taught the same gender stereotypes that shape the expectations too many people have for boys and girls. I assured my new friend that her nephew was born with his own unique identity and will grow up to be exactly who he is. He might be gay, or he might not. Her princess niece, for that matter, could grow up to fall in love with another princess. We are who we are. And our parents, families, and friends of the family simply need to let us be our true selves, at any age, in a tutu or a hardhat, or both. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Gender, 'jewry' and a little heartbreak." "Gender confusion in Aisle 7." "Gift ideas for gender-nonconforming kids."
June 10, 2016
- In defiance of gender roles: Clothes!
Young ladies wearing tuxedos, Jaden Smith in a skirt, and my own kid Harry’s personal style of self-expression have me hopeful that this year might be trending to an end of gendered clothing. Okay, maybe that’s wishful thinking. But I think all three examples signal that the younger generations are way less hung up on ideas about “girl clothes” and “boy clothes.” Recently I smiled until my cheeks hurt scrolling through pictures of women who wore tuxes to their high school prom. The photos appeared in a Buzzfeed story titled, “Badass Ladies Rockin’ Suits at Prom.” In addition to seeing proud, happy kids, you'll get to read their comments about dressing for comfort, wearing an outfit that represents who they really are, and, well, just being true to their authentic selves. Bottom line: They looked great, with feelings to match! [caption id="attachment_4870" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Instagram: @liv.without.boundaries[/caption] The prom photos reminded how stunning I thought Marlene Dietrich looked wearing a tuxedo and top hat in the 1930 flick, Morocco. She looked cool, fierce, and incredibly sexy. The first time I slipped on a pair of "men's" tuxedo pants I was in my late twenties. I wore them with a metallic knit necktie and a leopard print jacket. I felt suddenly more confident in those pants, emboldened by two single strips of black satin. I think the sense of inner strength and invincibility they gave me is the same feeling of power Harry describes when he puts on a skirt suit or pair of high heels. And Harry has told me he doesn’t think of his clothes as women’s clothes, they’re just his clothes. [caption id="attachment_4876" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry on the set of "Between the Shades"[/caption] As a PFLAG NYC mom of a queer kid who has defied gender stereotypes since he was two years old, I volunteer to share my experiences and what I learned from Harry with classes of high school students. I usually start by asking how many of them know who Jaden Smith is. Everyone raises their hand. Most of the kids know the 17-year-old actor and rapper has been in the news for wearing a dress. A few know he’s one of the models in Louis Vuitton’s new ad campaign for its women’s wear line. And nobody laughs. [caption id="attachment_4871" align="aligncenter" width="390"] Jaden Smith, Credit: VIPix /Splash News[/caption] "I feel like people are kind of confused about gender norms,” Smith said in an interview with British GQ Style magazine earlier this year. “I feel like people don't really get it. I'm not saying that I get it, I'm just saying that I've never seen any distinction. I don't see man clothes and woman clothes, I just see scared people and comfortable people." Smith’s goal in life: “I just want to teach people how to be comfortable.” In this season of proms, graduations (where everyone wears a gown!), and Pride, I like to think that the young ladies comfortable in tuxes, the Harrys and Jaden Smiths comfortable in a skirt, are reminders that everyone has the right to define their own identity, express it freely and be proud of who they are. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The day I fell in love with Jean Paul Gaultier." "Life lessons learned from a drag queen." "Now who can tell me what transgender means? This one's a little tricky."
June 3, 2016
- May 2016
- Graduation advice for any kid.
Every child in my son’s graduating kindergarten class of 1996 was giddy. They shined beneath gold sparkly top hats and celebrated with cake. My child Harry had big dreams about first grade and beyond. He wanted to be a “scientist comedian” who made rocket fuel out of chips and dip. They also pictured themself an artist or songwriter. To mark academic achievement and feel excitement about a future filled with all they can imagine for themselves is what I wish for every child, young or old, graduating or not. Some mighty wisdom is shared in commencement speeches. From Harry’s kindergarten teacher’s brief remarks, it was to explore, discover and "be you.” No matter what the age of a child you know, here’s some memorable advice that, like sunscreen, can be applied liberally.
James Rogers, CEO of Duke Energy
Northern Carolina State University, 2011 “The best graduation gift that I—or any of us—can give you is the copyright to your own story. Begin writing it today. Write it with passion and purpose. And write it without limits.”Ms. Frizzle, CEO of The Magic School Bus
Scholastic Corporation, 1986 “Take chances, make mistakes, get messy.”Steve Jobs, CEO of Apple Computer
Stanford University, 2005 “Don’t let the noise of others’ opinions drown out your own inner voice. And most important, have the courage to follow your heart and intuition. They somehow already know what you truly want to become. Everything else is secondary.”Sheryl Sandberg, COO of Facebook
University of Southern California, Berkeley, 2016 “I hope you remember that anchored deep within you is the ability to learn and grow. You are not born with a fixed amount of resilience. Like a muscle, you can build it up, draw on it when you need it. In that process you will figure out who you really are—and you just might become the very best version of yourself.” Cheers to the graduates, past, present and future. As they celebrate all that they are and all they are becoming still, please remind them to dream big. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "No matter what their age or gender expression, all kids need to hear this." "Gay, straight or transgender, all teens want freedom." "Whatever their gender identity, every child is a gift."May 20, 2016
- Full disclosure from a queer kid's ‘controlling mother.’
[caption id="attachment_4652" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Cousins Dylan and Harry[/caption] I have a confession to make," I said. My upper lip twitched with uncertainty about revealing some of my early-mom ridiculousness. “Oh?” said my 26-year-old son Harry. “About what?” We were at Sunday brunch with Harry’s first cousin Dylan, who was in NYC for a visit en route from Tucson to London. We'd been talking about the funny ads that used to run in the back of comic books in the ‘60s and early ‘70s for pets like “sea monkeys." “Well, talking about mail-order pets just reminded me of your ant farm,” I said. “Do you remember having that when you were six years old?” “I do, but it disappeared right away. When I asked Gloria about it, she told me the ants had all died.” “Aha,” I said. Until that moment I had no idea Harry had asked our housekeeper about the ant farm. “I thought it was odd you never mentioned it again. I had kind of hoped at the time that you’d just forgotten about it. So do you want to know what really happened?” "You have to tell us now, Mom,” Harry replied. “Well, after you and Dad finished setting it up and putting the ants in, you brought it into the kitchen to show me. I was loading the dishwasher, so you left it on the counter for me. When I went to take a look, the ants, probably still in new-home-freak-out mode, were all clumped together on one side. I looked over the instructions and was not pleased to learn that the ant farm was supposed to be kept in a dark place, like a closet. “I remember thinking, ‘What fun is that?’ I’d envisioned the ant farm sitting on your dresser where you could see progress everyday. Annoyed, I put it on the floor of the coat closet and shut the door. “When you went upstairs later with your dad to get ready for bed, I checked on the ant farm. It looked nothing like the picture on the box, with ant tunnels every which way. They’d burrowed only in one spot, which looked more like a hole than a tunnel. I reached for a toothpick and tried to move a few of the ants over to another spot on the sand.” Harry and Dylan’s jaws dropped simultaneously. “I know, so crazy, right?” I admitted. “The first ant I prodded up to the sand line turned upside-down, wiggled its legs and then stopped moving. Suddenly, half the colony was on alert, surrounding the murder victim and trying to carry him back to their only hole. In an instant I’d become an ant killer. Horrified, I put the whole thing in a plastic bag, tied it up, and took it outside to the the trash bin. “That is hilarious, Mom,” Harry said, as he and Dylan both started laughing. “Your dad thought it was funny, too. ‘You can’t control everything, you know,’ he told me. And then there was that word again: control. “You may not know this, my Pilates instructor didn’t either, but in the 1990s, there were so-called child psychology experts who theorized that if a boy was feminine or wanted to play with 'girl toys,' it was because his mother was controlling. I never wanted to believe that, but it still irked me whenever I heard the word used to describe me. You did love your Barbie dolls, and I didn’t want anybody who might believe those theories to judge me." [caption id="attachment_4650" align="aligncenter" width="410"] The cousins, 1996[/caption] “I did feel really bad about the ants, Harry," I said. "At least I can make fun of my controlling self now. And I'm glad you two are here to laugh about it with me!” Note: As for certain so-called child psychology experts, they’re still out there. If there's a transgender or gender creative child in your life, steer clear of anything written by Dr. Kenneth J. Zucker of Toronto, Canada. He is famous for believing that gender-nonconforming children could be “cured” via reparative or conversion therapies. Ugh. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The gender angel for gender-nonconforming kids." "A primetime winner for parents of LGBTQ kids." "Stilettos, wedges and pumps, oh my!"
May 13, 2016
- 5 Mother’s Day maxims from a ‘gender creative parent.’
There are a lot of strollers in my Brooklyn neighborhood. Lately I’ve been noticing more first-time moms with newborns close to their chest in baby carriers. And probably because Mother’s Day is approaching, I can’t help but notice the adoration and pride on their faces. I’ve gotten a little misty-eyed passing them on the sidewalk, as I think about all of the joy that’s to come for them, especially on Mother’s Day. But I know newborns aren’t always about sweet smelling skin and irresistible cooing sounds. No matter how many “What to Expect” books one reads, some mechanics of motherhood can be a complete mystery. Case in point: My next door neighbor, who is a new mom to baby Sandi. I couldn't wait to meet the little munchkin and brought over some children's books and the girl's first car -- a yellow Flower-Power-painted toy VW Bug -- apparently a big yawn from her vantage point. [caption id="attachment_4606" align="aligncenter" width="500"] My new neighbor and her first car.[/caption] When my friend was ready for her first mom-daughter outing to the Botanical Gardens, I helped her adjust the straps on her three-week-old's Baby Bjorn. And even though the precious bundle slept the entire time, my new-mom friend worried that her baby wasn’t comfortable. I flashed to my now 26-year-old son Harry’s newborn screams that could have awoken the dead if they* weren’t happy. “I think she’d let you know if something wasn’t right.” I said. “Oh, I’m such a newbie!” she groaned. “I have no idea what I’m doing most of the time.” I remembered thinking that very same thing quite often when Harry was little. After discovering the six reasons he could be crying as an infant, came the time at two years old when he told me “inside” his head he was a girl. A year later he wanted to be a girl when he grew up. Then at six years old, they were content being a boy, but wanted to wear girl clothes from the dress-up box. “You’ll figure it out,” I told her. “Experience is the best teacher.” Experience helped me the most during my clueless early years as a mom. The lessons learned from my gender creative child also played a big part on my journey to kickass in the mom department. The learning curve was sometimes steep, and in many ways required that I become what developmental and clinical psychologist Diane Ehrensaft calls a gender creative parent. I know I became a whole lot smarter thanks to my kid. Here are a few things Harry taught me over time.
- No matter what books you’ve read about what to expect from your child, it’s the unexpected that makes you think.
- Children don’t think about what they can’t do or shouldn’t do. They think about what they can do and would like to do. Just like adults, they want to be free.
- Children are better than adults at accepting their differences.
- Fitting in means being accepted for who you are.
- Life is supposed to be fun.
May 6, 2016
- Apr 2016
- The Purple One always wore heels.
[caption id="attachment_4577" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Thanksgiving, 1994[/caption] My hand covered my mouth yesterday afternoon as I read the breaking-news headline that Prince was dead at 57. Alone at my computer, I imagined a purple rain of tears among his fans. I had a secret crush on him in the early ‘80s. His clothes reminded me of Jimi Hendrix. His guitar playing electrified, and his lyrics were hot. We both liked sexy music, Prince and I, and something about his androgyny appealed to me. [caption id="attachment_4592" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Image via Mobtown[/caption] Ten years after Prince won an Oscar at the 1984 Academy Awards for Best Original Song Score for that year’s Purple Rain, my son Harry got his dress-up box. Fashion was always important to Prince, just as it was for then four-year-old Harry. Harry told me in first grade that girls were lucky because they got to wear "whatever they want and play sports.” I had promised Harry that as an adult he could wear anything he wanted. I told him about Prince, among other flamboyantly dressed celebrities. And when style-conscious Harry chose head-to-toe purple as his outfit choice for parties and special occasions, again I thought of Prince.
“A strong spirit transcends rules.” ~Prince
Watching the MSNBC special “Purple Reign” last night and reading online during commercials, I learned much about Prince that I’d never known. And liked him even more. In a clip from a 2009 PBS interview with Tavis Smiley, Prince remembered being teased a lot in school as a child. As a result, he withdrew and taught himself how to play the piano. Then rather than teasing, “It became ‘wow,’ look at what he can do,” Prince said. “People giving you support is motivating.”And with that support he believed he could do anything. He said that early on in his career he compensated for the past bullying “by being as flashy as I could and as noisy as I could.” Prince wore heels every day. He had a female alter ego named Camille and recorded an album as Camille. Prince had the courage to be different. Just like Harry does now. [caption id="attachment_4595" align="aligncenter" width="468"] Harry at the school dance, 1996[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Gay, straight or questioning, kids should dress as they feel." "The appreciation of beauty doesn't have a gender." "My queer son is my own personal 'Fashion Police.'"April 22, 2016
- The ‘gender angel’ for gender-nonconforming kids.
[caption id="attachment_4555" align="aligncenter" width="405"] My gender creative child, 1998[/caption] By the time he was two years old, my son Harry loved Barbie dolls, sparkly fabrics and all things pink. That’s also the age he told me, “Inside my head I’m a girl.” It was 1992. Harry’s dad and I had no idea what that meant. The Internet was no help, because there was no internet. Terms like transgender and gender nonconforming were rare. And the concept of a gender creative child? Well, that just didn’t exist. Fast forward to April 2016, and the release of an exciting new book titled, The Gender Creative Child: Pathways for Nurturing and Supporting Children Who Live Outside Gender Boxes, by Diane Ehrensaft, PhD. It comes five years after her groundbreaking first book, Gender Born, Gender Made, in which she first coined the term “gender creative” to describe kids whose authentic gender identify or gender expression didn’t match the sex markers of M or F that appeared on their birth certificate. The Gender Creative Child is an essential guide for any parent whose child goes against the grain of society’s expectations about gender. Dr. Ehrensaft has delved deeply into the hearts and minds of gender-nonconforming and transgender children and adolescents to bust a multitude of myths. In simple language, The Gender Creative Child explores and explains affirming new ways of thinking about gender nonconformity. As she points out in her very first chapter, a dress no longer equals girl; a buzz cut no longer equals boy. And the boys and girls themselves are most often the ones challenging the old and rigid ideas of gender conformity. [caption id="attachment_4556" align="aligncenter" width="409"] Harry in second grade, 1997[/caption] For any parent or family member confused or anxious by their child’s gender creativity and complexity, The Gender Creative Child will be an invaluable handbook that provides sensitive wisdom, helpful messages, and constructive advice. In all honesty, I think it’s a must-read for all parents, teachers and pediatricians and should be in every public library. Riding the crest of the sea change of gender she describes, Diane Ehrensaft is indeed a “gender angel.” I only wish I’d had this book when Harry was growing up. I know I’ll read again and refer to it often, just as I did with the one that preceded it. [caption id="attachment_4566" align="aligncenter" width="375"] The well-worn book that changed my life in 2011.[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "When gender nonconforming means not fitting in." "Transgender and gender-nonconforming kids are just... kids." "A look to the future for gender-nonconforming kids."
April 15, 2016
- When a dad thinks being gay is being a 'sissy.'
I had my toughest assignment yet this week from my friends at My Kid Is Gay, who exist to help parents understand their lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, intersex and asexual kids. The question they asked me to field came from an anonymous mom who suspects her 15-year-old son is gay. Personally, she has nothing against LGBTQIA people, but her husband and family are homophobes. And when she tries to discuss with her husband the possibility their child may be gay, she gets the "my son is not a sissy" argument. She wrote: "How do I convince my husband to change his opinion and create a friendly environment in which our son would feel comfortable coming out?" Even if their son isn't gay, I imagined that dad's prejudice sending signals to their teenager that he might not be worthy of love or free to be himself. I felt sad and then angry. But instead of suggesting the mom strangle her homophobic husband, I submitted this reply: "I feel the love and concern you have for your teenager and want you to know I’m relieved that should he be gay your son has at least one parent in his corner. That’s one more than many LGBTQIA kids have. "I understand your desire to create a friendly environment. And to do that I think you’re asking how to change the fairly deep-rooted beliefs of someone who is prejudiced about LGBTQIA people. And that’s often easier said than done, because in reality the only person who can change an individual’s beliefs, attitude and behavior is the person himself. That’s doesn’t mean it’s impossible. But it’s going to mean work for both of you: a lot of questions and steadfastness from you; and both education and soul-searching for him.
Unconditional love is not about dictating how your child should or shouldn’t “be.”
"To help meet your goals of having a more open-minded husband and creating a loving and secure, gay-friendly atmosphere at home, I think a good place to start might be a conversation to simply find common ground. "The truth is neither of you knows for sure whether or not your son is gay. Your teenager may not even be sure himself. So try telling your husband that while you may suspect that your son is gay based on a mother’s intuition, you won’t know for certain until your son tells you so. What you do know for sure is that you love your son unconditionally. And regardless of who’s correct about his sexual orientation, you want your home to be the secure, loving place where he can feel safe to tell either of you anything that’s on his mind – be that fears, hopes, dreams or deepest feelings. "Ideally, he can commit to loving your son unconditionally and creating a home where that young man feels safe to express himself authentically. "Then ask your husband if he doesn’t also want to offer a home that nurtures trust and a close parent-child bond. And if you share that goal, ask him if he can commit to providing those things that create such a home environment: unconditional love, support, acceptance and celebration of your son for who he is as an individual. Remind your spouse that unconditional love is not about dictating how your child should or shouldn’t “be,” and it can’t be based on whether or not your son meets your husband’s expectations. Ideally, he can commit to loving your son unconditionally and creating a home where that young man feels safe to express himself authentically. "The next step is more challenging because it involves asking him to examine his beliefs about LGBTQIA people. Whether he realizes it or not, his dislike and discrimination may be creating an atmosphere or hostility in your home. So there’s an opportunity for him to identity his feelings, analyze them, discover the beliefs behind those feelings and try to figure out where they’re coming from. "Does he think two men or two women liking each other is unnatural or wrong? "Beliefs are just thoughts you keep on having, so they can be changed. It just takes time. And work. So acknowledge that you’re willing to stick by him in exploring his feelings and beliefs about LGBTQIA people and help identity the origin of those beliefs. "A good place to start is for him to think about what actions trigger feelings of homophobia (that’s the term for prejudice against gay people.) For example, does he feel uncomfortable when he sees two men holding hands? Does he think two men or two women liking each other is unnatural or wrong? From there he can ask himself why he feels that way and where those emotions are coming from. Can he identify who or what influenced that feeling? Was it his early religious teachings? Were his parents homophobic and he just took on their views? I hope he’ll see that it’s worth it to become a role model who can stand up for love. "Those first steps take time and will undoubtedly require more than one conversation. Then when he’s identified his discomfort and the root of those feelings, then he can start to examine his behaviors. For example, does he have a habit of using the derogatory word “sissy” instead of gay? Does he understand that it’s offensive? Does he make jokes at family gatherings with other homophobic relatives? Did he complain over news reports of the backlash to the recent discriminatory law passed in North Carolina? Does he see how he’s portraying intolerance of others to his son? "Experts say it takes about 30 days to develop new habits. But with desire and commitment for your son’s happiness and well-being, I hope he’ll see that it’s worth it to become a role model who can stand up for love, acceptance and equality for others regardless of race, religion, gender or sexual orientation. [caption id="attachment_4550" align="aligncenter" width="375"] My son Harry with their ever-loving dad.[/caption] "If your husband is incapable of committing to unconditional love, providing a safe nurturing home, and making an effort to change his beliefs about LGBTQIA people, then his relationship with your son will be of his own making. And if there’s not the bond between them you would hope for, then your husband will have to work it out for himself. "Either way, I encourage you to check out PFLAG.org and visit the “Get Support for Families & Friends page. You’ll find information about getting in touch with someone who’s been in the same situation as you. There’s also a link on that page to “Find a Local Chapter” with a listing of more than 500 chapters. While I haven’t had your same experience, I assure you that many moms, and dads too, have faced the same scenario. "As for your loving and accepting home, I’m hopeful you’ll advise any homophobic family members that hurtful hate speech won’t be tolerated in your home. And if you’re in their homes when egregious disrespect for human rights and equality starts up, then you, your husband and your son – or just you and your son – shouldn’t feel obligated to stay. "Lastly, you can feel free to double down on love and support for that son of yours. Even though he’s a teenager, he still needs to hear that you will love him forever no matter what, and that you’re proud of his accomplishments and the person he’s becoming. Remind him that he can be open and honest with you about anything, and that you will always have his back. Because you’re a good mom, and that’s what good moms do." IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Getting through the holidays with homophobic relatives." "Gay, straight or transgender, all teens want freedom." "When a mom is worried about her teenage son's 'femininity.'April 1, 2016
- Mar 2016
- A look to the future for gender-nonconforming kids.
My kid Harry will be in San Francisco next week for their* birthday. I like to see him on or around the day that celebrates him, so we’re getting together for brunch on Sunday. I asked him to make a reservation, because it’s Easter. And then I reminded him that I wasn’t bringing a present, because, instead, I'd offered to get a large fine-art photograph that his dad bought him framed professionally. “That’s a great gift, Mom,” he said. “And I’m glad you finally stopped buying me Easter candy.” Then I had to admit I did have one chocolaty item for him. My son used to love hunting for Easter eggs. And even though Harry will be 26 this year, I still have their notes to the Easter Bunny. And to the Tooth Fairy, too. I think Harry figured that if he wrote to Santa, why leave out anyone else who was magical. Then yesterday an email I received from a woman who identified herself as the "mom of an 8-year-old fabulous, gender creative boy" made me smile. I could feel the pride in her words. And I flashed on Harry at that age, when the terms “gender creative” and “gender nonconforming” were rare or unknown. I remembered his birthdays at that age in the late ‘90s. He wanted nothing more than Pokémon cards, bear Beanie Babies and a purple Game Boy. And as Harry’s mom, my wish every year was that the happiness of each birthday would last 365 days. I wanted him to know always the love his dad and I have for him, to be confident and secure with himself, and to feel safe in the world. That’s still my wish. I imagine it’s the hope for the mom who wrote to me yesterday. And I'm sure countless other mothers hope for that, too. Especially those moms of gender-nonconforming and transgender children in North Carolina. Like so many, I was horrified to learn that a state law, rammed through the Republican-controlled legislature and approved yesterday by the governor, eliminated anti-discrimination protection for all LGBTQ people in North Carolina, including barring non-binary and/or transgender men and women from entering the bathroom they feel most comfortable using.
We must demand full civil rights for all people.
Influential activists in the movement for LGBTQ equality, like Michelangelo Signorile and Dan Savage, have written often and spoken loudly of the enemies of LGBTQ rights. It was at a talk last May, presented by the National Lesbian & Gay Journalists Association and the CUNY J-School Chapter, that the two of them reminded writers not to be complacent following the victory of what they expected would be an historic SCOTUS decision for marriage equality. We can't be complacent; we still have to fight, they said, especially for youth issues and the trans movement. So in the wake of yesterday’s huge step back in to time to bigotry at the state level, and on the brink of similar legislation in Georgia, I want to stay focused on working for a solution. We must demand full civil rights for all people. [caption id="attachment_4508" align="aligncenter" width="500"] The restroom at The Public Theater, NYC[/caption] This morning I got an email for Mara Keilsing, executive director for the National Center for Transgender Equality (NCTE). They put together a series of resources and action items in response to the shocking and shameful North Carolina law. I’m sharing the NCTE list here not only for the people who live in North Carolina, but for everyone else around the country who’s outraged and angered by the new law. I’m hopeful you’ll agree that the time has come for all who believe in equality to step up, speak out and be heard. Let’s do it because it’s the right thing to do, and because all of our kids -- regardless of how they express themselves -- need to know we’re invested in a future for them where everyone will be treated equally under the law. Note: My kid Harry uses he/she/they pronouns interchangeably. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The (genderqueer) kid I never expected." "6 ways to be a better LGBTQ ally." "What my son taught me about gender identity."March 25, 2016
- A primetime winner for parents of LGBTQ kids.
[caption id="attachment_4471" align="aligncenter" width="450"] "The Real O'Neals" airs on ABC on Tuesdays at 8:30pm ET[/caption] I took extra time selecting my outfit for an NYC sneak peek of the family sitcom The Real O'Neals at the LGBT Community Center last week. I knew Project Runway mentor Tim Gunn would be there to moderate a post-screening conversation with two stars and a writer from the show. I figured I’d manage my usual front-row spot in the audience and didn’t want Tim to be distracted by a bad look. [caption id="attachment_4469" align="aligncenter" width="500"] l to r: Moderator Tim Gunn, actors Noah Galvin and Martha Plimpton, writer David Windsor[/caption] If you haven’t seen The Real O’Neals yet, I hope you’ll check it out. Even though gay teenagers on primetime television aren’t new, I think a family sitcom that centers on a boy coming out to his Irish Catholic parents is a welcome first. It’s a scenario that can be scary for both kids and parents, but this show does it with such love and humor that I think any viewer will be able to relax into any of those fears. [caption id="attachment_4479" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Photo: Bob D'Amico/ABC[/caption] The focus in the show's pilot was on 16-year-old Kenny who worried that coming out to his super-Catholic perfectionist mom would “literally kill her.” She is after all chairman of the church’s Bingo Bonanza and wants more than anything for her family to be featured in the church bulletin. And it’s at the Bingo Bonanza fundraiser that Kenny tells his family he’s gay, which is, of course, overheard by everyone. The second episode previewed was of Kenny’s first day back at St. Barklay’s High School after his coming out.
"It takes courage to grow up and become who you really are." ~E. E. Cummings
Coming out to your parents and being bullied at school are serious issues for kids, so presenting those real-life, heart-racing experiences with humor is no easy task. But I think the writers have hit just the right balance of family fear and comedy. And I believe the messages to kids that things can (and should!) turn out okay is just as important as the message to parents that it won’t kill you if your kid is gay (or bisexual, transgender or queer). As Kenny says, he’s still the same person he was last week.“I’ve never played a homophobe before.” ~Martha Plimpton
After the screening, Tim Gunn asked television newcomer Noah Galvin, who’s wonderful as Kenny, Martha Plimpton who brilliantly plays quintessential overbearing type-A mom Eileen, and writer/exec producer David Windsor how they would characterize their experience with the show. Martha Plimpton said she saw it as an interesting opportunity, because she’d never played a homophobe before. The show presented a mother-son relationship she’d never seen before, particularly in a comedy. Viewers know she adores Kenny – she says he’s her favorite – but at the same time her fear and ignorance make it very difficult for her to reconcile his sexual orientation with her faith. [caption id="attachment_4470" align="aligncenter" width="500"] TV Mom Martha Plimpton tells it like it is.[/caption] “I really wanted the chance to explore a religious Catholic mother re-learning who her son is while antagonizing him in his process toward adulthood and going through what he needs to go through in adolescence and assert himself,” Plimpton said. “I’d never seen that dynamic before, and I wanted to be a part of it. I thought it would be a way to give those people – those Eileens of the world – a view into the reality that they’re not going to die if they accept and love and change their thinking a bit.” Tim Gunn, who will step out of the family’s television in an upcoming episode, concurred with Martha that hopefully her character Eileen, would help parents who are struggling with these issues. And he agreed with Noah and David who said ideally the show will help some young person out there, as well. “It’s a little bit of a cliché,” Plimpton added, “but that’s because it’s true, that with comedy you can approach subjects that are difficult for some people and give them permission to see themselves in it. And I hope that happens.” Kinda makes you want to watch, right? IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Transphobia? Homophobia? May love conquer all." "LGBTQ haters will die off." "No matter what their age or gender expression, kids need to hear this."March 18, 2016
- Life lessons learned from a drag queen.
ou The thick Rapunzel braid knotted on top of my kid Harry’s head hung draped over her* right shoulder. Dressed all in black, from feathered boa and long slit skirt to the open-toe stilettos, I thought Harry looked like a young celebrity. In drag, my creative director and photographer son becomes Amber Alert to her fans and me. But I wasn’t sure if the fuzzy photo on Facebook was of Amber or Harry. “Loved your look for that show at the Jane Hotel,” I told Harry over the phone. “I know you were there with the other ‘Girls of Straight Acting,’ but didn’t know if you were in drag. You weren't wearing any glitter, so I wasn’t sure.” “I had some glitter on, Mom, but it was a subtle look – no eyelashes.” “Eyelashes make a difference?” “Oh, for sure!” Harry replied. “Big time!” I appreciated the clarification, because I occasionally get questions about Harry based on his look. If wearing a dress, some people ask if she’s trans, to which I reply that my son is genderqueer. Or, if Harry’s wearing earrings with a sweater and leggings, I get asked if he’s in drag. So now I can explain that drag for Harry means false eyelashes, glitter and at least a pound of makeup. The truth is, some days Harry feels more feminine, so his gender expression just reflects how she feels on any given day or time of day. I remember asking Harry in 2005 where drag queen fit it in with transvestite and transsexual. (Transgender wasn’t a common term at the time.) It was the summer before Harry’s sophomore year in high school. He was fifteen and a Rocky Horror Picture Show devotee who dressed in wildly extravagant outfits for every midnight showing at Milwaukee's Oriental Theatre.
"When a gay man has waaay too much fashion sense for one gender, he’s a drag queen.”
Before answering me, Harry glanced over and smiled at his friend Alex who had stopped by the house. “Well, Mom, people don’t really use the word transvestite anymore. Cross-dresser is probably better. And that’s just when a straight man or woman puts on clothes of the opposite sex because it makes them feel good.” “Okay.” I’d said, thinking about comedian Eddie Izzard who often performed stand-up in a dress. “When a man feels like a woman trapped in a man’s body and has an operation,” young Harry continued, “she’s a transsexual." My thoughts went to Christine Jorgensen, my only reference point then for a transsexual (now transgender) woman. "And when a gay man has waaay too much fashion sense for one gender, he’s a drag queen.” At that, he and Alex burst out laughing. And while I stood in the living room processing that idea, they headed up the stairs to Harry’s room. I understood about “too much fashion sense,” remembering that Harry was only six years old when he tried to teach me clothes don’t have a gender. Then last month, thanks to the 1995 comedy film, To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything! Julie Newmar, that was playing in marathon rotation on Logo TV, I figured out Harry had picked up those definitions, along with many other tips, from the flick’s drag royalty duo of Vida Boehme (Patrick Swayze) and Noxeema Jackson (Wesley Snipes). I flashed on the To Wong Foo DVD cover Harry had received from a friend in San Francisco while still a high school freshman. The movie is about the road trip three New York City drag queens take to Los Angeles for the Drag Queen of the Year competition. And along with “drag princess” Chi-Chi Rodriguez (John Leguizamo), I learned a lot about life from Ms. Vida and Ms. Noxeema. At the same time, I felt an infusion of Harry’s spirit and outlook. When my kid and I are out together now and I notice someone staring at Harry’s look, I can hear Vida Boehme saying, “Your approval is not needed, but I will take your acceptance.” So I want to share what I think are important life lessons for anyone, as spelled out by Vida and Noxeema. The header is theirs.Four Steps to Becoming A Drag Queen
- Let good thoughts be your sword and shield.
- Ignore adversity.
- Abide by the rules of love.
- Stand up! Because being larger than life is just the right size.
March 4, 2016
- Feb 2016
- Don't be your gender creative kid's first bully.
[caption id="attachment_4389" align="aligncenter" width="586"] Harry as Cleopatra, age 6[/caption] Seeing photos of Adele strolling her two-year-old son through Disneyland dressed as Princess Anna from the movie Frozen made me admire the pop star even more than I already do. I wondered though her reaction the first time her boy asked to wear a princess costume. Like a lot of parents of little boys, chances are she wasn’t expecting him to want to dress in a sparkly tulle skirt. Of course the best possible response is, “So what?” But for some parents of toddler boys who want to dress in clothes that the general public says are only “girls’ clothes,” it can be confusing and worrisome. I know, because that was me 24 years ago. And it can still trigger concern today. I know that because I got a letter from a dad recently whose four-year-old son was wearing his mom’s heels, wrapping a towel around his head for hair, and pretending other clothes were a skirt. He wrote: “This is all so new to us. My wife and I are very concerned about him getting teased and bullied if he expresses any of this in preschool or out in public. "He's asked to grow his hair longer and we've agreed to allow him to do that. But as for the heels we told him yesterday that he's getting older and can't wear mommy's clothes anymore. Seems to be ok with it. Still loves to hold a scarf because it has tassels at the end and he sees it as hair or pretends it's a girl. It’s probably his version of a doll since we don't have any of those. Please pass along any advice you could share. We want our son to be happy, but also don't want him teased.” I appreciated this dad Roger’s letter so much. It took me back a couple of decades to the time Harry’s dad and I were worried about him being teased or bullied for the same reasons. We wanted our child to be happy, too, and I shared that with Roger. Here’s the rest of my reply: “From my point of view, a kid’s happiness comes from the freedom to be and express who they know themselves to be. And it sounds like Justin is a boy who likes expressing the so-called “feminine” side of his whole being. It took me years to recognize that each child – each adult – has traits that our society has deem as either masculine or feminine, but they’re really just the characteristics that make a complete person. [caption id="attachment_4388" align="aligncenter" width="405"] Harry, age 4, feeling pinkalicious.[/caption] “While I understand you want to protect Justin, I think it’s important that you not become Justin’s first bully by not allowing him to do or -- as I think you so accurately stated -- ‘express’ his likes or dislikes regarding clothes, toys or colors. We’ve been taught those things have a gender, so there may be a little unlearning to do on your part. “If Justin is in preschool, I wonder if they have a ‘dress-up corner,’ or ‘drama corner.’ Many do, as imaginary play is important for kids. Maybe providing a dress-up box for Justin would allow him some freedom to explore himself. I made a lot of mistakes with Harry, but I tried to guide myself so that I never made Harry feel like his outlets of expression in play were ‘wrong’ or something he shouldn’t be doing. “And I’m all for boys having a baby doll, because I think caring and nurturing play is going to help them be better fathers some day. "Perhaps the best way for you to protect Justin at preschool is to talk to the administrators and ask what they teach about gender expression. And how do they handle children teasing those who express outside the rigid gender boxes? It’s kids like yours who are going to bust all those myths, not just for other children, but for adults, too. At some point you may have to explain to Justin that while some people think there are ‘girls’ colors’ and ‘girls’ toys,’ there really is no such thing. And that may take examining your own beliefs, too. I recognize that I had a double standard when it came to those things. “There are two wonderful books I recommend you and your wife read. The first is called Gender Born, Gender Made, by Dr. Diane Ehrensaft, the developmental and clinical psychologist who wrote the foreword to My Son Wears Heels. The other is Raising My Rainbow, by Lori Duron. I only wish I’d had those books when Harry was two. While I want to be able to help you in whatever way I can, I can tell you that the love you have for Justin will be your best guide.” Ideally the parents of gender-nonconforming or gender creative children will become gender creative parents, giving their kids the freedom and time to explore their inner gender self. I hope little girl who wants the thrill of waving a light saber and every toddler boy who wants the chance to cradle a baby doll gets their wish. Because in the end, those freedoms mean they’ll feel loved, safe, and valued. [caption id="attachment_4412" align="aligncenter" width="343"] Harry, right, in one of his most creative headdresses.[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "When gender nonconforming means not fitting in." "Don't expect gender-nonconforming kids to conform. Ever." "Transgender & gender-nonconforming kids are just...kids."
February 19, 2016
- Transphobia? Homophobia? May love conquer all.
[caption id="attachment_4368" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Prancing Elite Tim, being challenged by friends for her gender expression.[/caption] I couldn’t believe what I was hearing. As I lurched for the remote, my dinner plate teetered on the edge of the table that separated me from the TV screen across the room. Just as I hit the pause button, Harry’s key to my apartment turned in the lock. “Harry!” I sang, excited to see the grown kid I consider my top Valentine walk through the door. “How are you, honey? The package you ordered is on the stool at the breakfast bar.” “Thanks, Mom,” Harry said, sitting down opposite me to open his latest UPS delivery. “Sorry I’m late. Angel wanted to stop at the Pat Field’s sale.” “No worries. I’m watching The Prancing Elites Project before the Democratic debate starts. And reality TV or not, I’m still a little shaken – horrified, really – by how the show opened.” What do you mean?” Harry asked. “Well, Tim, who identifies as a woman, gets challenged by two of her gender-nonconforming teammates who think she should be taking female hormones or having boob surgery so she can 'portray herself' the way they think the world expects a trans woman to present.” “Ugh. Really?” “Here, I’ll play it for you," I said. "It’s all in the first three minutes of the show.” I cringed as Tim’s dance teammate Adrian asked if she wanted to “be this way” for the rest of her life. “And what if you meet a guy, Tim, and he says that you’re not fully transgender? ’Cause you’re not respecting the image you’re trying to put on.”
That's called internalized transphobia.
Prancing Elite Jerel chimed in. “We’re not trying to offend you by saying that you look masculine, but, Tim, in reality you’re not a woman. You are a transgender woman. You can’t continue getting mad when you’re not fully portraying that image.” “I’m putting on my own image,” Tim defended, clearly hurt and angry. “Can you believe this?” I asked Harry, still incredulous that Tim’s friends could be so insensitive.There's no physical requirement to what a woman is. That doesn't exist.
“That's called internalized transphobia,” Harry said, shaking their* head. “It's rampant. Even with Caitlyn Jenner, a lot of people have the idea that trans women aren't women, no matter what they do. There's no physical requirement to what a woman is. That doesn't exist.” “I know, but why do you say ‘internalized’ transphobia?” “That it’s latent,” Harry said. “They should know better, but they don't. It's just ridiculous. They don't see it as anti-trans, but that's how it manifests. It's like gay men who say they don't like feminine men is the equivalent of internalized homophobia.” “Why is that so threatening to people?" I asked. "Because some people don't fit into the box that others think they should be in. It's tragic.” Harry – my Valentine, my tutor, my perceptive and insightful child – had once again shone a light on the expectations, assumptions and directives some people make about even their closest friends. They don't realize the emotional pain it causes. My heart ached. Tim’s friends thought they were being helpful by telling her how to act, how to be, and what she should do with her body. After Harry left, I watched the rest of the show. And I almost couldn’t handle hearing Tim’s mom at a big family dinner refuse to refer to her youngest child as she. “I know you don’t like it,” Tim’s mom told her. “But that’s just life.” So there I sat, alone in my living room, eyes welling up as it sank in that the people Tim feels closest to don’t accept her as the woman she knows herself to be. On this Valentine’s Day, I can only wish that Tim’s mom will find it in her heart to be there one hundred percent for her daughter, to celebrate her and support her for who she is. And I send big hugs and sequined optimism to Tim. I know that while dancing continues to bring her joy, her self-love will eventually draw to her a more loving and accepting world. And in the spirit of this day meant for love, that’s my wish for every youthful LGBTQ heart. *Note: My child uses the pronouns he/she/them" pronouns interchangeably. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The look of everyday love." "Married or single, every parent has a Valentine." "The (genderqueer) kid I never expected."February 14, 2016
- Why I Cheered for 'Queer'
(This piece was published on HuffPost.) I applauded and breathed "yessss" as an explosion of rainbow-hued virtual fireworks filled my apartment. My party-of-one celebration was triggered by the email I received Tuesday from HuffPost welcoming me to its "Queer Voices" page. Yep, HuffPost Gay Voices had changed to HuffPost Queer Voices, and this was huge. The editorial staff had embraced inclusivity and given voice to a word that I believed would be empowering to many of today's youth. I'm not a queer person, but I have tried to understand the term and see it from a broad perspective.
As the mom of a child who defies labeling, queer gives my son a place in a richly diverse community of people living as their authentic selves.
I've learned that queer can be used as an umbrella term that covers both gender and sexual orientation without having to declare any of the above. Queer is my son Harry's answer when asked to describe how he* identifies. My kid is a person whose total expression as a human encompasses characteristics we all possess, but which most of our society has deemed specific to only maleness or femaleness. But people have varying views on the word, and, for some, queer has an entirely different connotation. Reading the comments to "Voices" Editorial Director Noah Michelson's article about the name change, many commenters found the word queer in a banner headline offensive. For them, it was the painful reminder of a hurtful slur; they preferred the word gay. I get the same shocked response when someone my age (read: older) asks if my son is trans. When I explain that my kid is queer, people are often horrified I would use such a "derogatory" word. They haven't heard queer used as a term that describes various communities whose orientations are not heterosexual and/or not strictly male or female. To be honest, I remember being surprised myself in 2008 when my son Harry came home from freshman year in college to tell me he was queer. Queer was the word my mother had used in the 1960s and 1970s to describe her hairdresser, interior designer and an artistic friend of the family. She never used it in a mean-spirited or disparaging way; she only intended to convey that someone creative was homosexual. To her, queer just meant different. And once she learned the word gay, and understood queer to be disparaging, it disappeared from her vocabulary. I learned from her it was just synonymous with homosexual or, as she would say, "bent." So to hear my then-18-year-old son use the term queer to describe his identity caught me off guard. But there was such satisfaction in his statement. I could see that for him it was a sweeping term that encompassed all facets of their developing humanness - degrees of maleness or femaleness, body image, gender identity, sexual orientation, attitudes, and behaviors. According to Harry, queer was proudly oppositional to the dominant gender binary framework. (I remember having to ask him what "gender binary" meant.) Harry explained that queer was non-linear; it was nebulous, a term in flux. And in the context of their artistic identity, I understood queer to be a space where my kid had the freedom to continue evolving as a whole person. I had a sense those eight years ago of a generational shift within that one word. For queer people in my generation, survival was often dependent on blending in, so it's quite exciting these days for queerness to be so visible and uplifting. I believe babies come into this world knowing everything about themselves. So I think becoming who you are meant to be is about accessing your true inner self and editing out who other people say you are or who you should be. As I watched Harry grow into adulthood, I realized that life's development is really about understanding your sense of self and learning how to articulate it. [caption id="attachment_4340" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Image credit: Ken Hanson[/caption] Labels are just plain limiting, and that's why I applaud the broadness of queer. Surely there are thousands of teens and young adults exploring their own authentic selves. It's my wish that queer gives young people the same wide berth it did my son to discover themselves with joyful, cheering abandon. *Note: My son uses the pronouns "he/him," "she/her" and "they/their" interchangeably, so as Harry's mom, I do as well. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "The (genderqueer) kid I never expected. "When gender nonconforming means not fitting in." "Don't expect gender-nonconforming kids to conform. Ever."February 5, 2016
- Jan 2016
- An island rainbow of gender diversity.
[caption id="attachment_4297" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Harry's rainbow ice, Hawaii 1994[/caption] The social media maven here at My Son Wears Heels, Naomi Waxman, who I’m proud to say is now also a TA at Marquette University, is back from a trip to Hawaii with a guest blog that takes a look at beauty and gender in our 50th state. My mom’s family lives on the island Oahu. I don’t get to visit very often, but whenever I do I try to learn something new about Hawaiian culture. I remember how often I would see rainbows around the island, and my grandmother taught me that Hawaii is considered the rainbow capital of the world. I typically associate rainbows with a flag waving proudly in a parade or the magical route to a pot of gold, but rainbows hold special meaning in Hawaiian culture. [caption id="attachment_4300" align="aligncenter" width="498"] Waikiki Harbor, by Naomi[/caption] According to folklore, they are a walkway for the gods, a celestial path by which they may visit Earth. The rainbow represents a means of journeying from one world into the next. Much like the transformation of dark clouds into a stunning rainbow, Native Hawaiians understood there were people within their culture whose gender identity empowered them to take on essential societal roles. Often assigned male at birth, māhū people donned women’s dress and were entrusted with protecting and celebrating Kanaka Maoli (Native Hawaiian) culture. They acted as spiritual leaders, healers, educators, and Hula instructors. Māhū are the keepers of their history and rituals. Passing their knowledge to the next generation, they play an essential role in the survival of Kanaka Maoli culture. The arrival of Christian missionaries in the 1800s had a profound impact on Hawaiian culture, and the importance and beauty of māhū was utterly lost. These travelers feared what they did not understand, and māhū were increasingly stigmatized and excluded from society. The term itself became a slur. Through my research I became familiar with the māhū teacher Kumu Hina, who has elevated understanding about the continuing role that māhū play in modern Hawaiian society. Through a wonderful PBS documentary as well as the Hawaiian anti-bullying initiative A Place in the Middle, Kumu Hina and her “in-the-middle” students reveal not only the complexity of gender identity, but also the damage inflicted when sacred rituals and ideas are torn away from a people. [caption id="attachment_4304" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Image courtesy of kumuhina.com[/caption] In the māhū tradition, Kumu Hina has chosen to dedicate herself to teaching young Hawaiians how to keep their history and rituals alive. Chants are the oral history of Hawaii and play a fundamental role in Kumu Hina’s lessons, as do hula dances, which, as in their original conception, are religious performances. The students learn how to honor Hawaiian gods and goddesses through dance. According to Kumu Hina:
“My purpose in this lifetime is to pass on the true meaning of aloha: love, honor, and respect. It’s a responsibility that I take very seriously.”
I’ve watched the PBS documentary on Kumu Hina several times, and the love, respect, and pride shared between Kumu Hina and her students always strikes me. She encourages students to embrace their identities fully, to remember the responsibility and honor required to be the “warriors of today,” making sure their way of life is not forgotten. In an effort to describe māhū, English-speakers might use the term transgender. But in her bestselling memoir, Redefining Realness, Janet Mock emphasizes why this application isn’t quite accurate: “Māhū defined a group of people who embodied the diversity of gender beyond the dictates of our Western binary system.” I would add that these people have existed and persisted throughout history, all over the world. Transgender, māhū, two-spirit, and East Indian hijira identities, among many genders found around the world, are not a trend. They highlight the endless variation and multiplicity of the human experience, a beautiful rainbow of perspectives that should be celebrated. Check out this fantastic, comprehensive map from PBS to learn more about non-binary genders across the globe: A parent of one of Kumu Hina’s students expressed her support for her "in-the-middle" child beautifully:“Love is the biggest thing that we should always teach our children…if you love a person for who they are and let them be who they are, that’s the whole circle, right?”
[caption id="attachment_4317" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Rainbow Harry on the island of Kauai, 1994[/caption] IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: "Performing Gender in Japan" "No matter what their age or gender expression, kids need to hear this." "Now who can tell me what transgender means? This one's a little tricky."January 22, 2016
- Whatever their gender identity, every child is a gift.
On the firsts of January while we were married, my son Harry’s dad always wrote down his New Year’s resolutions. He had vision, firmness of purpose and clarity for what he wanted to accomplish in the year ahead. My list, on the other hand, was more of a mental sticky note of desired behaviors. To be more positive, more patient and less hard on myself usually topped the list. They were things I didn’t want to admit needed work, so I keep them in my head. That list didn’t change much over the years, and certainly held fast in the early ‘90s when toddler Harry was a boy who loved Barbie dolls, the color pink and anything sparkly or glittery. But I wish I’d had then a list of suggested New Year’s resolutions I didn’t discover until almost two decades later, when Harry was about to graduate from high school. And like my unwritten bullet points, they focused on attitudes and feelings. I’ve adopted the short list as my own and recommend it to anyone, especially to parents of children who color outside society’s gender boxes of pink and blue. It’s a reminder that we're capable of being exactly who our child needs in their life to become a hopeful, confident, resilient and optimistic adult. And instilled in our kids, the ideas on this list affirm that they are exactly who they're meant to be. [caption id="attachment_4282" align="aligncenter" width="406"] Harry as the Karate Kid, January 1995[/caption] So now that we’re at the end of this first week of 2016, feel free to add these four suggestions to your own list of goals or resolutions for the New Year. I’m pretty sure that no matter what you have going on today, you’re going to feel good just reading it.
- I will approve of myself, my characteristics, my abilities, my likes and dislikes, my inclinations and disinclinations, realizing that these form my unique individuality. I have them for a reason.
- I will approve of and rejoice in my accomplishments, and I will be as vigorous in listing these – as rigorous in remembering them – as I have ever been in remembering and enumerating my failures or lacks of accomplishment.
- I will remember the tremendous energy, joyful spontaneity, possibilities and potential that lie within me to create that which I can imagine for myself.
- I will realize that the future is a probability. In terms of everyday experiences, nothing exists there yet. It is virgin territory, planted by my feelings and thoughts in the present. Therefore I will plant accomplishments and successes, and I will do this by focusing on how I want and expect the future to be for me.
January 8, 2016
- Dec 2015
- From homophobes to genderqueer: The top fave blog posts of 2 ...
[caption id="attachment_4247" align="aligncenter" width="375"] Meeting Jacob Tobia for a hot chocolate, February 2015[/caption] You clicked. And the social media analytics mavens took note. The most popular posts of the year here at My Son Wears Heels were headlined with words I see remaining big news in 2016. Public awareness and understanding of what it means to be LGBTQ will continue to grow. The educated won’t tolerate homophobes, certainly not at the dinner table. And those who identify outside the traditionally accepted ideas of male and female, like articulate genderqueer activist Jacob Tobia, will help bridge gaps of knowledge and broaden national discourse. Before we scroll past 2015, I hope you’ll click on any of the year’s top posts that you didn’t get a chance to see. 1. Getting through the holidays with homophobic relatives. [caption id="attachment_4183" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry & me, Christmas 2008[/caption] 2. My nonbinary kid's awesome dad. [caption id="attachment_3645" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Harry & Ken, 1995[/caption] 3. Gender + discombobulation = Panti Bliss [caption id="attachment_4248" align="aligncenter" width="375"] Gender discombobulation at its best, June 2015[/caption] 4. My queer kid's loving aunt remembered. [caption id="attachment_682" align="aligncenter" width="500"] Aunt Shirley & Harry, 1997[/caption] 5. The (genderqueer) kid I never expected. [caption id="attachment_4250" align="aligncenter" width="407"] Harry's high school senior ID photo, Sept. 2007[/caption] Anything you'd like me to share here in 2016? leave a note in "Comments" below. Happy New Year to you and yours! IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE: "A 2014 round-up of most popular posts on My Son Wears Heels."
December 31, 2015
- Getting through the holidays with homophobic relatives.
[caption id="attachment_4233" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Harry & me, Christmas 2008[/caption] In this season of peace, love and understanding, it’s easy to forget that some LGBTQ+ youth and their parents dread holiday family get-togethers. Relatives who aren’t supportive or who are openly homophobic can trigger hurt feelings and unspoken tension. Let's face it, getting through the holidays with homophobic relatives can be tough. The good folks at My Kid Is Gay asked me to help a mother deal with the anger she’s built up towards relatives who have been incredibly offensive at Christmastime since her 18-year-old daughter came out several years ago. "I can't seem to get over it and no longer have good relationships with any of these people,” wrote the mom. “I feel so hurt and don't know how to handle holidays because I don't want to pretend it's ok when I have to be around them." My reply required digging deep. Family is family. But feeling good and protecting your child, no matter what their age, will always drive my advice: If these were my relatives, I wouldn’t want to be around them either! I’m concerned about your emotional state, and I’m preoccupied with how your relatives’ openly offensive comments affect your daughter’s well-being, because family members are supposed to love and accept each other for who they are. Regardless of the season, family gatherings should be safe spaces.
When relatives are bullies.
Here is a sad fact: There will always be people whose ignorance, fear and insecurities lead them to bully and demean others in order to build themselves up. And sometimes those people will be relatives. But here’s the thing: You don’t have to tolerate it or pretend it’s not eating you up inside. While it’s true that you can’t pick your genetic family, you can choose how and when you interact with them. (I’m still horrified that we’re talking about multiple people here and not just one rude aunt, uncle or cousin.) It sounds like you’ve tried to ignore your relatives’ hurtful anti-gay comments in the past. I say that because you’re talking about not wanting to face annual repeat offenders again this year. Typically, though, not verbalizing hurt feelings–trying to be the bigger person and not engage with their hate speech–can often embolden family bullies to continue their jokes, snide remarks and insults.You have options for handling the holidays.
So this year, even though you have distanced yourself from these relatives, I think you still have some options for how you handle the holidays. It all depends on what you want. Is there an elderly aunt who you adore that you only get to see once a year at Christmas? Is there a favorite cousin your daughter enjoys hanging out with? If your answer to either of those questions is yes, and you don’t want to allow the bullies to keep you from seeing even one person you love, then call or send an email to the family member who’s hosting this year’s get-together. Verbalize your feelings. Tell them who has said hurtful things in the past. Name names. Let them know that if those relatives can’t behave differently this year, you won’t tolerate it and can’t come back. If they’re unable to assure you that everyone will treat you and your daughter with respect, then you may end up not having any relationship with them at all. And you can be okay with that.Limiting what you put up with.
Unfortunately, you’re not alone. Many parents and young adults struggle this time of year with the same range of emotion while trying to get through the holidays with homophobic relatives. In fact, local PFLAG chapter meetings the week before Christmas usually include a conversation on the topic of how to deal with homophobic relatives who say things at the dinner table that are hurtful to both the parent and the child. On the flip side, maybe you feel as if you’ve already tolerated all that you can from these relatives. Maybe they’re not really important in your life and you’re just ready to move on and create a new holiday tradition for yourselves. Think about inviting over friends who are alone for the holidays. Have a potluck supper. Sing carols. Play games. Enjoy each other’s company. Or maybe order in Chinese food and go to one of the movies opening on Christmas Day. The bottom line: Christmas is about you and your daughter, about surrounding yourselves with family and friends who care about you and respect you, whatever your differences. It is not about "getting through" the holidays with homophobic relatives. What's really important here is your own personal power. Which option makes you feel the best when you think about it? Which gives you the strongest feelings of relief and joy? Choose the option that’s going to bring you and your daughter the peace and happiness you deserve this holiday season. No matter how you celebrate, make it count for the two of you. IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “Holiday gift ideas for gender non-conforming kids.” “Gender issues at the North Pole.”December 22, 2015
- Even Einstein couldn't explain.
It is not every mom who can smile while reminiscing about her kid’s holiday projectile vomiting. I assure you that during those unfortunately timed episodes, my son Harry’s puke was about as humorous as the green slime Linda Blair spewed into the face of that cute priest in The Exorcist. But in hindsight, chuckling at the Science of Parenthood pie chart above, I can look back at how comical a few holiday barf sessions actually were.
EMERGENCY FLASHERS ON
“Okay, Andy, that’s enough,” I said, watching my adult nephew repeatedly toss nine-month-old Harry into the air above his head for a second before catching him. It was a few days into snowy January 1991. Harry’s dad Ken and I had taken two cars to dinner at his sister Shirley’s in the suburbs. [caption id="attachment_4209" align="aligncenter" width="487"] Harry, January 1991[/caption] I knew Andy was having fun seeing Harry laugh so hard with each release. But it was getting late, and I worried Harry would be too over-stimulated to sleep. I bundled him up in his striped snowsuit, and Ken buckled him into the car seat. The heater in my car hadn’t even warmed up before Harry started to cry uncontrollably. I turned on the overhead light only to see him squirming and screaming in the rear view mirror. With a 40-minute drive ahead of us, I decided to pull over onto the shoulder of the freeway. I put on my emergency flashers and pulled Harry out of the back seat. Wearing the blue fur coat I was sure my mother would have wanted me to buy with the money she left me, Harry started to upchuck. I quickly thrust out my arms, turned him over onto a gloved palm and let him empty his liquid mess onto the side of the highway, while I silently cursed Andy. Back in the car, contented Harry fell asleep. And I drove home both splatter free, quite pleased I had nothing to clean up.NOT ON MY BLANKET
“Harry wants to kiss you goodnight,” Ken said. It was Christmas 1995, and Ken’s sisters and I were finishing up kitchen duty. Harry was sitting on his top bunk when I crossed the threshold. “I threw up,” he said. “But not on my blanket.” I didn't move. If Harry hadn’t puked in his bed, where was it? My eyes darted to the periwinkle blue carpeting that now looked like a Jackson Pollack drip painting. Holy crap. “Are you okay, Honey?” I asked, overwhelmed by the stench and the urge to hurl myself. “Yeah, I feel fine,” he said, cheerfully. “Isn’t it good that I didn’t get any on my bed?” I was sure Harry remembered that the last time he barfed in bed I’d had to take all of covers down to the basement laundry sink. But he was in the bottom bunk then. “Yes, Thank you for being so considerate. But you know what? Now that you’re sleeping in the top bunk, it’s okay to throw up on your blanket.” [caption id="attachment_4213" align="aligncenter" width="340"] Harry, me & the toboggan, 1995[/caption]THE "'SCIENCE'
For these looks back, I have only Norine Sworkin-McDaniel and Jessica Ziegler to thank. Or blame. In their hilarious new book, Science of Parenthood: Thoroughly Unscientific Explanations for Utterly Baffling Parenting Situations, the writer-illustrator duo uses fake math and snarky science to examine the follies and frustrations of modern parenting. The book drills deep into the core sciences—biology (my fave section), chemistry, physics and mathematics—to provide tongue-in-cheek “explanations” for the ridiculous situations otherwise capable adults find themselves in as a result of birthing and caring for tiny humans. Blending their wit and brightly colored cartoons with flow charts, infographics and the kind of higher math typically seen only on physicists’ whiteboards, Science of Parenthood answers such mystifying questions as: * Why do children grow up so fast, yet Candy Land drags on so s-l-o-w-l-y? * Why must children sleep perpendicular to any adult lying down with them? * Seriously, how is it possible for one kid to lose so many thermoses? I can recommend Science of Parenthood as required reading for any parent who has despaired over no time to shower, little sleep or excavating their living room from layers of primary-colored plastic toys. As for me, mom of a grown-up kid, instead of stressing over a Hanukkah gift that UPS has yet to deliver for Harry or the blown fuse on a string Christmas tree lights, I just turn to a random page in Science of Parenthood for the chemical reaction of laughter.Anyone who thinks science is trying to make human life easier or more pleasant is utterly mistaken. ~Albert Einstein
IF YOU LIKED THIS POST YOU’LL PROBABLY ALSO LIKE THESE: “The year I said no to Kwanzaa & other holiday memories.” “My gender creative kid was creative with meaning.” “Whatever their gender identity, kids are funny. And not always on purpose.”December 11, 2015
- Just in time for the holidays: Mean parents & gay dogs.
[caption id="attachment_4164" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Harry & me on the last night of Hanukkah, 1998[/caption]
MOVE OVER SCROOGE
Clips circulated on social media this week from Jimmy Kimmel’s “I Gave My Kids a Terrible Christmas Present” video. I was stunned to learn Kimmel was a father. Because I couldn’t believe any dad would challenge parents to wrap up the worst gift possible. Think bag of onions, toilet brush, half-eaten sandwich. Then tell their young kids they could open that one gift a few weeks early, only to record their reactions. I don’t know about you, but encouraging viewers to betray their kids’ trust for a laugh borders on abuse, not humor. I felt some relief when I found out Kimmel issued that on-air challenge in 2011 because he’s had a daughter since then, and I can’t imagine he’d pull a trick like that on her. (Really, Jimmy?) I’d also like to think that the mom in the video who wrapped up a pink “girl's’” activity sticker book as the worst gift ever for her son has evolved since then. That is, right alongside Target in ditching the stereotyped gender labeling of toys. Whether kids conform to society’s boxes of pink and blue or creatively reject what colors, toys and clothes they’re “supposed” to like, I hope that parents, family, friends and Santa will remember that the best gift for a child is the one that